Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Live Streaming of Council Meeting
In the spirit of open, accessible and transparent government, this meeting of the Inner West Council is being streamed live on Council’s website. By speaking at a Council meeting, members of the public agree to being recorded and must ensure their speech to the Council is respectful and use appropriate language. A person who uses defamatory, discriminatory or offensive language may be exposed to liability for which Council takes no responsibility. Any part of this meeting that is held in closed session will not be recorded
Pre-Registration to Speak at Council Meetings
Members of the public must register by 2pm of the day of the Meeting to speak at Council Meetings. If you wish to register to speak please fill in a Register to Speak Form, available from the Inner West Council website, including:
Are there any rules for speaking at a Council Meeting?
The following rules apply when addressing a Council meeting:
What happens after I submit the form?
You will be contacted by Governance Staff to confirm your registration. If you indicated that you will speak online, you will be provided with a link to the online meeting. Your request will then be added to a list that is shown to the Chairperson on the night of the meeting.
Where Items are deferred, Council reserves the right to defer speakers until that Item is heard on the next occasion.
Accessibility
Inner West Council is committed to ensuring people with a disability have equal opportunity to take part in Council and Committee Meetings. At the Ashfield Council Chambers there is a hearing loop service available to assist persons with a hearing impairment. If you have any other access or disability related participation needs and wish to know more, call 9392 5657.
Persons in the public gallery are advised that under the Local Government Act 1993, a person may NOT record a Council meeting without the permission of Council.
Any persons found recording without authority will be expelled from the meeting.
“Record” includes the use of any form of audio, video and still camera equipment or mobile phone capable of recording speech.
An audio recording of this meeting will be taken for the purpose of verifying the accuracy of the minutes.
Statement of Ethical Obligations
The Mayor and Councillors are bound by the Oath/ Affirmation of Office made at the start of the Council term to undertake their civic duties in the best interests of the people of the Inner West Council and to faithfully and impartially carry out the functions, powers, authorities and discretions vested in them under the Local Government Act or any other Act, to the best of their skill and judgement.
It is also a requirement that the Mayor and Councillors disclose conflicts of interest in relation to items listed for consideration on the Agenda or which are considered at this meeting in accordance with Council’s Code of Conduct and Code of Meeting Practice.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
PRECIS |
VOLUME 1 of 4
1 Acknowledgement of Country
2 Apologies
3 Notice of Webcasting
4 Disclosures
of Interest (Section 451 of the Local Government Act
and Council’s Code of Conduct)
5 Moment of Quiet Contemplation
6 Confirmation of Minutes Page
Minutes of 9 May 2023 Council Meeting 7
7 Public Forum – Hearing from All Registered Speakers
8 Condolence Motions
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 1 Condolence Motion: Mrs Georgette Chedra 27
C0623(1) Item 2 Condolence Motion: John Ward 30
C0623(1) Item 3 Condolence Motion: Judy Finlason, Community and Environmental Champion 32
9 Mayoral Minutes
Nil at the time of printing.
10 Reports for Council Decision
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 4 Delivery Program 2022-26 (Year 2), Operational Plan and Budget 2023-24, Long Term Financial Plan 2023-33 – Outcomes of Public Exhibition 36
C0623(1) Item 5 Planning Proposal - Macarthur Parade Heritage Listing 508
VOLUME 2 of 4
C0623(1) Item 6 Future Special Entertainment Precincts 588
C0623(1) Item 7 Post Exhibition Report 1 - 13 Parramatta Road Annandale VPA 595
C0623(1) Item 8 Post Exhibition - Inner West Cycling Strategy and Action Plan 656
C0623(1) Item 9 Dulwich Hill Skate Park 818
C0623(1) Item 10 Marrickville Mosaics 822
C0623(1) Item 11 FOGO Service Update 825
C0623(1) Item 12 Henson Park - Public Private Partnership - Licences 884
C0623(1) Item 13 Leichhardt Oval Masterplan - Preliminary Concepts 893
C0623(1) Item 14 Local
Government Remuneration Tribunal - Determination
of Mayor and Councillor Fees 2023/2024 955
VOLUME 3 of 4
C0623(1) Item 15 Inner West Heritage Program 1004
VOLUME 4 of 4
C0623(1) Item 16 Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Minutes, Annual Report and EOI for new Independent member 1647
C0623(1) Item 17 Local Traffic Committee Meeting - 15 May 2023 1658
11 Reports for Noting
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 18 Planning Industry Professional Workshop Summary 1669
C0623(1) Item 19 Update report on the Implementation of the Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Act 2021 1695
C0623(1) Item 20 Camdenville Park upgrades and Peter Bulger Wetlands 1702
C0623(1) Item 21 Inner West Council Service Charter 1705
C0623(1) Item 22 Update on Town Halls 1726
C0623(1) Item 23 Investment Report at 31 May 2023 1728
C0623(1) Item 24 Updated Annual Disclosure of Interest Returns 2021-22 1752
12 Rescission Motions
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 25 Notice of Motion to Rescind: C0523(1) Item 7 Fishing along Foreshore Reserves - 9 May 2023 1768
13 Notices of Motion
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 26 Notice of Motion: Cycling Infrastructure Signage, Designation and Enforcement 1769
C0623(1) Item 27 Notice of Motion: Leading a Reform Agenda on Waste 1773
C0623(1) Item 28 Notice of Motion: Council to Display First Nations Map, State from the Heart and Torres Strait Flag in Council Chambers 1776
C0623(1) Item 29 Notice of Motion: Customer Service 1780
C0623(1) Item 30 Notice of Motion: Emergency Services Levy increase 1783
C0623(1) Item 31 Notice of Motion: Webcasts 1785
C0623(1) Item 32 Notice of Motion: Unoccupied Dwellings Rise by 35% 1787
C0623(1) Item 33 Notice of Motion: Support for Inner West organisations with anti-poverty and food relief programs 1790
C0623(1) Item 34 Notice of Motion: Making the Rainbow Tunnels Permanent 1793
C0623(1) Item 35 Notice of Motion: Balmain Road/Orange Grove crossing 1795
C0623(1) Item 36 Notice of Motion: Newtown Festival 1796
C0623(1) Item 37 Notice of Motion: Good Neighbour Policy 1798
C0623(1) Item 38 Notice of Motion: GreenWay Community Forum 2022/2023 Annual Report 1799
C0623(1) Item 39 Notice of Motion: Drag Story Time 1803
C0623(1) Item 40 Notice of Motion: Trial of Extended Hours at Henson Park 1804
C0623(1) Item 41 Notice of Motion: Hawthorne Canal Multipurpose Courts 1805
C0623(1) Item 42 Notice of Motion: Local Democracy Groups and Council Committees 1806
C0623(1) Item 43 Notice of Motion: Community Support for FIFA Women's World Cup 1808
C0623(1) Item 44 Notice of Motion: Cumulative effect of Additional Equipment for Telecom Towers 1809
C0623(1) Item 45 Notice of Motion: Henson Park Lighting 1810
14 Questions From Councillors
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 46 Question on Notice: Clontarf Cottage 1811
C0623(1) Item 47 Question on Notice: Update on Affordable Housing 1813
C0623(1) Item 48 Question on Notice: Dwelling Targets 1815
C0623(1) Item 49 Question on Notice: Quality of Pedestrian Crossings 1817
C0623(1) Item 50 Question on Notice: Council Flyer “We are about Respect” 1819
C0623(1) Item 51 Question on Notice: Aquatic Centres 1821
C0623(1) Item 52 Question on Notice: Fleet Transition 1822
15 Reports with Confidential Information
Reports appearing in this section of the Business Paper are confidential in their entirety or contain confidential information in attachments.
The confidential information has been circulated separately.
ITEM Page
C0623(1) Item 53 Update on the Acquisition of Investment Properties 1823
C0623(1) Item 54 Quarterly Strategic Investment Property Report 1824
C0623(1) Item 55 HJ Mahoney Memorial Park & Tempe Reserve Playing Surface Upgrades 1825
C0623(1) Item 56 Henson Park Development Agreement 1826
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Minutes of Ordinary Council Meeting held on 9 May 2023 at Ashfield Service Centre
Meeting commenced at 6.30 pm
Present: |
|
Philippa Scott Liz Atkins Marghanita Da Cruz Jessica D’Arienzo Mark Drury Dylan Griffiths Mathew Howard Justine Langford Pauline Lockie Chloe Smith John Stamolis Timothy Stephens Zoi Tsardoulias Simone Plummer |
Deputy Mayor (Chairperson) Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor Councillor General Manager Director Planning |
Ryann Midei |
Director Infrastructure |
Ruth Callaghan Kelly Loveridge Beau-Jane De Costa Aaron Callaghan Daryl Jackson Chris Sleiman Manod Wickramasinghe Ken Welsh David Paton Erin White Megan Jenkins |
Director Community Director Corporate Senior Manager Governance and Risk Parks Planning and Ecology Manager Chief Financial Officer Financial Partnering and Analytics Manager Traffic and Transport Planning Manager Team Leader Transport Planning Engineering Services Manager Manager Resource Recovery and Fleet Services Senior Lawyer |
Katherine Paixao |
Business Paper Coordinator |
APOLOGIES:
Motion: (D’Arienzo/Stephens)
That apologies from The Mayor, Councillor Byrne and Councillor Shetty be accepted.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
DISCLOSURES OF INTERESTS:
Councillor Howard declared a non-significant, non-pecuniary interest in Item 16 Local Traffic Committee Meeting – 17 April 2023 as he works in the Ministerial Office of the Minister for Transport, who in her capacity as the Member for Summer Hill has a representative on the Local Traffic Committee. He will remain in the meeting during discussion and voting as the vote of the State Member is exercised through a representative.
Motion: (D’Arienzo/Smith)
That Council note the disclosure of interest.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
Councillor Griffiths declared a non-significant, non-pecuniary interest in Item 16 Local Traffic Committee Meeting – 17 April 2023 as the traffic committee meeting discussed some proposed works on his street. He does not own the property. He will remain in the meeting during discussion and voting.
Motion: (Howard/Atkins)
That Council note the disclosure of interest.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
Councillor Drury declared a significant, pecuniary interest in Item 13 Dobroyd Canal and Hawthorne Canal Flood Risk Management Plan as his street is referred to as a hotspot. He will exit the chamber during discussion and voting of the item.
Motion: (Lockie/Langford)
That Council note the disclosure of interest.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES
That the Minutes of the Council Meeting held on Tuesday, 11 April 2023 and Extraordinary Council Meeting held on Tuesday, 18 April 2023 be confirmed as a correct record.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
PUBLIC FORUM
The registered speakers were asked to address the meeting. The list of speakers is available on the last page of these minutes.
Councillor Drury noted the passing of a Former Mayor of Ashfield, John Ward. He will submit a condolence motion to the next Council meeting.
Procedural Motion (Howard/Stephens)
That Council Suspend Standing Orders to bring forward the following items to be dealt with at this time:
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
Procedural Motion (Howard/Stephens)
That the following items be moved in globo and the recommendations contained within the report be adopted.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
C0523(1) Item 3
Marrickville Parklands and Golf Course-Priority Plan of |
1. That projects identified as capital development improvements with high community benefit and identified as Council’s responsibility be considered for funding over a seven-year period, and Government grant funding support be sought where applicable. 4. 2. That Council congratulates the Marrickville Golf, Sporting and Community Club on its commitment and action in developing an inclusive and welcoming community sporting club and importantly its hosting of a wide range of sporting and cultural events in 2023.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
C0523(1) Item 12 Arts and Music Recovery Final Plan for Endorsement |
Motion: (Howard/Stephens)
That Council endorse the Arts and Music Recovery Plan.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
Procedural Motion: (Smith/Stephens)
That Council allow Councillor Drury to speak for 1 additional minute on Item 1.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
C0523(1) Item 4 Preparation of a Draft Plan of Management - Hammond Park |
1. That Council publicly exhibit the Draft Plan of Management for Hammond Park for a period of 42 days and seeks public feedback on the proposed plan of management and master plan for the park. 10. 2. That following the conclusion of the exhibition period, the Park Plan of Management be brought back to Council for consideration for adoption.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil
Procedural Motion (Griffiths/Langford)
That the Da Cruz/Atkins amendment be voted on in seriatum.
Motion Lost For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, Griffiths, Langford and Stamolis Against Motion: Crs D'Arienzo, Drury, Howard, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Amendment (Da Cruz/Atkins) 1.
That Council undertake a Traffic Study
paying particular attention to Parking and Pedestrian and Cyclist safety,
also the provision of bicycle parking. 2.
That Council reduce the additional
hours allocated to organised sport on Sundays to a half day and consult the
Ashfield Pirates whether they would prefer Morning or Afternoon access to the
ground. 3.
That Council enable Ashfield Pirates to
continue to use their food trailer instead of a permanent Kiosk. 4.
That Council include the use of the
ground by Schools and Cricket Players. 5.
That Council investigate whether
traffic noise on the park. 6. That Council develop a strategy to manage the impact of sports training in the evenings. Motion Lost For Motion: Crs Atkins and Da Cruz Against Motion: Crs D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias |
That Council maintain current servicing and management of foreshore parks.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs D'Arienzo, Drury, Howard, Scott, Smith, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, Griffiths, Langford, Lockie and Stamolis |
Procedural Motion (Stephens/Howard)
That Council allow Councillor Smith to speak for 1 additional minute on Item 8.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
1. That Council adopt “Powering Ahead” - Electric Vehicle Encouragement Strategy (2023) as policy to inform its future implementation of initiatives to encourage electric vehicle uptake in the Inner West. 11. 2. That Council investigate ways to support residents who live in existing unit blocks in the LGA to install charging stations.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
1.
That Council adopt
FY 2030/31 as the interim target for the complete transition of the
Inner West Council fleet to Electric vehicles (EV). 2.
That Council
investigate and report back on opportunities to bring forward the target for
the complete transition of the Inner West Council fleet to EVs by the October
meeting of Council. 3.
That Council
commence the installation of charging infrastructure at Ashfield Service
Centre, Leichhardt Service Centre, and Leichhardt Depot, and investigate and
report back at the October meeting of Council on opportunities to maximise
charging infrastructure at Balmain and Summer Hill depots. 4.
That Council
initiate planning for the roll out of comprehensive EV charging at St Peters
Depot as part of the St Peters Depot Masterplan project. 5.
That Council
commence replacement of existing pool vehicles now with EV’s, where fit
for purpose and cost-effective models are available. 6.
That Council
commence a trial of heavy vehicle plant to understand the current operational
capacities of EV heavy vehicles and support their innovation. 7.
That Council be
updated on progress with the EV fleet transition through quarterly
operational plan reports. 8. That Council adjust the draft FY 2023/24 capital budget to include $740,000 for charging infrastructure at Ashfield Service Centre, Leichhardt Service Centre and Leichhardt Depot.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
Councillor Stephens left the Meeting at 8:41 pm.
1.
That Council
proceed on the development of designs for the Little Village gateway and
wayfinding signs in Petersham, Marrickville and Leichhardt. 2.
That work continue
on identifying locations for giant lettering signs for Little Greece and
Little Portugal. 3. That work continue regarding the design, fabrication and costs for giant lettering signs of Little Italy and Little Vietnam, and that this work include comprehensive consultation with the Leichardt and Marrickville resident and business communities, the Italian and Vietnamese communities through their community ethnic organisations, and that the consultation include options for locations of the signs.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil Absent: Cr Stephens |
Councillor Stephens returned to the Meeting at 8:43 pm.
Procedural Motion (Scott/Lockie)
That the meeting be adjourned for 10 minutes.
The meeting was adjourned at 8.51pm
The meeting recommenced at 9.02pm
Councillor Drury left the Meeting at 9:02pm as he declared a significant, pecuniary interest in Item 13 Dobroyd Canal and Hawthorne Canal Flood Risk Management Plan as his street is referred to as a hotspot.
Councillor Drury returned to the Meeting at 9:07 pm.
Procedural Motion (Scott/Stephens)
That Council allow Councillor Drury to speak for 2 additional minutes on Item 14.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
That the updated Inner West Council Investment Policy be adopted.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
That Council convenes a Renters Rights town hall to engage and consult with advocates on Council’s legislative and regulatory objectives in support of renters rights. The town hall should include representatives from tenant advocacy groups, social service and housing organisations, and invitations to be extended to the Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading, and the Minister for Housing. The town hall will be cofacilitated by Clr Smith and Clr Griffiths.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
That Council receive and note the report.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
C0523(1)
Item 28 Notice of Motion: Camdenville
Park upgrades and Peter Bulger |
1. That Council receive a report at the June council meeting about opportunities to bring forward and complete planned works as soon as possible given the delay of several years to works at Camdenville Park, St Peters, due to WestConnex.
2. That Council reaffirm its support for the establishment of the Peter Bulger Wetlands at Camdenville Park and request funding options for the wetlands be included as part of the June report.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
Procedural Motion (Howard/Griffiths)
That Council allow Councillor Smith to speak for 2 additional minutes on Item 29.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
That Council submit an Expression of Interest (EOI) application for the Commonwealth Government's Community Batteries Funding Round 1 before close of applications on 30 June 2023, and that Council explore opportunities to partner with Ausgrid as part of the EOI application.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
1. That Council affirm its commitment to the Good Neighbour Policy as the best way to mediate and support both the amenity of residents and the commercial viability of local pubs, clubs and licensed venues. 25. 2. That Council write to all businesses in the LGA where the policy may be relevant to inform them of the policy.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Cr Stamolis |
Motion: Howard/D’Arienzo)
That Council enter into Confidential session.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
Confidential Session
That in accordance with Section 10A(1) of the Local Government Act 1993, the following matters be considered in Closed Session of Council for the reasons provided:
C0523(1) Item 39 Update on the Acquisition of Investment Properties (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business and (Section 10A(2)(d)(ii) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council.
C0523(1) Item 40 Deed of Agreement (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business and (Section 10A(2)(d)(ii) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council.
C0523(1) Item 41 Tender Recommendation for RFT 04-22-2 Electrical Contractors Panel (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business
Motion: (D’Arienzo/Howard)
That Council move back into the Open Session of the Council Meeting.
Motion Carried
For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias
Against Motion: Nil
resolutions passed during closed session
That Council authorises the General Manager or delegate to negotiate a deed as detailed in the Confidential Report in Attachment 1 and authorises the General Manager to execute the agreed deed.
Motion Carried For Motion: Crs Atkins, Da Cruz, D'Arienzo, Drury, Griffiths, Howard, Langford, Lockie, Scott, Smith, Stamolis, Stephens and Tsardoulias Against Motion: Nil |
Meeting closed at 10.35pm.
Public Speakers:
Item #
|
Speaker |
Suburb |
Item 3: |
Andrew Tighe |
Marrickville |
Item 4: |
Yaying Dong Nick Kambounias Jean Kouriel Josephine Pinto Annette Alexander Rob Honeybrook Claudia Martinoris |
Ashfield Earlwood Marrickville Ashfield Ashfield Ashfield Ashfield |
Item 6: |
Luke Wright |
Leichhardt |
Item 7: |
Annette Hartmann |
Balmain East |
Item 8: |
Tim Hand Stan Baker |
Balmain Balmain |
Item 11: |
Mark Skelsey |
Dulwich Hill |
Item 29: |
Dr Margaret Vickers |
Balmain |
Item 32: |
Justin Simon |
Summer Hill |
Item 42: |
Ray Stevens Mat Wilk |
Balmain Rozelle |
Unconfirmed minutes of the Ordinary Council meeting held on 9 May 2023.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Condolence Motion: Mrs Georgette Chedra
From: Councillor Marghanita Da Cruz
MOTION
1. That Council write to the family of Mrs. Chedra to express its condolences.
2. That Council plant a tree in her honour with a location to be determined in consultation with her family and put a plaque on a bench in her honour with words to be determined in consultation with her family. |
Background
Mrs Georgette Chedra (1937 – 2023) was a true and constant champion in the Leichhardt community for the rights of people with mental illnesses.
Mrs Chedra was born in the Lebanon into an Antioch Orthodox Community. She migrated with her husband and three children in 1968. After arriving in Australia, Mrs Chedra had two more children. The family came to live in Catherine St, Leichhardt in 1969. Then a considerably poorer and more dangerous neighbourhood than it is today.
As her Children grew and attended Leichhardt Primary and then Secondary school, Mrs Chedra rallied for school improvements, including the oval at Leichardt High. Her son recalls attending the Leichhardt Greek Orthodox Church to learn Greek and serving as an Altar boy at Catholic St Fiacre’s. Mrs Chedra’s funeral was streamed from Leichhardt Anglican Church (across the road from the Town Hall).
Mrs Chedra was an inadvertent Carer for two of her close family members with mental illness for several decades which impacted her personal health in many ways. She constantly sacrificed her own needs for the ongoing care of her family members and their children and that is what lead her to campaign for the rights and needs of those with mental health issues in her later years.
In 2006, on a bus trip to remind COAG (Council of Australian Governments), meeting in Canberra she found allies in the Friends of Callan Park movement and rallied under the Save Rozelle Psychiatric Hospital. In 2016, the Friends of Callan Park recognised Georgette with a Certificate of Appreciation in recognition of her enduring commitment to, and advocacy for mental health services at Callan Park and Broughton Hall. Mrs Chedra was proud to have me Governor Professor Marie Bashir with whom she shared an understanding of Mental Health and origins in Lebanon.
Mrs Chedra would confront Federal, State and Local Politicians or Councillors with hard questions - she was never afraid to speak up for what she thought was right and just, to help those less fortunate. Wherever she went she took a trolley of papers – documents, petitions and flyers to further her cause.
Well known at Leichhardt Council, one evening she arrived at the Council Chamber to find the debate on Callan Park closed and a break called before she had time to speak. Most of the Councillors had traipsed out to the supper room when unabashed Mrs Chedra strode up the Open Council Chamber, raised her pile of papers and brought them down with a mighty bang drew everyone’s attention.
After the amalgamation access to Ashfield was impossible for the aging Mrs Chedra. Her participation in Council Meetings, Committees and Activities were terminated. However, Mrs Chedra did not miss an opportunity to speak about Mental Health and Housing issues.
One cold winter’s evening, in 2021, she came across a gathering for the launch of “Little Italy” at Leichhardt Town Hall. Seizing the opportunity, she pushed her walker (which had now replaced her Trolley) forward and addressed the crowd on the plight of the mentally ill homeless.
Mrs Chedra also faced the challenge of resolving errors in her Rate charges with the amalgamated Council. The task was made more difficult when the Council insisted on contacting the 85 year old via email and texts through intermediaries.
Mrs Chedra displayed a strong awareness of the political landscape and would often phone friends to discuss local, state and federal candidates and issues – to inform her vote. Mrs Chedra would tackle representatives, at local council, state and federal government level, asking challenging questions and demanding answers in her polite way.
Whatever her private fears, Mrs Chedra demonstrated much courage in speaking up publicly and frequently to a range of decision-makers about the injustices in the treatment of those with mental illness, in her third language, after Arabic and French.
Mrs Chedra had many health problems of her own over the years some involved hospitalisation. Yet her stoicism saw her continually re-emerge to support and find help for members of her family.
Mrs Chedra seemed indefatigable and indestructible. But now she has left us and is at peace. We will greatly miss her presence and quiet determination, but she remains an inspiration.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Condolence Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Condolence Motion: John Ward
From: Councillor Mark Drury
MOTION
That Council write a letter of condolence to the family of John Ward.
|
Background
John Ward was a person who tirelessly served to make a difference to our community. In 1977, he was elected as an Alderman, as they were then called, to represent the East Ward of Ashfield Municipal Council (that is, Summer Hill and parts of Ashfield.) He served on Council for eighteen years, until 1995 and was Mayor of Ashfield from 1991 until 1995.
John was motivated to stand for election, in part, because of the large scale demolition of historic buildings, the unchecked destruction of heritage which occurred in the post war decades, in the Municipality, the surrounding suburbs and the city. Many of the buildings which form part of the contemporary heritage register have survived because of John Ward’s agitation, for example, working with Jack Mundey and the builders Labourers’ Federation, who combined with residents to Green Ban the demolition of local buildings. In 1973, John was also instrumental in forming the Ashfield and District Historical Society which will celebrate its fiftieth anniversary in June 2023. The Society is still a significant community voice and chronicler of local history, with a membership of approximately 200.
He was a life member of both the Ashfield and District Historical Society and the Haberfield Association, having always supported the listing of the Haberfield Heritage Conservation Area on the state register and the establishment of other HCA’s listed in the current Local Environment Plan.
John ward was a progressive community representative and leader, a defender of left wing politics at all levels of government. He was a generous supporter of those who earned his respect and for causes that he considered to be for the betterment of the social good. He was instrumental in establishing parklands along Hawthorne canal and, in co-operation with Leichhardt Council, tree planting programs along the railway embankments and walking and cycling paths adjacent to the canal, now part of the GreenWay. John gave up his last car, a clapped out VW Beetle (which he called the blue beast or the rocket) decades ago and, until recently, could be seen cycling through local streets. He looked after locals, especially long term older residents he termed ‘the venerables’.
An imaginative and prolific historian, John was a world renowned scholar, a foremost international authority in his field, publishing many highly regarded books and essays. A Lecturer and Reader in Medieval History at the University of Sydney, he was a much beloved teacher, a wonderfully engaging lecturer, a great wit and raconteur. His humour was notable and sophisticated. He was renowned for occasional appearances in historically authentic mediaeval papal regalia, delivering satiric dissertations and sermons from the Juliet balcony of the Ward family terrace.
Perhaps ironically, John loved the Blues Brothers film and would attend midnight sessions when it showed in the city with his son. He loved trains, travelling far with his life partner Gail and his children to ride in steam engines. At his funeral, mourners joined in to sing a rambling rendition of Abba’s Fernando, a favourite of John’s which he often sang and hummed about the house. He would have laughed.
Vale John Ward, beloved husband for 60 years of Gail. Much loved father of Hilton, Tara, and Kate. Adored Grandpa of Marcel, Gabriel, and Jessie. Treasured father-in-law of Dina, Walter, and Toby.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Condolence Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Condolence Motion: Judy Finlason, Community and Environmental Champion
From: Councillor Justine Langford
MOTION
1. That Council note the recent passing of local resident, Judy Finlason, community and environmental champion.
2. That Council plant a tree in her memory.
|
Background
Judy was key in the development of Addison Road Community Centre and securing the
original funds for Reverse Garbage in Marrickville. Judy set up Kids Activities Newtown (KAN) and The Magic Yellow Bus.
Judy’s skills at bringing together and involving the community significantly contributed to the successful preservation of Wolli Creek, a contribution she continued for the rest of her life.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
1.⇩ |
Judy Finlason Obituary |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Delivery Program 2022-26 (Year 2), Operational Plan and Budget 2023-24, Long Term Financial Plan 2023-33 – Outcomes of Public Exhibition
Prepared By: Daryl
Jackson - Chief Financial Officer, Prue Foreman - Corporate
Strategy and Engagement Manager and
Kathryn Parker - Team Leader Corporate Strategy
Authorised By: Ruth Callaghan - Director Community
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council note the outcome of the public exhibition of
Council’s Integrated Planning and Reporting documents as required by
the Local Government Act 1993; 2. That Council adopt the following documents with the proposed changes arising from the public exhibition as outlined in the report and attachments: a) Revised Delivery Program 2022-26 (year 2),
Operational Plan and Budget 2023/2024 (including Fees and Charges 2023/2024); b) Revised Long Term Financial Plan 2023-2033
(Scenario 1 – Business as Usual); and c) Amendment to the adopted Residential and Business - General Rates Harmonisation transition timeline, for 100% transition from 1 July 2023, instead of ending July 2029.
3. That Council note the package of Service Statements that have been developed to provide a succinct description of every service, including activities undertaken, actions and KPIs, levels of service where relevant and budget.
4. That Council publish the final documents on its corporate website by 30 June 2023 and notify the Office of Local Government of the link to its web page.
|
DISCUSSION
Background - Integrated Planning and Reporting
Under the Local Government Act, NSW councils are required to develop a suite of plans as part of the ‘Integrated Planning and Reporting Framework’ (IP&R). IP&R is a rigorous and consistent system of community planning across all NSW local councils which also takes into consideration state and regional priorities.
IP&R assists councils in delivering their community’s vision through long, medium and short-term plans.
Each year Council must review the fixed four-year Delivery Program, develop a new annual Operational Plan and update the Long Term Financial Plan so that it forecasts 10 years ahead. All the draft plans must be publicly exhibited for a minimum of 28 days prior to adoption by Council.
Council resolved at its April 2023 meeting (C0423(1) Item 1):
1. That Council place on public exhibition for a period of 28 days the:
a) draft Delivery Program 2022-26 (year 2), Operational Plan and Budget 2023-2024 (including fees and charges 2023-2024);
b) draft Long Term Financial Plan 2023/2033; and
c) Amendment to the adopted Residential and Business - General Rates Harmonisation transition timeline, for 100% transition from 1 July 2023, instead of ending July 2029.
2. That Council receive a report of the public exhibition outcomes at the June 2023 Council meeting.
The draft documents were publicly exhibited from Monday 17 April – Friday 19 May 2023. The community was invited to provide submissions by mail, email, phone, or online.
The public exhibition was promoted by:
· Inner West Council News – April edition
· Inner West Council E-news
· Web announcement
· Your Say Inner West project page
· Your Say Inner West E-news
· Social Media
· Budget explainer video
The draft documents were available for the community to view in hard copy at:
· Council’s Service Centres – Ashfield, Leichhardt and Petersham
· Council’s Libraries – Balmain, Haberfield, Marrickville and St Peters
· Online at Council’s online engagement website (yoursay.innerwest.nsw.gov.au)
Public Exhibition Outcomes
During the public exhibition, the Your Say Inner West online project page received a total of 1,542 views, 982 visits, and 11 online contributions were submitted, one of which was a petition with 106 signatories. The feedback received from the public is provided in detail below and includes comment from Council officers.
Your Say Inner West Online Results
During the public exhibition draft documents could be viewed ‘magazine-style’ or downloaded. The number of downloads is as follows:
· Budget video explainer (272 views)
· Draft Delivery Program, Operational Plan and Budget (84 downloads)
· Draft Fees and Charges (25 downloads)
· Draft Long Term Financial Plan (25 downloads)
· Rates Map (18 downloads)
Overview of Online Contributions
Respondents were asked whether they supported each of the draft documents (optional question) and whether they would like to comment. Of the eleven online contributions, the following indications of support were received.
1. Draft Delivery Program, Operational Plan and Budget
· Yes 4
· No 4
· Unsure 1
2. Draft Fees and Charges
· Yes 3
· No 4
· Unsure 1
3. Draft Long Term Financial Plan
· Yes 4
· No 4
· Unsure 0
Submissions
The eleven online submissions (including a petition) received from the community during the public exhibition are shown in the below table along with officer responses. No changes are proposed to the draft plans arising from community submissions.
No. |
Public Submission / Council Response |
1
|
Public Submission 1. Ensure sufficient staff resources to plan ahead for future projects and secure state government funding, especially for cycleway projects to connect the bike network and to ensure safe routes to schools 2. Include and prioritise e-bike fleet and supporting measures in the sustainable fleet plan (action 1.5.1.1) and electric vehicle encouragement plan (action 1.4.2.1) 3. Update the planning controls to remove parking minimums in locations with excellent access to public transport 4. Investigate extending the number of public space amenity and safety projects more quickly, by using temporary or interim materials initially until full streetscape upgrade funds can be available, and by using the new TfNSW Temporary Delegation to cut red tape 5. Increase the frequency of bike counting for more timely and useful data to measure progress against the target 6. Add operational plan actions, and attendant budget, for addressing the Councillor priority of supporting safe walking around 15 schools (or, provide an update on how this is going) 7. Include walking and cycling access plans, and addition of plentiful, well-located bike racks in place-based town centre planning, and plans for council facilities 8. Include walking and cycling in other council plans and strategies being developed this coming financial year. |
1 |
Council Response Council is committed to developing safe cycling options for the community. Specifically, there is $2.5 million allocated in the 2023/24 budget for bicycle facilities, and a capital works program of $15.4 million to be spent on cycleway projects over the next four years. Additional grants are also regularly sought to ensure adequate funding for planned projects and to supplement council funds. Action 2.6.1.1 includes the preparation of the Council's Bicycle Strategy and Action Plan that will improve cycle routes including bike racks that support active transport and cycling opportunities.
Specific capital projects planned include: • The development and expansion of the cycling network (Action 2.6.1.3) along the GreenWay project. There is approximately $27.6 million planned to be spent in 2023/24 and $10.6 million 2024/25 on missing links including cycleways • Action 2.6.1.5 includes the delivery of the Pyrmont Bridge Road Cycleway, and $398,000 is allocated for the Lilyfield Road cycleway project • Action 2.6.1.6 includes the delivery of the Pedestrian Access and Mobility Plan (PAMP). A total budget of $8 million has been allocated to complete high-priority works identified in the PAMP over four years commencing 2022/23.
Council adopted the PAMP in November 2021, which identifies pedestrian safety improvement priorities for the Inner West, including pedestrian routes around schools. To date, 13 raised pedestrian crossings near schools have been completed. Council prioritises safe walking around local schools through Action 2.6.1.2 "Support safe walking around local school" in the 2023/24 Operational Plan. This is also a Councillor priority.
Council also plans to monitor and count the number of people using the Inner West bicycle networks in 2023/24. Additionally, a sustainable fleet (Action 1.5.1.1) and an Electric Vehicle Encouragement Plan (Action 1.4.2.1) are priorities in 2023/24, with plans to build 12 electric vehicle charging units for the Inner West community. An electric vehicle engagement strategy was adopted by Council on 9 May 2023. Council will be reviewing its planning controls as part of the Development Control Plan for parking and the Inner West Parking Strategy which are currently under development. |
2 |
Public Submission (1) Generally supportive of the plans (2023OPDP). Definitely think more could be done to improve the streetscapes and livability of run-down areas like Ashfield. It would be great to see the roadmap for all town centre master plans focussed on the areas that need to most uplift first (2) Yes - just harmonise the rates and get on with it. Council could do more to promote this idea a bit better. It needs a comprehensive campaign around equity that is supported by the councillors.
|
2 |
Council Response 1. In the 2023/24 budget, $4.2 million is allocated to Main Street Revitalisation and Main Street Placemaking, with an additional $4.5 million to be spent in 2024/25. This is being coordinated with local businesses. A range of town centre masterplans are also currently being prepared including out-door dining pop-ups, parklets, lane closures, banners and street furniture artwork.
2. Council is harmonising rates as required by the State Government. This means that the three former rating structures from the former Ashfield, Leichhardt and Marrickville councils will become a single rating structure, and this is planned to take place during the 2023/24 financial year.
|
3
|
Public Submission (1) Agree that Harmonisation of rates should happen immediately; it is not fair to harmonise services across council but allow certain former LGA ratepayers to pay far high rates than other areas (2) Though not really sure why we'd want to create such a large surplus over time - should be spent back within council to improve services and facilities for residents.
|
3 |
Council Response 1. Council is harmonising rates as required by the State Government. This means that the three former rating structures from the former Ashfield, Leichhardt and Marrickville Councils will become a single rating structure. This is planned to take place during the 2023/24 financial year. The harmonisation process does not increase Council’s overall income from rates. However, harmonisation means that the specific rates paid by individual rate payers may change. Some ratepayers will pay less and some will pay more as rates are calculated according the Valuer General’s assessment of the land value, and subject to a minimum rate peg of 3.7% as provided by IPART. 2. Council's 2023/24 Budget has been built on the premise that existing service levels will be maintained and developed in tandem with the Delivery Program 2022-26 year 2. It is important for Council’s financial position to be positive over the Long Term Financial Plan to enable Council to deliver new capital works in the coming years. Council will continue to improve its operating position so that new capital works can be delivered.
|
4 |
Public Submission (1) I do not support the plan to accelerate the process to "harmonise" (ie: increase) council rates for the previous Marrickville Council area, namely Stanmore. I didn't ask to be merged, our vote was ignored by the current council, and now there's a proposal to bring forward the rates increase. I absolutely do not support this proposal (2) I do not believe there is value for money from the Inner West Council and therefore do not propose any increase in fees and charges until there is a noticeable improvement across the board (3) I do not support the plan to accelerate the process to "harmonise" (ie: increase) council rates for the previous Marrickville Council area.
|
4 |
Response 1. Council is harmonising rates as required by the State Government as explained in previous submission responses (refer to 2 and 3 above). 2. Council increases its fees for the services it provides to cover general movements in costs each year. Statutory fees have been increased in accordance with advice given by the relevant statutory body while discretionary fees have been increased by CPI. The CPI for 2023/24 is 7%.
|
5 |
Petition with 106 signatories A request to extend Community access to FANNY DURACK POOL.
|
5 |
Council Response Council previously trialled extending the Fanny Durack Aquatic Centre (FDAC) season in 2016/17 and again in 2019, both of which concluded that the extension was not financially viable.
In the 2016/17 financial year, Council undertook a formal trial of an extension of the swimming season to include April. The evaluation found there was very limited attendance, with 1588 swimmers (representing operating losses of $46k) during the April period.
The table below demonstrates impact of colder weather for the April period in 2016/17.
Month Council subsidy per attendee ($) Oct 2016 4.07 Nov 2016 4.02 Dec 2016 2.55 Jan 2017 2.11 Feb 2017 3.29 Mar 2017 11.69 Apr 2017 29.23
The review resulted in the season extension not being continued due to high costs and limited attendances. Operating in April was considered unviable, as it did not represent reasonable value to the majority of Inner West ratepayers.
In 2019, Council again undertook an extended season for the FDAC during the closure period for the AAC. In this period, attendance was again approximately 1600 visits with an estimated 800 paying visits in the month of April in line with 2016/2017 visitation and operating costs.
Current projections in 2024 for an additional month of operation under Council management would result in a direct unbudgeted operating cost of $47k with similar visitation as listed above. In this regard, the further unbudgeted cost of $47k for an extension of the FDAC swimming season for minimal attendance remains unviable.
It is noteworthy to add that the year-round operation of the indoor Annette Kellerman Aquatic Centre, the Leichhardt Park Aquatic Centre and Ashfield Aquatic Centre featuring both indoor and outdoor heated pools provides alternative locations all within a short travel time for residents to continue to swim within the Inner West.
|
6 |
Public Submission iwc YE24 budget submission dear council and councillors page numbers relate to 11apr23 meeting agenda paper containing the draft budget actions (p28) most of the actions in the YE24 draft are a backlog from past years (110 of 174) with 64 new actions added -a review of the the budget should focus on catching up the backlog of actions before new actions are included fees and charges - development assessment i note that the costs of pre-development and other development (ex-heritage) advice is not fully recouped but is category B "Partial Cost Recovery ... recognising the community benefit it provides" -the mar23 monthly report for development assessment has a budget deficit to year end of $2.3m being almost all of the difference between fees income $4.5m and staff costs $6.4m -this draft budget has deficits YE24 $3.45m YE25 $3.55m YE27 $3.62m YE27 $3.71m -a review of these fees is necessary as ever increasing costs must be covered for this service as contrary to iwc's statement that it is of community benefit it is benefiting only a tiny % of the community each year fees and charges - events the annual cost of staff in the mar23 monthly report is projected to be $658k and materials and contracts of $868k with a total income for the year of $99k making a deficit of $1.4m yet the fees schedule shows that not one item recovers costs not even for business categories -money is made from these activities so these fees must be reviewed to reflect at least recouping costs backlogs the introduction to the draft budget (p36) describes the two scenarios costed in the LTFPs. scenario one states "maintaining the capital works program to ensure infrastructure is renewed or upgraded over the 10 years" scenario two states "a process to reduce the infrastructure backlog of $20.7m from the 2021/22 financial statements over the course of the LTFP" resulting in a deficit by YE27. -neither scenario plans to 'catch up' the backlogs and scenario two includes a loan not mentioned in the introduction nor in the loan borrowings section (1.0.2) which is a lack of transparency -the backlog calculation was changed in YE22 resulting in a reduction in costing backlogs from $132m in YE21 to $21m in YE22. the change was to cost backlogs - assets in condition 4 and 5 at 20% and 50% of gross replacement cost respectively which means that iwc now only budgets to patch assets to condition 3 - satisfactory. condition 4 and 5 assets are failing or failed so patching instead of renewal is not a good LTFP nor is it appropriate asset management. -for consistency - the backlog amount in YE22 using the renewal calculation iwc used from YE17 to YE21 is $107m. -neither scenarios in the YE24 draft budget appropriately addresses the backlogs and should be reverted back to costing renewal or replacement of failing or failed assets -capex should preference backlogs before new infrastructure and before upgrading condition 1-3 assets -no loans or deficit will occur if iwc responsibly allocates spending income iwc has failed to declare in the draft budget data that it had an additional special variation (ASV) approved estimated by IPART to be worth $4.6m from YE23 to YE27. this amount is the majority of the supposed surpluses from YE25 to YE27 of $6.2m which would negate iwc's claim to IPART to be in financial need IPART - "Our decision means the council can increase income by 0.7% above the rate peg. We estimate this to be around $0.89million in additional income in 2022-23 which it can keep in its rate base going forward. This allows the council an extra $4.6 million over the next 5 years.The impact on rates from this ASV may be different for individual ratepayers and across different ratepayer categories. The ASV represents an allowed increase in general permissible income, the council decides how it collects that income from ratepayers." "Inner West Council resolved on 12 April 2022 to apply for a permanent special variation under section 508(2) of the Act.The council estimated it would receive around $0.88million of additional income in 2022-23. The council stated that the special variation is required to meet the council’s obligations as identified in its LTFP and delivery programs. The council stated that it considered the impact on ratepayers to be reasonable." "Inner West Council’s 2021-22 LTFP forecast an average Operating Performance Ratio (OPR) of 0.6% over 2022-23 to 2026-27. An average OPR at or below 2.0% over the next 5 years demonstrates financial need" https://www.ipart.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/cm9_documents/LG-Determination-Inner-West-Council-Additional-special-variation-application-2022-23-June-2022.PDF it is a worry that iwc applied the government to increase rates above the rate peg crying poor then tell the community that it is in surplus for years to come the below is from the YE24 draft budget on exhibition the YE23 Q3 review projects an operating deficit of $2,247k - the adopted budget projected a deficit of $744k - the $.88m increase in rate income above the peg from the ASV would have covered this deficit and put us into surplus for YE23 - the $1.5m increase in deficit seems to be mostly a result of rising costs for contracts and tenders (see Q review comments by staff) - iwc must not sign contracts that are not fixed costs and must review budget projections to more accurately reflect the reality of the market -iwc should not commit to budgets that are unrealistic and too costly - eg $1m toilet blocks - especially when the backlogs are not caught up employee costs Amalgamation was supposed to deliver significant savings in employee costs. This has not happened. In fact costs as a % of total expenditure has increased and is increasing still to 54.2% over the LTFP. Not even a huge council like the city of sydney council has such high employee costs as a % of total expenditure being 38.76% in YE22 rising to 41.23% over their 10 year LTFP. This is a significant difference and the reason for such increases in iwc costs should not only be explained in detail but be reviewed prior to the commencement of the financial YE24. -the variances between YE23 and YE24 presented in the YE24 draft exhibited schedule needs to be re-examined -one eg employee costs variance in YE24 stated is $3.26m increase (excluding work brought inhouse) -the adopted budget for YE23 was $127.2m (confirmed in the mar23 monthly report) - the YE24 proposed is $136.38m which is an increase of $9.18m not $3.27m as stated -even a 4% increase on YE23 costs comes up $822k short of the stated variance -the comment beside this adjustment includes "and other adjustments" - this requires explanation the YE21 budget had the below increases the YE22 budget had the below increase the YE24 draft budget has -however the nsw government states "Increases to remuneration of up to 3.0 per cent per annum are available for FY2022-23 and for FY2023-24, reverting to increases of up to 2.5 per cent per annum for FY2024-25 and following years." https://arp.nsw.gov.au/m2022-05-nsw-public-sector-wages-policy-2022 -iwc must not implement 4% increases from YE24 to YE28 and follow government guidelines of increases of 2.5% from YE25 onwards in the LTFP -these increases are a maximum not a minimum and should not be automatically allocated ie not based on merit
asset backlogs I disagree with council's statement that it will continue to maintain a high renewal of infrastructure -council has reduced its backlog calculation from renewal to patching condition 4 (poor) & 5 (failed or failing) assets to condition 3 (satisfactory) -condition 4 assets are now calculated at 20% of renewal value -condition 5 assets are now calculated at 50% of renewal value
we went from $142m backlog to $21m backlog in YE22 using this amended calculation -and we dont even spend all of the 20% or 50% at that the draft budget has the need for a $10.8m loan to catch up backlogs in YE27 demonstrating iwc can not keep our assets maintained to even a satisfactory level. Scenario 2 in the draft budget which is supposed to focus on backlogs does not record an increase in borrowing costs from YE27 so i do not see a loan reflected in the data. backlogs must be caught up from our existing funds and at the renewal rate not just patched to condition 3 being just satisfactory - no loan should be necessary i am sending you my submission on the YE24 draft budget in the hope that councillors will be appropriately informed and act responsibly -i am protesting the yoursay surveys format and requirements - it should not be necessary to have a digital account with iwc to participate so i am sending this to councillors and the staff member responsible for the yoursay survey so that my submission is included in the responses i rely on councillors to improve iwc's financial management and not just invisibly raise rates above the peg to fund budget excesses
|
6 |
Council Response 1. Council's Operational Plan 2023/24 includes multi-year projects that continue across subsequent Operational Plans. 2. Fees and charges (Development Assessment) - The pre-development and other development is partially cost recovered and the fees for the service are benchmarked against other councils which offer a similar service. The fees are to be increased by 7% this year to align with CPI. 3. Fees and charges (Events) - Council events are run to support the community and local businesses, where a need is determined. Fee and charges at events recoup costs where possible particularly around the provision of infrastructure but also balance the need to ensure that facilities can be accessed by all the community. 4. Backlog - Under Scenario 1, Council is below the 2% benchmark of backlog for the 10 year Long Term Financial Plan (LTFP). Council is ensuring to that the backlog does not increase and continue to focus on renewal of assets. 5. Income (IPART Increase) - In March 2022, IPART offered a one time opportunity for Councils to re-establish the rate peg that was reflected in the 2021/22 LTFP. This was due to the significant financial stress that all Councils in NSW faced with the original announced rate peg. The methodology originally used by IPART in 2022/23 has not been applied in the calculation of the rate peg for 2023/24. 6. Income (Further Response Regarding Rate Peg) - Prior to the rate peg increase for 2022/23, the budgeted deficit was $1.6m. Council fully allocated the $0.9m towards the deficit in 2022/23, reducing to $0.7m. 7. Employee costs - Council does not determine the award for salary and wages. This is an agreement between the Unions and Office of Local Government. Once the award is determined, this is applicable to all councils in NSW. Council will reflect this amount once the agreement is finalised. For now, Council has applied a 4.5% award increase for 2023/24 Financial Year. 8. Asset Backlogs - Please refer to response under point 4 - backlog.
|
7
|
Public Submission In support of Addison Rd bike route. Hoping this means a cycleway as I ride that route frequently and don't feel it is particularly safe. Would like to see the funding pulled into FY24 rather than FY25/26.
|
7 |
Council Response Council has scheduled capital works on the bike route along Addison Road, Enmore Park to Livingstone Road in 2024/25 ($500,000), and 2025/26 ($1 million). Due to other priority capital works projects, these works will take place in the 2024/25 year.
|
8 |
Public Submission (1) Not nearly enough emphasis on the 'Getting the basics
right' component. This is an area that is lacking currently and there is a
big backlog to fix in the neglected parts of the inner west things such as
more regular mowing and street cleaning, better verge and streetscape
beautification, maintenance and improvement of footpaths, more public bins
etc, especially in neglected areas of Inner West such as the Marrickville
Ward.
|
8 |
Council Response 1. Council has a strong focus on getting the basics right, including footpath maintenance, mowing and street cleaning, and streetscape beautification through Council's Main Street Strategy. An audit of the roads and footpaths was completed last year and has played an important part in setting the program for maintenance and renewal. Council is spending $8 million over 4 years to implement all high priority items from our Pedestrian Access Mobility Plan, aimed at improving accessibility across our footpath networks. An additional $7 million is being spent on footpath repairs and renewals across 2022/23 and 2023/24 and a new reporting system was recently implemented to facilitate a proactive approach to maintenance of all road, footpath, park and building infrastructure. 2. Harmonisation of rates is required by the NSW Government. Refer to Council response to community submissions 2 and 3 on this issue. 3. Council reviews proposals for new locations of public bins from residents as well as our staff. We are currently completing trials with new technology in some of our parks through a litter prevention education campaign. 4. Council is currently in the process of developing a Customer Experience Strategy that will improve and expand technologies to enable more effective customer service for the community. Council has recently launched the new Service Charter that reflects Council's commitment to providing service excellence. This charter was developed through extensive consultation with the community 5. Path lighting was installed on the Cooks River shared path at Steel Park (Illawarra Road to Thornley Street) in 2019. Path lighting through Warren Park between Steel Park and Mackey Park was extensively investigated and found to not be feasible due to the constraints of multiple major utilities in this area. A plan of management and masterplan is currently being prepared for Mackey Park which will inform future capital works program priorities, including path lighting. 6. Council holds regular local matters forums in each ward across the Inner West where community members can discuss issues and ideas with ward councillors and executive staff. 7. Pages 6-7 summarises the Community Strategic Plan on a page, while pages 18-22 include major projects and initiatives, a budget summary and capital project highlights for the 2023/24 year.
|
9 |
Public Submission (1) Residents voted overwhelmingly last year to de-amalgamate. This program ignores this fact (2) 7% seems a lot, considering the years that follow are almost half that amount. Plus, again, residents voted overwhelmingly last year to de-amalgamate. This program ignores this fact (3) If it depends on the proposed huge rate increase in the next financial year for former Marrickville Council residents, instead of the increase being spread out over eight years as originally promised, then services should exponentially improve too. Since amalgamation they have dropped off noticeably, and although it's great for the Mayor to have big ideas about turning Enmore Rd into an entertainment theme park, unless the plan is to drive out existing residents, then we expect services to come up to par. Plus, again, residents voted overwhelmingly last year to de-amalgamate. This program ignores this fact.
|
9 |
Council Response 1. The NSW Government formed Inner West Council in 2016 by bringing together Ashfield, Leichhardt and Marrickville Councils. In December 2021, a non-binding poll was conducted in which the Inner West community voted to de-amalgamate the existing Council and return to the three former Councils. The result was carried with 62.5 per cent in favour, in a poll with a 80.7 per cent turnout. In 2022, Council prepared a de-amalgamation business case for the NSW Minister for Local Government, who is responsible for the final decision. To inform the proposal, Inner West Council widely consulted with the community, including undertaking an independent survey to incorporate views on options for service provision. A report outlining the outcomes of the community engagement process along with the updated business case was presented to 13 September 2022 Ordinary Council meeting. Council is awaiting the determination of the Minister for Local Government.
2. Council is harmonising rates as required by the State Government. This process, and impacts was explained in previous submission responses above.
|
10 |
Public Submission Why are rates being harmonised this year with such little mention? I am not able to find any councillor motion on this topic since and the IWC page (https://yoursay.innerwest.nsw.gov.au/my-rates) on this subject still points to a motion passed in August 2021 whereby rates were being harmonised over a period of 8 years - what has changed since this time? Services have still not been harmonised - I have performers some analysis on the data uploaded here (https://www.innerwest.nsw.gov.au/live/information-for-residents/roads-and-footpaths/streetscape-maintenance) and it is clear that despite being told by my ward Councillor that it should not be the case, the North areas of the LGA are receiving much better service levels than the South. Where is the transparency on what targets are being met for what areas, and what is being done to address discrepancies? There is a great deal of levelling up that needs to be done between the wards before they can be considered equal. Instead you are proposing to charge hundreds of dollars extra to some of the poorest households in the LGA in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis - outrageous! Why are rates being harmonised this year with such little mention? I am not able to find any councillor motion on this topic since and the IWC page (https://yoursay.innerwest.nsw.gov.au/my-rates) on this subject still points to a motion passed in August 2021 whereby rates were being harmonised over a period of 8 years - what has changed since this time? Services have still not been harmonised - I have performers some analysis on the data uploaded here (https://www.innerwest.nsw.gov.au/live/information-for-residents/roads-and-footpaths/streetscape-maintenance) and it is clear that despite being told by my ward Councillor that it should not be the case, the North areas of the LGA are receiving much better service levels than the South. Where is the transparency on what targets are being met for what areas, and what is being done to address discrepancies? There needs to be a much bigger investment into ICT. The current system is completely unfit for purpose. Whilst it is great that Customer Service stalls have been a focus from Council for people that do not have access to the internet, most people do not have time to go out of their way to visit these stalls. Council really need to modernise their IT infrastructure to allow residents to get stuff done online. There needs to be a native mobile app as this is the device that people primarily use now. Woolahra Council have an app that allows you to quickly and conveniently place requests.
|
10 |
Council response 1. Council is continuously increasing its investment in its Information and Communications Technologies, including enabling many of its customer transactions to be undertaken online. Customer information stalls have been important for all sections of the community to engage with council and customer services staff. Council is committed to maintaining an efficient and up-to-date ICT portfolio that meets the needs of staff and residents. Council has adopted a modern cloud based approach to ICT technology which ensures we are using up to date secure modern technology solutions. Council is committed to ongoing expenditure in customer facing IT solutions which is demonstrated with the funding for the new Digital Experience Platform (DXP) initiative which aims to improve customer self service capabilities and experiences. Furthermore, it is anticipated that any future improvements will be device agnostic.
Council is currently in the process of developing a Customer Experience Strategy. Community engagement is currently underway to inform the areas of focus and it is highly likely to extend to the opportunities to improve and expand technologies to enable a more effective customer service for the community. The draft Customer Experience Strategy is expected to be submitted to Council for adoption in December 2023.
2. Council is harmonising rates as required by the State Government. This was explained in previous submission responses. This was also detailed on page 102 of the draft Delivery Program 2022-26 (year 2), Operational Plan and Budget 2023-24 ("The Operational Plan 23/24"). It is planned to take place during the 2023/24 year.
During the public exhibition, the Your Say Inner West project page included a section on rates harmonisation which included the following content: “Rates harmonisation was originally planned to take place over eight years from 2021-2029. At the moment properties that aren’t on the minimum rating are charged differently across the former Local Government Areas.”
“The draft budget instead proposes full harmonisation from 1 July 2023. This ensures all ratepayers across the LGA are charged rates fairly based on their property values, so all members of the community who share and benefit from the Inner West’s services and infrastructure such as parks, roads, footpaths, libraries and rubbish collection contribute equally to the cost of these.”
3. The Operational Plan 23/24 outlines what Council is planning to deliver in the next financial year, and sometimes these initiatives, including projects and programs are a collaboration of local community groups, and other state and federal agencies. A comprehensive service review program and reporting framework is currently being developed and will be implemented in the 2023/24 year (Action 5.1.2.3). More specifically, Council is developing a Service Review Framework to identify potential service delivery improvements and drive more efficient use of resources across the LGA. This framework, including the methodology and models, is currently being finalised.
|
11 |
Public Submission Supported Draft Delivery Program and Operational Plan and Budget 2023-24 - detailed report and open report. Supported Draft Fees and Charges 2023-24 - no option really as charges are increasing.
|
Council Response Support for the Draft Delivery Program and Operational Plan and Budget 2023-24, and Draft Fees and Charges 2023-24 acknowledged. |
Amendments to Delivery Program 2022-26 and Operational Plan and Budget 2023/24 KPIs arising from Internal Review
During the public exhibition period, an internal review was undertaken to ensure all actions were correct, and KPIs were based on robust data with accurate baselines. Minor amendments have been made including reassigning actions/KPIs to alternative teams due to reporting line changes, correction of typographical errors, and correction of reporting frequency (annual or quarterly). Details of these changes and the reason for the change are listed in the Attachment titled Internal Review Amendments to Operational Plan 2023/24.
Service statements
A package of service statements has been developed. For each of the service areas provided by Council, it includes a description of the service, major activities undertaken, actions and KPIs as listed in the Delivery Program and Operational Plan 2023/24, levels of service (where relevant), and budget. The service statements provide additional detail on the service for the benefit of councillors and our community. They are iterative documents and it is intended that they will be uploaded to Council’s website and updated annually as part of the Operational Plan and budget development process. The service statements are provided as an appendix to this report.
Proposed changes to Section 3 of the Delivery Program and Operational Plan
Below are the major movements in the Operational Plan budget. These changes are also reflected in the Long Term Financial Plan.
Adjustments to Operational Budget
1. Operational Expenditure Increase
After the draft budget and Long Term Financial Plan were placed on public exhibition, Council was advised by the Office of State Revenue (OSR) of a significant increase in the Emergency Services Levy (ESL) annual premium as well as confirmation that no subsidy was to be provided to offset this increase. The increase in premium and removal of subsidy is a $1.7m impact to Council for 2023/24 financial year and is now included in the four-year Operational Plan and Long Term Financial Plan.
The State Award increase for staff salaries in the 2023/24 draft budget was projected at 4%. Council has since received further information that the latest negotiations being discussed by the Union and its members are as follows:
o July 2023 4.5% which is an impact to Council of $611k
o July 2024 3.5% plus 0.5% or a lump sum $1,000 (whichever is greater), which is an impact to Council of $911k
o July 205 3.0% plus 0.5% or a lump sum $1,000 (whichever is greater), which is an impact to Council of $912k.
2. Operational Income Increase
Income relating to interest is budgeted to be higher than what was exhibited in the draft budget due to the recent RBA interest rates increase - which will result in higher returns on current investments. The increase will assist in offsetting the expenditure increases noted above.
The overall impact to the 2023/24 operational budget as a result of the above increases in expenditure and income is summarised below.
Adjustments to Capital Budget
The Capital Expenditure budget has been updated to incorporate several resolutions made by Council relating to capital spend, since the draft budget was placed on public exhibition, as shown below:
o The installation of electric vehicle charging stations at Ashfield Service Centre, Balmain Depot and Leichhardt Service Centre in 2023/24 at a cost of $740k
o 10 year capital works programs for the two investment properties recently acquired
o March QBRS adjustments of $4.5m increase in 2023/24 and $1.4m reduction in 2024/25. The reduction of $1.4m in 2024/25 is bringing forward budget for projects that will be delivered in 2023/24.
The table below summarises Capital Expenditure movements which have been reflected in the Long Term Financial Plan. Transfers of restricted and general funds have also varied from exhibition and are updated in the Operational Plan and Long Term Financial Plan.
Long Term Financial Plan
The Long Term Financial Plan has been updated to reflect the movements in the Operational Plan Budget. Whilst the external drivers of the increased Emergency Services Levy and State Award have pulled back the surpluses originally projected in 2023/24 and 2024/25 to deficits, every other key performance indicator exceeds the benchmarks set by the Office of Local Government, across the ten-year period.
Rates Harmonisation
The draft budget as exhibited proposes to move to a single harmonised rating structure from 1 July 2023. Harmonising rates means that rates will be paid equitably in proportion to land value by all ratepayers. Currently, home and business owners pay different rates depending on where their property is within the Inner West. It is considered only fair that everyone contributes equally to the cost of the facilities and services that all can access.
The harmonisation process does not increase Council’s overall income from rates, rather it is just a redistribution of the cost amongst ratepayers. Harmonisation means that individual ratepayers rates may change. Some ratepayers will pay less and some will pay more as rates are calculated according to the NSW Valuer General’s assessment of land value, and subject to a rate peg of 3.7% as provided by IPART.
Proposed changes to Fees and Charges
Since exhibition, there have been minor changes made to Fees and Charges for the following reasons:
o Fee and Charges changes made by a statutory body during the exhibition period
o Correction of GST included in Fees and Charges
o Name changes and further context provided for Fees and Charges
A summary of changes made to specific Fees and Charges is provided in attachment 6.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Council is required to adopt its Delivery Program, Operational Plan, Budget and Fees and Charges for 2023/24 by 30 June 2023.
1.⇩ |
Final Delivery Program 22-26 and Operational Plan 23/24 and Budget 23/24 |
2.⇩ |
Fees and Charges 2023/2024 |
3.⇩ |
Long-Term Financial Plan 2023-2033 |
4.⇩ |
Service Statements Package |
5.⇩ |
Internal Review Amendments to Operational Plan 2023/24 |
6.⇩ |
Fees and Charges 2023/24 Changes Log |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Planning Proposal - Macarthur Parade Heritage Listing
Prepared By: Daniel East - Acting Senior Manager Planning
Authorised By: Simone Plummer - Director Planning
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council supports the Planning Proposal to amend the Inner West Local Environmental Plan 2022 to identify 3,7,9,11 & 13 Macarthur Parade, Dulwich Hill as heritage items of local significance and submit it to the Minister for Planning seeking a Gateway Determination under section 3.33 and 3.34 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.
2. That if a favourable Gateway Determination is received, place the Planning Proposal on community consultation in accordance with Council's Community Engagement Framework to meet the requirements of the Gateway Determination, Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 and Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2021.
3. That Council request delegation from the Minister for Planning to manage the plan making functions of the Planning Proposal.
4. That Council authorise the General Manager to make minor/technical modifications to the Planning Proposal prior to consultation. |
DISCUSSION
In 2021, Council engaged specialist consultants GML Heritage to undertake a heritage review of the Inner West. During the project's early phases, five properties on Macarthur Parade, Dulwich Hill, were identified as having potential heritage significance. The Potential Heritage Conservation Area Study (February 2022) identified:
“That Nos. 7 to 13 Macarthur Parade are pursued for group listing. A group listing would provide additional statutory protections than would be achieved through a Heritage Conservation Area. It is also recommended to investigate the individual heritage listing of 3 Macarthur Parade, the Dulwich Hill Baptist Church. The church, while originating from the same estate, displays different values and would have inherent local historic and social significance.” (GML Heritage, 2022)
Interim Heritage Orders
Council is authorised to make Interim Heritage Orders (IHOs) by Ministerial Order as published in the Government Gazette No. 90 of 12 July 2013. An IHO can be made if Council has considered if the following pre-conditions are in place:
a) it has considered a preliminary heritage assessment of the item prepared by a person with appropriate heritage knowledge, skills and experience employed or retained by the Council and considers that:
(i) the item is or is likely to be found, on further inquiry and investigation, to be of local heritage significance;
(ii) the item is being or is likely to be harmed;
(iii) the IHO is confined to the item determined to be under threat.
Council invoked an IHO in response to a perceived threat to 11 Macarthur Parade in November 2022. The IHO (No. 6) was issued under Section 25 of the Heritage Act 1977 and was published in the NSW Government Gazette 553 on 25 November 2022.
The Council also resolved to place Interim Heritage Orders on 7, 9 and 13 Macarthur Parade at the 9 May 2023 Council Meeting. This will ensure the group of houses are protected throughout the planning proposal process. Once at statutory consultation they will achieve draft heritage group item status.
Draft Planning Proposal
Having carried out the preliminary heritage assessment, and further to the IHO, a detailed assessment of heritage significance was carried out for the five properties, informed by a site inspection in March 2023. The Macarthur Parade Heritage Assessment Study was finalised in May 2023, with the recommendation that 7-13 Macarthur Parade, Dulwich Hill be listed as a group heritage item of local significance, and that 3 Macarthur Parade, Dulwich Hill should be listed as an individual heritage item of local significance in Schedule 5 and on the Heritage Map of the IW LEP 2022.
The preliminary heritage advice received from GML Heritage, and the draft detailed heritage assessment received from Council’s Heritage Specialists, both state that heritage significance is achieved for 7, 9, 11 and 13 Macarthur Parade as a group of houses built at a similar time with joint historical significance. This demonstrates the need for interim heritage orders on all four sites, as the loss or damage to one building would diminish the heritage significance of the group. The heritage assessment forms the evidence base for the draft Planning Proposal and demonstrates the strategic and site-specific merit of the listing. Attachment 1 provides the draft Planning Proposal and supporting documents.
The draft Planning Proposal will preserve local heritage in the Inner West local government area by providing statutory protection and recognition to sites of historical significance.
Local Planning Panel
The draft Planning Proposal was heard by the Inner West Local Planning Panel (IWLPP) on 9 May 2023 and resolved to support the Planning Proposal in its entirety:
1. The draft Planning Proposal
prepared by Council officers dated April 2023 to amend Schedule 5 of the IWLEP
2022 to heritage list five properties on Macarthur Parade, Dulwich Hill is
supported as it has sufficient strategic and site-specific merit for submission
to Minister for Planning and Public Spaces for a Gateway Determination in
accordance with Section 3.34 of the Environmental Planning & Assessment Act
1979.
2. The Panel noted in the Council Officer’s report that:
a. The map on page 4 requires modification to identify the relevant properties; and
b. In Section 7 Part 5 – the community consultation should also include local heritage groups, such as Marrickville Heritage Society.
The decision of the Panel was unanimous.
Next Steps
If supported, the draft Planning Proposal will be submitted to the State Government for Gateway Determination. Statutory community consultation will occur if a Gateway Determination is issued and must occur before the first IHO lapses on 25 November 2023.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
There are no financial implications associated with the implementation of the proposed recommendations outlined in the report.
1.⇩ |
Planning Proposal Macarthur Parade |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Future Special Entertainment Precincts
Prepared By: Daniel East - Acting Senior Manager Planning
Authorised By: Simone Plummer - Director Planning
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council endorses commencing early engagement on new special entertainment precincts in Marrickville, Leichhardt, Rozelle, and Balmain.
2. That the findings of the early engagement are reported to Council.
|
DISCUSSION
Inner West Council is in the process of formalising Enmore Road as NSW’s first Special Entertainment Precinct (SEP). In this precinct:
· Liquor and Gaming no longer plays a role in noise compliance,
· Fixed sound criteria applies to entertainment sound coming from venues,
· Future and modified residential accommodation will be required to attenuate against entertainment sound (once the SEP is formalised), and
· Venues hosting entertainment are entitled to an additional 30mins of trade and outdoor street dining till 11pm (10pm is standard elsewhere in Council).
Due to the success of the Enmore Road SEP, Council resolved to scope new precincts in Marrickville, Leichhardt, and Balmain/Rozelle. This report outlines possible locations for the future precincts.
This project is a result of a Council Resolution from 13 September 2022:
That Council:
3. Noting alignment of many of the Summit’s priorities with Council’s current Living Arts program and Cultural Strategy, endorse the following initiatives from the Summit for immediate action:
e) Noting the opportunities to support local artists and music venues under the pilot Special Entertainment Precinct on Enmore Road, commence scoping works to identify other potential locations to pilot SEPs in the LGA including Marrickville Road, Darling St, and Norton St
The map provided in Attachment 1 shows a possible location for the precinct stretching 1.7km walking distance between Sydenham Station and Marrickville Station. This encompasses Railway Parade, Marrickville Road up to Marrickville Town Hall and Illawarra Road from Marrickville Road to the station. It also includes the Great Club, a live music venue located behind the Marrickville Library development.
This precinct was selected for several reasons:
· It takes advantage of convenient public transport connections with a train (future metro) station at either end of the precinct.
· There are numerous live music venues and venues that occasionally host live music along this stretch including Lazybones, Camelot Lounge and Gasoline Pony.
· Council intends to use Marrickville Town Hall as a live music venue.
· It covers the Sydenham Creative Hub, an initiative from 2017 that permits small bars, restaurants, and cafés on three blocks of industrial zoned land facing Marrickville Road.
· Marrickville is becoming more prominent as a night-time destination for the Inner West and Greater Sydney.
There is a further opportunity in Marrickville to create a precinct along Victoria Road and Addison Road to protect existing venues and encourage the establishment of new ones. Creating a SEP in this area would ensure that the residential development being introduced is adequately sound proofed to assist in the retention of existing venues such as the Factory Theatre, Vic on the Park, Red Rattler and Marrickville Bowling Club. The Golden Barley Hotel has also been included as an isolated venue.
It is noted that the Victoria Road precinct covers Industrial land. Council is committed to protecting industrial land for creatives and the local economy. Whilst a SEP may encourage new cultural venues, there are no changes proposed to land use permissibility in industrial zones. Entertainment facilities, creative industries, breweries and some forms of food and drink premises are already permissible through existing planning controls in these zones. It is expected that protecting cultural venues for performance and live entertainment will have a positive flow on effect to the local creative sector.
LEICHHARDT
Norton Street and a portion of Parramatta Road present an opportunity for a SEP. This area includes an existing live music venue (Crowbar on Parramatta Road) and would encourage new venues or hosting entertainment in existing premises. A map of the possible precinct area is included as Attachment 2. The reasons for this location include the following:
· It covers the commercial area of Norton Street and part of Parramatta Road.
· It’s largely aligned with the existing late night trading area under the Leichhardt DCP that has been in place since 2013.
· It covers notable night-time businesses including Palace Cinemas, Norton’s Pub, the Bald Faced Stag/Crowbar, The Royal Hotel and the Petersham Inn.
· It covers major developments including the Italian Forum and Norton Plaza.
· It includes Leichhardt Town Hall, which Council intends to use as a live music venue.
· There is a strong mix of hospitality businesses in the precinct and within walking distance.
· The area is likely to go through significant change given its location within the Parramatta Road urban transformation corridor.
BALMAIN / ROZELLE
Darling Street and part of Victoria Road present an opportunity for two SEPs, one in Balmain and the other in Rozelle. The two precincts would cover several pubs, hospitality businesses and Balmain Town Hall. Maps of the possible precinct areas are included in Attachments 3 and 4. Reasons for the locations include:
· They cover the busier commercial areas of Darling Street across both sides of Victoria Road, and part of Victoria Road around the Darling Street intersection.
· They align with the existing late night trading area under the Leichhardt DCP that has been in place since 2013.
· Numerous hospitality businesses and pubs in the precincts that already provide or could host live music including the Bridge Hotel, Sackville Hotel, Cricketers Arms and the Unity Hall Hotel.
NEXT STEPS – EARLY ENGAGEMENT
Early engagement is required to inform the wider public, residents, businesses, land owners, industry and key stakeholders such as the Police and Liquor and Gaming of Council’s intention to roll out new SEPs. It’s also an opportunity for residents to participate in decision making and identify proactive solutions to local issues.
Early engagement will include:
· Letters to affected land owner/occupiers, including residents and businesses
· Information and feedback to patrons of the proposed precincts
· Information about the proposed SEPs and feedback forms or surveys on Council’s Your Say Inner West (YSIW) page
· Face-to-face pop ups in each precinct
· Direct consultation with key venues in each precinct
· Direct consultation with key stakeholders in each precincts including the Police and Liquor and Gaming
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
There are no financial implications associated with the implementation of the proposed recommendations outlined in the report.
1.⇩ |
Marrickville and Victoria Road SEP map |
2.⇩ |
Leichhardt SEP map |
3.⇩ |
Balmain SEP map |
4.⇩ |
Rozelle SEP map |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Post Exhibition Report 1 - 13 Parramatta Road Annandale VPA
Prepared By: Scott Mullen - Strategic Investments and Property Manager
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council enters into the Amended Voluntary Planning Agreement for 1-13 Parramatta Road, Annandale as provided in Attachment 4 to this report.
2. That Council delegates authority to the General Manager to execute the Voluntary Planning Agreement.
|
BACKGROUND
1-13 Parramatta Road, Annandale (Property) is located on the northern side of Parramatta Road to the east of Nelson Street. There is frontage to both Parramatta Road and McCarthy Lane. The total site area is approximately 1,765 square metres and it is located within a predominantly residential area, characterised by one and two storey developments.
The Property falls within the Parramatta Road Corridor Urban Transformation Strategy (PRCUTS) which identifies Johnstons Creek as a pedestrian and cycle corridor to connect Parramatta Road with Rozelle Bay.
In conjunction with the PRCUTS, Council developed a draft masterplan for the Parramatta Road Urban Amenity Improvement Program (PRUAIP) for various projects to be undertaken in the LGA which included the Johnstons Creek pedestrian and cycle corridor (Masterplan).
The Property is a key link in the creation of the pedestrian and cycle path throughout the Inner West Local Government Area (LGA) as part of the strategy.
The property was the subject of a Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) which was tabled for consideration at the Council meeting held on 14 March 2023. Council subsequently resolved as follows:
That the Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) for 1-13 Parramatta Road, Annandale be:
1. Placed on public exhibition for a minimum of 28 days.
2. Reported back to Council after public exhibition; and
3. Authorises the General Manager to approve any amendments to the amended VPA prior to public exhibition.
This report has been prepared following the public exhibition process, to consider the execution of the VPA.
DISCUSSION
Development Consents
DA 2017/161 relates to the Property and is for a mixed-use development comprising of retail shops and 41 residential units. In 2019 a modification to DA 2017/161 was lodged (application M/2019/53).
M/2019/53 was subject to Land and Environment Court (LEC) proceedings which resulted in the LEC making orders by consent. Part of the s.34 conciliation conference negotiations during 2020 and 2021 included a Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) which would deliver the public benefits of a pedestrian and cycle through link at the Property that was identified in the Masterplan as well as a pedestrian pathway at McCarthy Lane, Annandale. The entering into the VPA was a condition of consent.
In 2022 a further modification to the DA 2017/161 was lodged (application MOD/2022/0143). This modification required amendments to the VPA regarding the pedestrian and cycle through link adjacent to Johnstons Creek.
Original Voluntary Planning Agreement
Between June 2020 and March 2021, a VPA was negotiated as part of M/2019/53 with Eranna Developments Pty Ltd (Developer) and E&R Property Pty Ltd (Owner). At the 23 June 2020 council meeting Council resolved to:
1. Endorse the recommendations in Confidential Attachment 1; and
2. Place the Voluntary Planning Agreement on public exhibition for a minimum of 28 days and receive a further report after the exhibition period.
The 23 June 2020 Council Report (Attachment 1) and Confidential Report – VPA Details (Attachment 2) are attached.
Note that whilst the original VPA Details Report was tabled as Confidential at the time, the contents have been publicly exhibited and there is no need to treat it as confidential in this report.
After the granting of MOD/2019/53 public exhibition of the VPA and Explanatory Note was conducted in June 2021. There were two submissions with neither objecting to the proposed VPA.
Amended Voluntary Planning Agreement
At the council meeting held on 14 March 2023 a report was tabled (Attachment 3) detailing the amendments to the VPA (Attachment 4) through the second modification application MOD/2022/0143 (Attachment 5) as well as the Explanatory Note (Attachment 6).
In accordance with the EP&A Act, Planning Agreements must be publicly notified and made available for public inspection before they can be executed. At that meeting Council resolved to place the VPA on public exhibition for 28 days, and this was undertaken from 24 April to 23 May 2023.
The engagement was undertaken online via Your Say Inner West and promoted through Council’s website and social media. Two submissions were received with neither opposing the proposed VPA.
It is recommended that Council now proceed to enter into the VPA, and delegate authority to the General Manager to execute the VPA document.
The total value of the VPA is estimated at $1,270,000.
1.⇩ |
Council Report 23 June 2020 |
2.⇩ |
VPA Details Report 1-13 Parramatta Road Annandale |
3.⇩ |
Council Report 14 March 2023 |
4.⇩ |
Amended Voluntary Planning Agreement 1-13 Parramatta Road Annandale |
5.⇩ |
Plans MOD20220143 - 1-13 Parramatta Road Annandale |
6.⇩ |
Explanatory Note - 1-13 Parramatta Road Annandale |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Post Exhibition - Inner West Cycling Strategy and Action Plan
Prepared By: Ken Welsh - Coordinator Strategic Transport Planning
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council adopt the Inner West Cycling Strategy and the Cycling Action Plan.
2. That initiatives
outlined in the Cycling Action Plan be incorporated into the 4-year Delivery
Program and annual Operational Plan and be considered in the annual budget
planning process. 3. That authority be delegated to the General Manager to make minor editorial amendments for clarity or correction following adoption of Cycling Strategy and Action Plan.
4. That authority be delegated to the General Manager for the periodical review and updating of the cycling network map and the Cycling Action Plan in accordance with the Community Strategic Plan.
|
DISCUSSION
The Inner West Cycling Strategy (Attachment 2) and the associated Cycling Action Plan (Attachment 3) outlines priorities, actions and projects to expand the safe bike network and support more people cycling.
The Cycling Strategy outlines strategic directions as well as a cycling network map to inform Council’s work to make bike riding a viable transport option for more people. The Action Plan outlines infrastructure and non-infrastructure initiatives to which resources will be allocated in the short- and medium-term future. The cycling network map (Figure 1 in the Cycling Strategy) and the Cycling Action Plan will be reviewed and updated periodically to respond to relevant circumstances such as changes in Community transport needs, funding opportunities and unforeseen project constraints.
The Strategy was informed by collaboration with Bicycle User Groups and the Bicycle Working Group throughout 2020 and 2021 and developed based on community engagement carried out in March 2022. Amendments to the draft Strategy and development of the Action Plan were based on Community comments received during its public exhibition in November 2022.
Ongoing engagement with Bicycle User Groups, Bicycle Working Group, adjoining councils and Transport for NSW took place throughout development and refinement of the draft Strategy and the Action Plan. This engagement will continue with the proposed periodic review and updating of the cycling network map (Figure 1 in Cycling Strategy) and Cycling Action Plan.
Summary of Exhibition Results
Public exhibition of the Strategy took place between 26 October and 28 November 2022 with the Your Say Inner West project page receiving 2366 views. In total 135 responses were received to online questions and 18 submissions were sent directly to staff. Submissions were received from individuals as well as key stakeholders such as Bicycle User Groups (BUGs), climate action groups and Transport for NSW. Analysis indicated that 85 percent of respondents were somewhat, mostly or very satisfied with the draft Cycling Strategy
A copy of the Engagement Outcomes Report is provided as Attachment 1.
Key Changes to The Draft Strategy in Response to Public Exhibition
Based on feedback received from the Community during public exhibition of the draft strategy the following key changes were made:
· Development of a denser cycling network map with more routes indicated;
· A new approach to recognise main streets in accordance with their uniqueness and NSW Government policy (Movement and Place Framework);
· Specifying of the ongoing review and updating of the cycling network map (Figure 1 in the Cycling Strategy) and the Action Plan;
· Various changes to wording including several new actions and other changes suggested by the Community.
Development of the Action Plan in Response to Public Exhibition
The Cycling Action Plan outlines cycling initiatives, both infrastructure and non-infrastructure, to which limited Council resources will be allocated in the short- and medium-term futures. It was developed based on input from the Bicycle Working Group and the Community during engagement in March 2022 and public exhibition of the draft Strategy in November 2022.
Based on Community feedback the Cycling Action Plan includes the following projects:
· Investigation of routes and infrastructure types to provide safer cycling Ashfield in north of the train line;
· A new wayfinding map;
· Cycling confidence courses for staff and the Community;
· Improved and coordinated wayfinding signage with new infrastructure projects;
· A public education campaign to help drivers share the roads safely with bikes;
· Continued work with NSW Government agencies to provide safer cycling access on Parramatta Road and Victoria Road, Rozelle;
· Finalisation of cycling infrastructure projects including Lilyfield Road, Pyrmont Bridge Road and Marrickville Road East.
It has been recommended that delegation be provided to the General Manager for the periodical review and updating of the cycling network map and the Cycling Action Plan to allow unplanned grant opportunities to be capitalised on and for completed projects to be removed as relevant.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Infrastructure projects identified in the Cycling Action Plan are to be funded by developer contributions and/or grants from external bodies such as the NSW Government Active Transport Program that are likely to be successfully applied for. If the grant applications are unsuccessful for specific projects, this may affect timelines for delivering projects until an alternative funding source is found. It should be further noted that the Livingstone Road Cycleway enhancements project is currently unfunded and would require a funding source to be delivered.
Other initiatives are being delivered within existing operational budgets or staff resourcing as shown on the Action Plan.
A summary of the funding source for the infrastructure initiative is provided below:
Action – Description |
Funding Source |
Design development and construction of missing links for Cooks to Cove GreenWay * |
· Grant Funding – successful · Developer Contributions |
Design and delivery of Marrickville Road East cycleway * |
· Developer Contributions · Grant Funding - submitted |
Design and delivery of St Peters to Sydenham cycle route |
· Grant Funding - successful |
Investigation of north-south cycling routes and infrastructure types in the Ashfield Strategic Investigation Area |
· General Fund |
Design and delivery of Lilyfield Road cycleway * |
· Grant Funding - unconfirmed |
Design and delivery of Pyrmont Bridge Road cycleway (Parramatta Road Urban Amenity Improvement Program (PRUAIP)) |
· Grant Funding - successful |
Finalise design of West St to Livingstone Rd cycle route * |
· Grant Funding - unconfirmed |
Upgrade Carrington Road cycleway to provide cycling access across intersections |
· Grant Funding - successful |
Cycling works – general. Annual budget allocation for minor works relevant to cycling such as signage, ramps, line marking, etc. |
· General Fund |
Work with Sydney Metro - Sydenham-Bankstown to finalise concept design of the East-West Pedestrian and Cycle Link (EWPCL) * |
· Grant Funding - submitted |
Install pilot wayfinding signage on bike route between Annandale and Leichhardt installed as part of the Parramatta Road Urban Amenity Improvement Program (PRUAIP) |
· Depreciation Reserve |
Design and install wayfinding and interpretive signage on Iron Cove to Cooks River Greenway |
· Grant
Funding - successful |
Work with Transport for NSW to identify possible early works for the Parramatta to Sydney Foreshore Link |
|
Livingstone Road Cycleway enhancements ** |
· Unfunded and unbudgeted |
1.⇩ |
Engagement Outcomes Report - Public exhibition in November 2022 |
2.⇩ |
Inner West Cycling Strategy |
3.⇩ |
Inner West Cycling Action Plan |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Dulwich Hill Skate Park
Prepared By: Morna Scott - Capital Projects Manager
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council authorises the General Manager or his delegate to negotiate the terms and execute a lease/ licence between Council and Transport Administration Holding Entity (TAHE) regarding Jack Shanahan Reserve.
2. That Council plan to deliver the skate park resurfacing with the lighting work in 2024-25 and include additional funding in the appropriate budget process. |
DISCUSSION
At the Council meeting held on 14 June 2022, Council resolved the following:
That Council:
1. Investigate the lighting along the pedestrian path between the Dulwich Hill Light Rail to Terrace Road and;
a) undertake a lighting test to measure the existing lighting level and performance and ensure compliance with Australian Standards;
b) work in consultation with the NSW Police to conduct a Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) assessment which includes reviewing current lighting lux levels within the park.
2. Bring forward up to $200,000 from the 2023/24 Parks Upgrades capital works budget and allocate funding to light the Dulwich Hill skate park, subject to community engagement support and report it to Council.
3. Convene a community meeting with ward councillors at the skate park to identify ‘quick wins’ to improve the facility.
The report outlines actions undertaken in response to the resolution including the community engagement outcomes. It is noted that Dulwich Hill Skate Park is located within Jack Shanahan Reserve, Dulwich Hill.
Pedestrian path between the Dulwich Hill Light Rail and Terrace Road:
Lighting of the pathway within Jack Shanahan Reserve was audited on 16 February 2023 by a council engaged lighting consultant. The audit found the pathway to be compliant with lighting category P3. Lighting category P3 is considered appropriate for this location and may be used on streets/pathways where there is increased pedestrian activity and potential risk of crime. Two light fittings were found to be faulty and will be repaired.
Consultation with NSW Police
Council staff met with three officers from Inner West Police Area Command, including the Crime Prevention Officer on 2 March 2023. The site was reviewed, and the following feedback provided to improve activation of the space and safety:
- Increased lighting throughout the park including lighting the skate bowl, basketball/ tennis court and carpark
- Repainting the toilet block
- Tree trimming to improve sight lines
The Police also supported the Greenway link from the top of the site through to Hercules Street.
Community Engagement Summary
Council undertook community engagement between 31 March 2023 – Monday 15 May 2023. This included an online survey and feedback via Your Say Inner West and an on-site community session with local ward Councilors on 13 May 2023.
The Your Say Inner West page received 1,236 views with 49 contributions. Approximately 40 people attended the on-site meeting on Saturday 13th May along with two Council staff and three Ward Councilors.
Online respondents ranked improvements as follows:
1. Repair skate park surface (40)
2. Additional tree planting (31)
3. Additional seating (28)
4. Repair chainmesh fencing (15)
5. Tree pruning for safety (12)
6. Repainting of walls (12)
7. Pressure Cleaning footpaths (9)
The majority of respondents commented that the skate park surface has deteriorated overtime with exposed aggregate creating an uneven and abrasive surface. Most attendees recommended rectification of the skate park surface as a priority.
The community supported lighting the skate facility and agreed it would activate the space, provide a healthy activity for people after work using both the skate facility and the tennis/basketball court.
No on-line respondents or engagement session attendees opposed the lighting proposals.
Approvals
Jack Shanahan Reserve land is owned by Transport Administration Holding Entity (TAHE). The lease for Jack Shanahan Reserve has expired. A new lease with TAHE is required before proceeding with the proposed lighting upgrades. Negotiation of the new lease terms is anticipated to take approximately 12 months including approval by the TAHE board. The report recommends Council authorise the General Manager or his delegate to negotiate the terms of the lease / licence and execute the agreement. This will assist in minimising time frames for this approval.
The Marrickville Neighborhood Parks plan of management, adopted in 2001, includes Hercules Street Reserve (now referred to as Jack Shanahan Reserve). The lighting upgrade can be completed under Part 5 of the EP&A Act and State Environmental Planning Policy (Transport and Infrastructure) 2021, with preparation of a Review of Environmental Factors. The REF will be completed as part of the design process.
The quick wins works can be undertaken as required as maintenance activities and do not require the above approvals.
Recommended Works
Based on the resolution, community engagement feedback and approval requirements, the following outlines the proposed scope and delivery time frames:
“Quick Wins” for completion by 30 June 2023 which are being completed as maintenance works:
· Painting of entry retaining walls and amenities building pillars and facia
· Additional tree planting in grassed areas south and east of the skate park and tennis court
· Additional bench seat
· Repair of tennis court chain wire fence
· Pedestrian lighting repairs
· Pressure cleaning of footpaths
· Under pruning of trees to improve sight lines
The following upgrades are proposed to be completed in 2024-25 following design and approvals in 2023-24.
· Lighting of the skate park and tennis court including design review of the car park lighting
· Resurfacing of all skate surfaces (main skate park and snake bowl)
Undertaking these works at the same time will minimise disruption to skate park users.
Lighting of the skate park is proposed to be on a timed setting from dusk until 11pm in the evening in line with timing provided at Sydenham Green Skate Park, subject to the Part 5 approval process and review of environmental factors.
In line with the resolution, $200,000 was included in the 2022-23 capital budget. Due to community engagement timing, this budget was rephased at Quarter 3 to provide $50,000 for the quick wins in 2022-23 and $150,000 in 2023-24 for lighting works. Based upon the further investigations and consultation to the project, further rephasing is required to include the approvals process.
The recommended works, including quick wins, skate park and tennis court lighting and skate park resurfacing is estimated to cost $700,000. The estimated additional budget required for the recommended works can be funded from existing parks assets renewal budgets in 2024-25. The following proposed budget will be considered as a part of the 2023/24 budget planning process
Table 1 Proposed Budget
Year |
Existing Budget |
Proposed Budget |
Activity |
2022-23 |
$50,000 |
$50,000 |
Quick Wins |
2023-24 |
$150,000 |
$50,000 |
Design & REF concurrent with Lease/Licence |
2024-25 |
$0 |
$600,000 |
Construction of lighting and skatepark resurfacing |
Total Budget |
$200,000 |
$700,000 |
|
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Marrickville Mosaics
Prepared By: Lachlan
Broadbent - Manager Parks and Streetscape Operations and
Manod Wickramasinghe - Traffic and Transport Planning
Manager
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
That the review and replacement of the Marrickville footpath mosaics be considered as part of the Marrickville Town Centre master plan.
|
DISCUSSION
At the Council meeting held on 11 April 2023, Council resolved the following:
That Council prepare a report on the cost of restoring and repairing all of the footpath mosaic artworks in Marrickville to allow for funding to be allocated to the works when the Budget is adopted in June.
The footpath mosaics are generally located along the footpaths of Marrickville Road between Petersham Road and Victoria Road.
The mosaics were audited by Council’s streetscape team in May 2023 and a total of 74 mosaic artworks were identified with the following condition noted:
· 19 identified as good condition with no defects
· 49 identified as damaged with missing tiles
· 6 identified with minor damage
Damage was predominantly in the form of missing tiles due to loss of adherence to the concrete slab as well as damage due cracking of the underlying slab, examples of this damage is shown in Figure 1 and 2. It is also noted that previous damage has included natural causes such as weather and general pedestrian traffic, as well as utility service work such as trenching which has required partial removal of the slab and the overlaid mosaic. These damages have sometimes resulted in public safety concern and Council has acted accordingly to make the area safe and free from hazard.
It is considered that attempts to partially repair the mosaics will cause additional damage and cracking. Therefore, to repair the damaged mosaics, Council would need to engage a third-party artist to design and manufacture new mosaics tiles. The mosaic tiles would be placed on a concrete slab within an aluminum steel tray. The tray would subsequently be placed within a new concrete footpath slab. This would be an improved methodology to affixing mosaic tiles directly to a new concrete slab as it will prevent cracking of the adjacent footpath slab propagating to the mosaic and therefore minimise the risk of the future loss of tiles over the long term.
Figure 1 - Examples of damaged mosaics due to the underlying slab cracking
Figure 2 - Examples of damaged mosaics due to the lack of adherence of mosaic tiles
It is also noted that Council is currently engaging the community regarding the Marrickville Town Centre master plan. This master plan preparation process is expected to continue into 2024 and will include consideration of whether the existing in-situ concrete pavement is to be upgraded to a higher standard, consistent with new paving works being undertaken elsewhere such as within the Dulwich Hill Station Precinct, Alex Travellion Plaza and adjacent to the Marrickville Library and Town Hall.
Noting that the Marrickville Road footpaths are generally in poor condition, there is a high likelihood that footpath works may be prioritised through this process. It is therefore important that any decision around the repair and replacement of the mosaics consider the renewal of the footpath paving, as the artworks may be damaged by the future footpath works.
The master plan process could also seek input from the community to determine whether other forms of public art should be commissioned, noting the physical integrity of the artworks (i.e. to what extent they may/may not be repairable) may make repair difficult.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
It has been estimated that a total budget of $250,000 would be required to repair the 49 mosaics identified as being damaged with missing tiles.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: FOGO Service Update
Prepared By: Erin
White - Manager Resource Recovery and Fleet Services and
Helen Bradley - Manager Resource Recovery Planning
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council endorses the Community Engagement and Change Communications Strategy.
2. That Council endorse the Inner West Creative FOGO (Food Organics and Garden Organics) campaign.
3. That the General Manager be delegated authority to write off all fees in relation to requests to increase the size of any existing red-lid garbage bin to 240 litre or 120 litre within the Domestic Waste Management service, associated with the implementation of the food recycling program until 1 July 2024.
4. That an update be provided at Councillor workshop before a further report is considered at the August Ordinary Meeting.
|
DISCUSSION
Background
Council resolved on 8 February 2022 to deliver a Food and Garden Organics (FOGO) Service to all Inner West households within this Council term.
At the Extraordinary Council Meeting held on 13 December 2022 Council confirmed that Veolia would process its Food and Garden Organics material and resolved to enter into a Deed of Variation to the existing Inner West current contract to commence the service in 2023. The processing is through a third-party provider in Forbes, that will use the product for agricultural land application.
Inner West engaged external communications experts in FOGO, Icon Agency to develop a communications and engagement plan. The process for this work involves discovery, definition, development and delivery phases.
Icon undertook workshops in early March with key stakeholders including the FOGO Project control group, staff and Councillors to understand the Inner West community and our local challenges.
From this discovery phase a Draft Behaviour Change Strategy was prepared and considered at the April Ordinary Council Meeting. The next phase involved the creative development phase, and the proposed concepts are outlined in section 5 of this report and are tabled for Council’s consideration.
Following the endorsement of the creative concepts this will progress into the delivery phase (designs and detailed comms plan) by the end of June ready for implementation (printing and distribution) as part of the FOGO roll out.
In addition to this, Council has sought Expressions of Interest to find trusted local champions (organisations, businesses or notable individuals) who have expertise in sustainability education and recycling with established networks and audiences in the Inner West. The EOI was advertised on Friday 19 May and closes on Monday 12 June 2023. The applications are via VendorPanel and an online briefing was held on Friday 26 May in which interested individuals, businesses and organisations attended. The assessment panel will review EOI submissions in June. The champions engaged are then trained and provided with the communications to support council by engaging community and sharing key messages and communications through their face-to-face and online networks.
The Inner West Environment Advisory Group was engaged on the Community Engagement and Change Communications Strategy and asked a series of questions:
· What opportunities, networks or community groups are you aware of, to extend our reach and connect with our community to ensure everyone living in a house knows what FOGO is and how to use it?
· What are the key barriers and challenges for people in houses we should consider in developing FAQs, troubleshooting and solutions? These will also inform the program of engagement for two waste buster officers being recruited.
· Do you have suggestions for respected and trusted individuals for our FOGO Hero?
The group provided feedback on a range of community groups and networks, offered to share the EOI with their networks and named some additional trusted locals. Potential barriers and suggestions were discussed including unacceptable items such as dog poo, plastic bags and nappies and suggestions for communications.
1. The Proposed Service
The FOGO service will commence on 9 October 2023 for all single dwelling properties and will be in addition to the food collection service that is currently available to all multi-unit dwellings.
The waste service will be consistent across the entire Inner West Local Government Area and will involve fortnightly collection of the existing garbage bin (120 litre standard) and weekly collection of the FOGO bin (240 litre) and a fortnightly collection of recycling (240 litre). This total volume available for each residential dwelling to dispose of all domestic waste produced will total 840 litres per fortnight compared to the current system of 600 litres per fortnight.
The contract for the Supply and the Roll out bins for FOGO has been awarded. This is for the 7000 plus properties that currently do not have a garden organics or Food organics only bin. The roll out of these bins is planned to commence in late August 2023.
A Risk Management Plan has been developed with measures to mitigate risks. The highest level risks from this matrix are identified below:
· Increased demand for larger garbage red-lid garbage bins - Residents on smaller bin service (80 litres or 55 litres) not having sufficient waste capacity and opting for larger bin due to fortnightly collection. Mitigated via bin upsizing, information, and support from waste educators (Section 3 of this report).
· Miscommunication – incorrect messages and information being shared with our community. Mitigated through the comms and engagement plan.
· Timing - Residents adding food to their garden organics bin before October. Mitigated through clear instructions and information as per comms and engagement plan.
· Responsiveness – to resident complaints and enquiries. Mitigated by employing two additional customer service staff and daily monitoring of response times to engage additional resources as needed (Section 2 of this report).
· Transfer - Veolia awaiting extensions to capacity licencing at Banksmeadow Transfer station. Mitigated by maintaining contact with EPA (Environment Protection Authority) licencing and Veolia contract manager.
· Collection responsiveness - Collection vehicle and crew availability for increased demand on services. Mitigated by delaying (retaining use off) sale of collection vehicles and having a casual pool of staff available.
2. Anticipated demand on Customer Requests relating to waste
Council has recently increased the number of call centre staff to meet its service standard of 90% of calls to be answered within 60 seconds. In addition to this, council will be adding a further two call centre staff for a period of 12 months to manage anticipated additional requests throughout the recycling improvements and FOGO service introduction. Council will monitor calls and enquiries throughout this period and will be adjusting resources accordingly.
Council is recruiting an additional two waste education officers (Waste Busters) who will be in the community directly educating residents on the use of the FOGO bin, assisting with the reduction of garbage in the red-lid garbage bin through waste avoidance, reuse and best-practice recycling to be support a fortnightly garbage collection. A grant has been applied for from the NSW EPA to cover the cost of these two 12-month positions, and we are awaiting the outcome.
3. Managing residents' concerns with the transition to a fortnightly collection of red-lid garbage bin
The rollout of FOGO will require residents to make some changes to their garbage and recycling habits.
In order to maximise the efficiency and simplicity of the rollout, residential waste audits and tonnages were analysed to identify the capacity (red-lid garbage bin size) required for Inner West. Based on the red-lid garbage and organics tonnages for 2021-22, the average FOGO bin capacity is calculated at 32 litres per week when achieving a 50% recovery of food (from the garbage red-lid garbage bin into FOGO).
The average 120L red-lid garbage bin collected fortnightly will be 79% full (95 litres) if 50% of the available food organics are transferred from the red-lid garbage bin to the FOGO bin. There is excess capacity in the 240 litre FOGO bin to accept all food and garden organics generated by Inner West households, with additional FOGO bins available at no additional charge if required.
The Inner West use of the existing 120 litre red-lid garbage bin on a fortnightly collection is reinforced by the Penrith service whereby 84.5% households used the standard sustainable service (a 140-litre red-lid garbage bin collected fortnightly), the remainder upsized to a larger 240 litre capacity on a user-pays charge. According to ABS data, the average Penrith Household accommodates 2.72 residents equating to 51.5 litres red-lid garbage bin per fortnight per person compared to Inner West at 2.28 residents equating to 52.6 litres available per fortnight per person. Penrith’s organics capture rate is 61.5% and 86% of residents actively use the FOGO service. Inner Wests FOO (Food Organics Only) service in apartments currently recovers 54% as an indication of diversion, noting that recovery rates are usually lower in apartments compared to houses.
The Inner West Council fees and charges offer variable domestic waste charges based on the size of the red-lid garbage bin on a “user pays” model aligned with waste generation and our Zero Waste Strategy.
The domestic waste charge is based on the size of the red-lid garbage bin and not impacted by recycling or garden organics recycling services. Households can have additional recycling and garden/FOGO bins at no additional cost.
Maintaining the standard red-lid garbage bin is as per NSW (New South Wales) FOGO best practice guiding documents (based on audits and Councils that have implemented FOGO) as increasing red-lid garbage bin capacity acts as a deterrent for transferring food to the FOGO bin, reducing recovery of organics.
The proposed domestic waste charges in the 2023-24 draft budget are:
· Minimum Charge (80 litre or less red-lid garbage bin) - $377
· Standard (120 litre red-lid garbage bin) - $502
· Maximum (240 litre red-lid garbage bin) - $753
The below table demonstrates how surrounding councils compare with the Inner West domestic waste service charge. The City of Sydney (CoS) and Penrith offer a small service charge (less than 120 litre red-lid garbage bin).
IWCs domestic waste service charge for the smallest charge (under 120L) for 2023-24 is $54 more expensive than the City of Sydney's and $37 more than Penrith’s.
For the standard 120L charge, Inner West is $9 more than the City of Sydney, and $161.35 cheaper than Randwick which is the only other SSROC council which provides FOGO.
NB: Based on proposed 2023-24 charges.
Council |
<120L |
120L (Standard) |
Inner West |
$377 |
$502 |
City of Sydney |
$323 |
$491 |
Randwick (FOGO) 240L red-lid garbage fortnightly/eq 120L week |
NA |
$663.35 |
Canterbury -Bankstown |
NA |
$605 |
Canada Bay |
NA |
$439 |
Burwood |
NA |
$556.50 |
Penrith (FOGO) |
$340 |
$455 (140L) |
There are approximately 6,000 IWC dwellings on the minimum domestic waste charge. It is anticipated that some may require a larger red-lid garbage bin when the service changes to fortnightly. Changes to red-lid garbage bin size require the property owners consent as it alters the domestic waste charge on their rates notice. Council proposes that households requiring a larger bin (80 litre to 120 litre) will not be charged the additional cost until 30 June 2024 and Council will consider a further report regarding 2024-25 fees and charges including streamlining of charges to a standard or large service).
It is therefore recommended that the General Manager be delegated authority to write off all fees in relation to requests to increase the size of their bin to 240L or 120 L red-lid garbage bins within the Domestic Waste Management service, associated with the implementation of the food recycling program until 1 July 2024.
Council considered providing a weekly red-lid garbage bin service for the first 12 months of the FOGO service. The additional service would cost $6.3 million for 12 months and would need to be delivered by a collection contract requiring a lead time of 8-12 months to implement.
The service change may take some adjustment and Council has contingency plans in place in the form of a spare crew that could provide an additional collection service as required. Any concerns over the fortnightly collection of the red-lid garbage bin could be managed using the following steps:
1. Pick up overflowing red-lid garbage bin as a one off.
2. Provide education and tips on reducing garbage, whilst maximising FOGO and recycling.
3. Offer a larger bin to be delivered (expected delivery within 5 working days).
4. Follow up by in-field waste education officers to support the household with targeted and relevant waste avoidance, reuse and recycling opportunities to return to smaller bin size in future.
5. Adjust domestic waste charge as per size of red-lid garbage bin, seeking consent from the property owner who pays the rates charges to commence 1st July 2024.
4. Compostable bags for food scraps
Residents will be provided with a 6-month supply (pack) of compostable bags as part of the starter pack (caddy, bags and information).
In the longer-term residents will then be encouraged to:
a. Put their food in nude (bag free) as the garden organics help keep the bin clean
b. Buy Australian Standard compostable bags themselves (widely available and affordable via supermarkets)
c. Contact Council (as a last resort to collect compostable bags)
5. Creative Development Concepts
Icon Agency (the creative agency engaged) continue to develop the creative materials for Inner West Council’s FOGO roll out working alongside our own communications team.
Internal and community stakeholders will be engaged to ensure everyone is aware of FOGO and the what, when, why and how.
The key documents are summarised below and included in the appendix:
· Community Engagement and Change Communications Strategy – overarching detail and timelines
· Inner West Creative FOGO (Food Organics and Garden Organics) campaign Creative Concepts – developing ‘be a FOGO/Food Recycling Hero’ concept for our community
One of the important messages for our community is that many sustainability changes are unreachable for some such as owning an electric vehicle, offsetting carbon, installing solar panels (cost, home ownership), but FOGO is something we can all do and make a difference. It builds on behaviour levers and these are tapped in to when addressing perceived barriers to change;
· Social norming – everyone is doing it
· Social consistency – aligning to how others see me (e.g. environmentalist, progressive, innovator, conformist)
· Making it actionable – it's easy and we can all do it.
The communications and engagement plan focuses on the detail of what type of communication is delivered at what point prior to and post FOGO implementation to create excitement, raise awareness and ensure we reach all parts of our community.
The ‘Be a FOGO Hero’ concept aims to cut-through, raise awareness, activate and engage our community. It’s a visual identity that will be supported by public figures and community champions and ultimately all Inner Westies as it is promoted through a range of opportunities and channels.
6. Key Milestones
The following table is a summary of the key milestones until launch date.
Tender RFT (Request for Tender) 14-22 AWARDED Caddy supply, re stickering and printing, starter pack delivery and communications and engagement. |
February 2023 |
Processing Contract NEGOTIATED Veolia commences 9 Oct 2023 |
January 2023 |
Approval of Icon Behaviour Change Strategy |
13 April 2023 |
Peer review and feedback of behaviour change and comms and engagement via Environmental Strategic Reference Group |
25 May 2023 |
Tender RFT13-23 Compostable Bin Liners for Caddy and recommendation |
4 April – 9 June 2023 |
Approval of ICON Communication and Engagement Plan |
June 2023 |
|
|
EOI (Expressions of Interest) – FOGO Community Champions and briefing (panel evaluating submissions in June) |
19 May-12 June |
DECISION REQUIRED Red-lid garbage bin sizing – capacity analysis undertaken and options for upsizing (be decided at Council meeting) |
20 June 2023 Council meeting |
Icon final creatives – artworks and comms |
mid-July onwards |
Communication and Engagement FOGO is coming communications commence including media release, socials, letter to households, letter in rates notice, events, engagements etc. |
August onwards |
Letterbox drop to households introducing FOGO |
28 August 2023 |
Starter kit delivery to homes and bin re-stickering by Adpost (45 days / 9 weeks). Information and socials |
18 September 2023 |
Video (how to), FOGO ambassadors and community champions go live |
18 September 2023 |
Saturated comms with media releases, paid advertising, customer service screens, website info, posters etc |
2 October |
All houses to have received a green 240 litre FOGO bin |
2-9 October 2023 |
Service start - FOGO |
9 October 2023 |
Reporting and data – Tonnages, contamination reports, Audits (APC Anne Prince Consulting), resident surveys ongoing |
ongoing |
7. Other domestic waste service changes currently underway
Recycling Improvements
Collection - The Recycling collection (South Service area) contract was awarded to URM (United Resource Management). This will free up the two vehicles and 6 people to make up the FOGO collection team.
Bin Supply - A Tender was awarded to SULO for the supply and roll out and take back of recycling bins in the north area. The 2 x 120 litre recycling bins will be retrieved and a 240-litre yellow lidded commingled bin delivered. This will be scheduled across approximately 8 weeks and will conclude at the end of August 2023.
Communications - Adpost has been engaged to print and deliver the initial communication in the form of a letter to all affected households (16,986 properties) in the former Leichhardt Area the week commencing 12 June 2023. A second communication in the form of a postcard will be delivered two weeks prior to the resident receiving the bin. This postcard will be more detailed in what is required by the resident logistically; what, when why how.
Responsiveness – Two additional customer service/call centre staff have been engaged to respond to the expected increase in calls resulting from the recycling service improvement. A QR code has been added to communications to take residents directly to information on the website: Recycling - Inner West Council (nsw.gov.au)
Financial Implications
All budgeted for within grants and domestic waste operational budget.
1.⇩ |
Inner West - FOGO Community Engagement and Communications Strategy |
2.⇩ |
IWC Icon FOGO Creative |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Henson Park - Public Private Partnership - Licences
Prepared By: Matthew Pearce - General Counsel
Authorised By: Peter Gainsford - General Manager
RECOMMENDATION
1. That Council confirms that the outcomes and deliverables of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project as outlined in the Henson Park PPP Final Assessment are acceptable;
2. That Council continue to proceed with the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project as a Public Private Partnership with the AFL (NSW/ACT) Commission Limited;
3. That Council authorise the General Manager to:
a) certify that the Henson Park Licence for Use and Construction Licence, as part of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project, has been prepared in accordance with the Public Private Partnership Guidelines 2022;
b) confirm that there have been no material change to the Public Private Partnership of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project or its cost since the full assessment by the Office of Local Government;
4. That Council seek approval from the Office of Local Government to execute the Henson Park Licence for Use and Construction Licence in respect of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project.
5. That Council delegate to the General Manager the authority, if approval is provided by the Office of Local Government, to execute the Henson Park Licence for Use and Construction Licence in respect of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project.
6. That Council delegate to the General Manager (or his delegate) the authority to execute the Henson Park Deed of Agreement for Use in respect of the Newtown Jets with a term of 21 years noting that the AFL Henson Park Licence for Use also has a term of 21 years.
|
DISCUSSION
At its Council meeting on 13 September 2022, Council resolved:
That Council:
1. Confirm that the outcomes and deliverables of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project as outlined in the Henson Park PPP Assessment are acceptable.
2. Proceed with the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project as a Public Private Partnership with the AFL (NSW/ACT) Commission Limited.
3. Authorise the General Manager to:
(a) certify that all documentation, as part of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project, has been prepared in accordance with the Public Private Partnership Guidelines 2022; and
(b) submit all documentation to the Office of Local Government for assessment of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project as a Public Private Partnership.
4. Delegate to the General Manager the authority to negotiate a Heads of Agreement with the commercial terms to be reported back to Council for approval; and
5. Commit to entering into a Licence with the Newtown Jets in respect to the future sporting use of Henson Park
On 16 September 2022, the Initial Assessment of the Public Private Partnership (PPP) along with the draft Heads of Agreement was forwarded to the Office of Local Government (the OLG) for review.
On 23 September 2022, Council received a letter from the Australian Government, Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts (the Commonwealth Department). The letter confirmed an election commitment for the funding towards the cost of the Project and required Council to undertake a desk top review of the funding required for the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project. The desk top review was returned to the Department confirming funding in the amount of $2.5M.
A Priority Community Infrastructure Program Application (as part of the Federal Government’s 2022 election commitments for community infrastructure) has now been forwarded to the Australian Government seeking and applying for grant funding for $2.5M.
On 21 October 2022, the OLG provided a response to the Initial Assessment of the PPP and Heads of Agreement. No clarification was sought by the OLG in terms of their initial assessment. However, the OLG stated in the letter:
“OLG recommends that, as Council determines to proceed with the PPP, it ensures the governing body and the community are kept informed of key decisions, impacts and costs associated with the PPP. Council is also encouraged to ensure that any heads of agreements and leases it enters into provide the risk mitigation assurances the community expects.”
The OLG have confirmed that, in their initial assessment, the PPP is not significant and will not be referred to its Project Review Committee for review.
On 13 December 2022, Council resolved, at an Extraordinary meeting, to proceed with the Henson Park Redevelopment Project as a Public Private Partnership with the AFL (NSW/ACT) Commission Limited and referred an executed Heads of Agreement to the OLG for consideration (refer to the attachment).
On 22 December 2022, the PPP submission was forwarded to the OLG for full assessment.
On 1 March 2023 Council received a response from OLG, (refer to the attachment). The OLG again assessed and determined that the PPP is not significant and not high risk and that the project will not be referred to the Project Review Committee for review. The OLG also advised that no approval had been granted to enter into the PPP. The OLG further advised that if there was a material change to the PPP or its cost then the matter will require a referral back to the OLG and a re-assessment of the PPP.
Between March 2023 to June 2023 negotiations between Council and the AFL have occurred in respect of the Licences. There have also been related negotiations in respect of the Development Agreement (those privileged discussions are commercially confidential and are dealt with in the Confidential Report). In addition, Council and the Jets have negotiated a Deed of Agreement for use of Henson Park. As a result of the negotiations there has been no material change to the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project or its cost.
Ongoing Community Access to Henson Park
Council adopted a Plan of Management (POM) and Master Plan for Henson Park on 25 October 2022. Ongoing community access to Henson Park is an important issue for the community as the Park is a greatly valued public recreational asset. The POM has developed core objectives for the ongoing management of Henson Park and notes that the Park has three main categories of land use as defined by the Local Government Act 1993 (the Act). These categorisations are summarised in Table below
Land Categorisation Henson Park (Table 1 extracted from POM)
Council in its POM process has adopted a ceiling limit on the number of match games per year for both the AFL and the Newtown Jets. This ceiling limit provides clarity for all park users on access conditions as well as allow proper seasonal planning by the main sporting codes. Match days are capped at 20 game days per sporting code, per sporting season. This represents a total of only 120 match hours per year. This ceiling limit allows for additional sporting content to be planned for future years while still maintaining significant public access to the park for other recreational activities.
It is noted that the Park currently supports an off-leash dog exercise area which is designated as on leash when match games are played. It is critical to note that the dog off leash area has only been in existence since 2014 and that Marrickville Park located some 800m away also provides an off-leash exercise area for companion animals. Dog walkers are therefore not underprovided in terms of access to open space in this regard.
The AFL Licence for Use
The detailed terms of the AFL Licence for Use between Council and the AFL are as follows:
(a) Term - 21 years (this is the maximum period for a Licence of Community Land under the Act);
(b) Licence - A non-exclusive licence to use Henson Park in the following terms:
(i) 20 days for match games annually for ticketed community and elite Australian football (limited to 5 hours per day) over the Winter and Summer seasons (Match Days);
(ii) A seasonal licence for the Winter season (April to September) for community football;
(iii) Of the Match Days, half of the home games of the Sydney Swans AFLW are to be held at Henson Park;
(iv) Non-ticketed match games and training will be booked in accordance with the with principles and criteria in Council’s Allocation Policy.
(c) Licence Fee – The fee will be charged in accordance with Council’s Annual fees and charges for Henson Park:
(d) Mandatory Use - The licence to use Henson Park will be subject to the following ongoing mandatory use:
(i) use by the Newtown Jets;
(ii) a minimum amount of community use of the facilities;
(iii) the facilitation of junior sports; and
(iv) public access outside the playing surface during non-ticketed community match days that includes but is not limited to local residents and dog walkers.
The parties have reached an agreement in respect of the use of Henson Park and the Licence for use is ready to be executed (refer to the attachment).
The AFL Construction Licence
Henson Park is community land and is subject to the POM. The POM requires that a Construction Licence is required if works are to be undertaken at the Park. The Council, through the Construction Licence, grants the AFL occupation and use of a construction area to enable the AFL to undertake the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project. The parties have reached an agreement in respect of the construction of the Project and the Construction Licence is ready to be executed (refer to the attachment).
The Newtown Jets Deed of Agreement
Although separate to the PPP but in accordance with the Council resolution on 13 September 2022, Council has negotiated and prepared a Deed for use of Henson Park in respect of the Newtown Jets.
The term of the Deed is 21 years whereby the Newtown Jets along with the ALF are the primary users of Henson Park with other formal use requests by the Jets to be considered with regards to the ongoing management of the grounds as a premier sporting venue. It should be noted that the principles and criteria of this new Deed are similar to the current Deed with the Jets which has been in place since 2016. The 2016 Deed will be replaced with is new Deed.
The parties have reached an agreement in respect of the Newtown Jets use of Henson Park and as such the Newtown Jets Licence is ready to be executed (refer to the attachment).
The Guidelines and Final Assessment by the OLG
The Guidelines outline the requirements for Local Government PPP proposals. As the Project is deemed to be a PPP due to the AFL’s further financial contribution separate to Council and Government funding, the Council must not enter into such an arrangement to provide public infrastructure unless it has complied with the Guidelines. The OLG have confirmed that it considers the Project to be a PPP and is satisfied that the PPP is acceptable based on its current assessment. Council, therefore, must now submit the PPP contractual documentation (being the Henson Park Licences) to the OLG for final approval which will then allow the Council to enter into PPP with the AFL.
Certification by the General Manager and Council Resolutions required by the Guidelines
The Guidelines mandate the requirement that the General Manager must certify that Council’s PPP Documentation has been prepared in accordance with the Guidelines prior to any submission to the OLG. In addition, the certification will also confirm that since the previous full assessment of the PPP Documentation by the OLG there has been no major variation to the Project. The certification also seeks that the OLG provide an approval to execute the contractual documentation. Finally, the Guidelines require that such certification can only be authorised by Council resolution.
The proposed certification is to read:
“I, Peter Gainsford, General Manager of Inner West Council, hereby certify that the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project Final Assessment put forward by the Inner West Council to the Office of the Local Government for its assessment of the proposed Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment PPP has been prepared in accordance with the Public Private Partnership (PPP) Guidelines (January 2022).”
I further certify that there has been no material change to the Public Private Partnership of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project or its cost since the full assessment by the OLG.
In accordance with my certification, I seek approval from the Office of Local Government to execute the Henson Park Licences in respect of the Henson Park Grandstand Redevelopment Project.”
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Council has resolved on 26 October 2021 to contribute $500,000 towards the construction costs of the Project. There are additional costs associated with the engagement of a Project Manager ($487,000 excl. GST) and a Probity Advisor ($10,000 excl. GST) which will need to be funded in the capital works program as part of the 23/24 budget consideration.
1.⇩ |
Heads of Agreement |
2.⇩ |
Letter from the Office of Local Government dated 1 March 2023 |
3.⇩ |
AFL Construction Licence and Henson Park Licence |
4.⇩ |
Newtown Jets Henson Park – Deed of Agreement |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
THIS ATTACHMENT IS BEING DISTRIBUTED
AS A LATE SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA
C0623(1) Item 12
Heads of Agreement
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
THIS ATTACHMENT IS BEING DISTRIBUTED
AS A LATE SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA
C0623(1) Item 12
Letter from the Office of Local Government dated 1 March 2023
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
THIS ATTACHMENT IS BEING DISTRIBUTED
AS A LATE SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA
C0623(1) Item 12
AFL Construction Licence and Henson Park Licence
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
THIS ATTACHMENT IS BEING DISTRIBUTED
AS A LATE SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA
C0623(1) Item 12
Newtown Jets Henson Park – Deed of Agreement
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Leichhardt Oval Masterplan - Preliminary Concepts
Prepared By: Scott Mullen - Strategic Investments and Property Manager
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council endorse the public exhibition of the preliminary costed concepts for the Leichhardt Oval Masterplan. |
BACKGROUND
In 2020 a Plan of Management and Master Plan was adopted for Leichhardt Park that recommended the formalisation of a Master Plan for the long-term vision of Leichhardt Oval.
At the 10 May 2022 Council meeting it was resolved that:
1. Council begins work on formulating a new Master Plan for the upgrading and renovation of facilities at Leichhardt Oval in anticipation of an expected significant NSW Government financial contribution.
2. The Master Plan preserve and protect the heritage of the ground, including the Wayne Pearce Hill and Keith Barnes Stand, while providing the modern seating and facilities the ground desperately needs; and
3. The Master Plan is to include consideration of the following:
• The ground hosts a minimum of six Wests Tigers home games a year.
• A major new grandstand providing modern seating for professional sport.
• A Museum of Inner West Rugby League.
• Modern amenities including new change rooms, toilets, food outlets and screens.
• New function facilities.
• Improved parking.
• Opening the ground up to the public as a community centre during the week; and
• An upgrade of the adjoining Leichhardt Park Aquatic Centre providing improved gym, rehabilitation, and aquatic facilities for users of Leichhardt Oval and the community.
DISCUSSION
The purpose of undertaking the Master Plan is to establish a cohesive vision for planned upgrades and renovations of facilities at Leichhardt Oval, ensuring that the iconic oval can continue to serve the changing needs of the community and meet the demands of modern professional sporting venues.
The Master Plan will help to guide Council’s decisions around future uses of the site including concurrent upgrade of the adjoining Leichhardt Park Aquatic Centre and modernisation of grandstand amenities including change rooms, toilets, food outlets and screens. As a long-term planning document, the Master Plan will establish a framework for future uses and associated capital works, ensuring the continuation of Leichhardt Oval’s extensive history of hosting sporting and community events at both the local and professional level.
The Master Plan will provide clear direction to ensure the ongoing and future relevance of Leichhardt Oval as a compliant venue which can attract community and high-level sporting events and training; and maximises the use of all spaces, including increasing the use of the function rooms.
The key aims of the Master Plan are to:
· Formally acknowledge the history and culture of Leichhardt Oval and the important role it has played within our community since its establishment in 1934.
· Provide a multi-purpose high standard event, function and conference facility which is strategically planned and managed.
· Consider the needs of the community and key stakeholders including accessibility and inclusivity.
· Incorporate Environmentally Sustainable Design (ESD) principals into the Master Plan.
· Ensure an ongoing commitment to the management of the Leichhardt Park sporting precinct through the development of effective and innovative practices to minimise the impact that Leichhardt Oval may have on the surrounding area.
Following a public tender process, Cox Architects were awarded the contract to assist Council in the preparation of the Master Plan.
Community and stakeholder Engagement
The community and stakeholder engagement was developed to occur in three stages:
1. Visioning
2. Strategy development
3. Public exhibition
Stage 1: Visioning
To inform the preparation of the Master Plan, Council undertook user experience research to gather feedback from the wider community including current and potential sporting groups that utilise the oval, associated government institutions and relevant interest groups.
Community and stakeholder Engagement – Stage (a)
Council officers, consultants from Cox Architecture and Arup assisted in the extensive engagement process combining targeted one-on-one interviews with relevant interest groups and broader community engagement across three public pop-up sessions in December 2022, along with online surveys and interactive mapping through the Council’s ‘Your Say’ website.
The results of the engagement have been collated into the Leichhardt Oval Master Plan Engagement Outcomes Report (Attachment 1) which is also available on Council’s website.
The engagement period captured within this report was from 18 November 2022 to 14 March 2023.
Overall, the engagement process reached more than 370 participants from both within and outside the local area including residents, spectators, employees, athletes and other vested members across the community.
Feedback from this engagement has been reviewed, analysed, themed and included in the report and has been used to inform the preparation of preliminary concepts for the Leichhardt Oval Master Plan.
Consistent with the conversations throughout the engagement, the analysis of issues and ideas found:
· The community is passionate about building stronger neighbourhoods, they want to see better facilities for socialising in the public realm
· Finding environmentally and financially sustainable solutions were strongly expressed
· Transport, traffic, parking, and infrastructure provision are core community concerns
· Most of the transport related comments expressed a desire for better access to public and active transport options
Consistent themes that arose during feedback have been summarised below:
ACCESS
· Safe pedestrian access to/from the ground - closure of streets etc
· Dedicated event public transport services and wayfinding to/ from Leichhardt Oval
· Improved, expanded parking and circulation around the ground
· Emergency vehicle egress separate to crowd viewing areas
PUBLIC DOMAIN
· Retention of The Hill with minor accessibility and safety upgrades
· Preservation of trees surrounding the oval
FACILITIES
· Public facilities, DDA compliant circulation, accessible seating and amenities
· New stand to the north to include additional corporate offerings, covered seating
· Corporate facilities expansion and upgrades
· Museum and cafe at the gateway to the precinct.
· Council, or community run, cultural events outside of sporting windows
· Reconfigured southern end to include new undercover seating, amenities, food and beverage, grounds-keeping, storage, ticketing, merchandising
· Increased weather protected viewing areas (standing or seating)
Stage 2: Strategy development
Council worked with Cox to investigate and develop strategies in consultation with both internal and external stakeholders that considered:
ACCESS
· Accessible internal linkage to the hill from the western side
· Direct emergency vehicle access to and from the site
· Access from Leichhardt Oval to Oval #2 and LAPC
· Formalise broadcasting vehicles area on Mary Street
· 2/3 Level Structure for broadcast, waste and medical vehicles
· 2 storey car park on existing car park and connecting to oval
PUBLIC DOMAIN
· Leave open space including the Hill ‘as is’
· Upgrade both entries including new turnstiles to streamline access / egress
· Provide a propriety pedestrian zone - raised pedestrian areas at Mary Street entry
· Design public art that recognises the original local NRL teams
· Create a wall / walk that celebrates past Wests Tigers players
· Upgrade landscaping and preserve heritage trees and existing trees where possible
· New local and precinct wide wayfinding and information signage
· Install steps on the hill to allow movement in all weather conditions and reduce slippage
· Food / Beverage / Corporate / Beer Garden near Chapel Street entrance for range of events and kid friendly spaces
FACILITIES
· New Home End north stand including new Corporate facilities at player level
· New multi-level corporate facilities to south end of Western stand
· Upgrade Centurions Lounge Function centre and kitchen upgrade for multipurpose use
· Increase number of toilets and accessible toilets including Family room facilities
· Increase number of change rooms, allow for multiple teams / womens and mens games
· Increase and replace existing bench seating with numbered seating
· Provide permanent and temporary food and beverage options
· Upgrade Gate House to local NRL Museum
· Keith Barnes Stand to stay ‘as is’
TECHNOLOGY & SUSTAINABILITY
· Include nature-based design with green roof that can moderate temperature and boost PV efficiency
· Upgrade floodlights with newer technology with lower power density without reducing lux
· Upgrade Electrical Services
· Construct new Central HVAC Plant
· Install new Video Board
· Include Renewable Energy strategies including increased PV capacity on compatible surfaces and every roof, combination with battery system to allow for energy storage
· Design for facade modification including natural ventilation (louvres, operable windows, perforation etc.) for peak use
· Install up lighting in trees and replace all lighting to LEDs for energy sustainability
· Install a new Big Screen
· Provide for LED Advertising Boards to North East and South
Community and stakeholder Engagement – Stage (b)
With a number of preliminary concepts (Attachment 2) for the site now developed and costed following the visioning and strategy development, it is intended to undertake another round of broad community engagement and stakeholder meetings to seek feedback on the planning to date.
There will be an online survey through the Council’s ‘Your Say’ website over a 4-week period between 26 June 2023 and 23 July 2023, as well as three public pop-up sessions (Balmain, Leichhardt, and Rozelle) for the community to attend and discuss the preliminary concepts with staff and Cox consultants.
Stage 3: Public Exhibition
The feedback from this second round of community and stakeholder engagement will be analysed and considered in preparing and finalising a Draft Master Plan for the oval. It is intended to table the draft Master Plan at the August meeting of council, seeking endorsement to proceed to public exhibition for feedback. Following the final exhibition period, a further report seeking to adopt the Leichhardt Oval Master Plan would be presented to Council in September for consideration.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
A preliminary cost report has been prepared by Cox’s consultant team providing cost estimates for the various concepts that have been developed as part of the Master Plan project.
When fully developed, the Master Plan is intended to present a series of opportunities to upgrade facilities across the precinct. The concepts below have had preliminary cost estimates prepared, and can be considered for implementation independently or in combination, pending prioritisation and availability of funding.
Further refinement of the work scopes and estimated costs will be undertaken prior to finalising the Master Plan, including breakdown of the western grandstand upgrades into individual work packages for consideration.
A. Museum of Inner West Rugby League - up to $1.25M
B. Additional grandstand to the northern end - $21M
C. New and upgraded seating - $4.9M
D. Upgrades to the western grandstand – Moderate option $45.3M or Major option $98.3M
E. Additional parking - $12.3M
F. Improvements to accessibility and amenity around the oval + new LED floodlights - $5M
The 2023/24 Capital Works Budget includes $600,000 for the Leichhardt Oval precinct, providing opportunity to commence high-priority design, planning or minor works.
There is no further budget allocated at this time for any of the concepts that are currently proposed to form part of the Leichhardt Oval Master Plan.
1.⇩ |
Community and Stakeholder Engagement Outcomes Report Stage 1(a) |
2.⇩ |
Leichhardt Oval Master Plan - Preliminary Concepts |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Local Government Remuneration Tribunal -
Determination
of Mayor and Councillor Fees 2023/2024
Prepared By: Beau-Jane De Costa - Senior Manager Governance and Risk
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
1. That the Mayor and Councillor Fees, effective 1 July 2023, be set at the maximum level for a Metropolitan Large council being:
a) Mayoral Additional Fee $94,950
b) Councillor Annual Fee $32,590
2. The current Additional Fee for the Deputy Mayor, being $10,000 of the Mayoral Additional Fee, be re-confirmed.
|
DISCUSSION
The Local Government Remuneration Tribunal (Tribunal) has made its determination, under section 241 of the Local Government Act 1993, in relation to the fees to be paid to Mayors and Councillors.
The Tribunal’s Report and Determination provides details of the factors taken into account in its determination that an increase of 3 percent in fees for Mayors and Councillors is appropriate across the sector. The increase is effective from 1 July 2023.
In addition, Section 239 of the Local Government Act 1993 requires the Tribunal to determine the categories of Councils at least once every three years. This year, the Tribunal completed a review of categories and created two new categories of ‘Metropolitan Major’ and ‘Rural Large’. Inner West Council is classified as a ‘Metropolitan Large’ council. Additional information regarding the new categories and the factors taken into account to reach the determination of the 3 percent increase can be found in Attachment 1.
Pursuant to section 241 of the Local Government Act 1993, the fees for Mayors and Councillors in the ‘Metropolitan Large’ category have been determined as follows:
Category
|
Councillor/Member Annual Fee
|
Mayor/Chairperson Additional Fee* |
||
|
Minimum |
Maximum |
Minimum |
Maximum |
Metropolitan Large |
$19,760 |
$32,590 |
$41,960 |
$94,950 |
*The Mayor/Chairperson additional fee must be paid in addition to the fee paid to the Mayor/Chairperson as a Councillor/Member in accordance with section 249(2) of the Local Government Act 1993.
Council has previously resolved to pay the Deputy Mayor a fee of $10,000 per annum. The legislation requires that any fee set for the Deputy Mayor is taken from the annual fee payable to the Mayor. It is at Council’s discretion to determine the fee payable to the Deputy Mayor, if any.
This report recommends that Council adopt the maximum fees set out by the Tribunal on the following basis:
· Substantial size in geographic and population size of the Local Government Area;
· Substantial responsibilities associated with the annual budget;
· The wide scope, level and range of services delivered by Council; and
· Increased level of time and investment required for the Mayor and Councillors to fulfil their civic duties effectively.
Adopting the report recommendations will ensure the remuneration of the Inner West Council elected officials reflects the increased scope of responsibilities to undertake their civic duties in a large amalgamated Council.
Superannuation Contribution Payments
At the Council meeting held on 10 May 2022, Council also resolved the following:
That Council resolves for the Mayor and Councillors to receive superannuation contribution payments from 1 July 2022, in accordance with Section 254B of the Local Government Act 1993.
Superannuation is payable in addition to councillor fees. The superannuation contribution payment is paid at the same intervals as the annual fee is paid to councillors.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The 3% increase has been budgeted for in the 2023/24 Budget.
1.⇩ |
Local Government Remuneration Tribunal – Annual Report and Determination 2023 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Inner West Heritage Program
Prepared By: Daniel East - Acting Senior Manager Planning
Authorised By: Simone Plummer - Director Planning
1. That Council notes the update and progress on the heritage pubs project.
2. That Council undertakes early consultation with residents regarding the residential component of the heritage program.
3. That Council endorse the preparation of a draft Planning Proposal to amend the Inner West Local Environmental Plan 2022 for residential and substations Heritage Conservation Areas and Items.
|
DISCUSSION
The purpose of this report is to outline the proposed Inner West Heritage Program including:
· the matters ready to progress as amendments to the Inner West Local Environmental Plan 2022 (Inner West LEP), and
· the future steps that are scheduled for commissioning from July 2023 onwards.
Inner West Council is committed to protecting places of heritage significance. The Local Strategic Planning Statement and Local Housing Strategy contain actions requiring Council to review heritage significance across the LGA and inform amendment to the Inner West LEP and Development Control Plans.
The heritage review commenced in 2021 and focussed on the southern area of the local government area (LGA) as large areas of the north of the LGA have heritage protection, for example, Balmain, Haberfield, Annandale.
The review included heritage assessments conducted by independent consultants, GML Heritage, on Council’s behalf. Community feedback has provided further guidance to the scope. Collectively, the heritage program incorporates all GML Heritage recommendations and matters for consideration and will be progressed through future planning control amendments, including housekeeping matters as they arise.
Current Activity
Current work proposes to amend the Inner West LEP by mid-2024. The matters included in this work are those where the level of detailed heritage assessment has occurred to fully inform the proposals. Outlined below is a summary of each of three themes – Residential, Substations and Pubs. Attachment 1 provides maps depicting the proposed LEP amendments relating to these themes.
Theme 1 - Residential
Scope
The aim of the residential review was to identify areas and items of heritage importance and items in need of amendment. Analysis by GML Heritage identified several locations with heritage potential and undertook detailed assessment of these. Community feedback assisted in refining the scope, including the addition of two further HCAs and the modification to the boundary of another.
The GML Study recommended the preparation of a Planning Proposal to amend Schedule 5 of the Inner West LEP to:
1. Introduce nine (9) new Heritage Conservation Areas (HCAs):
o Petersham Hill, Dulwich Hill
o Campbell’s Dairy, Dulwich Hill
o The Parade, Dulwich Hill
o Woodlands Estate, Marrickville
o Terrace Garden Estate, Marrickville
o The Warren Estate, Marrickville
o David Street, Marrickville: ‘C66’ reorganised, extended and renamed to form:
§ Marrickville Market Gardeners Estate, Marrickville
§ Shrublands Estate, Marrickville
o Fredbert Street, Lilyfield.
2. Extend three (3) existing HCAs:
o Inter war group – three locations Hollands Avenue, Jocelyn Avenue and Woodbury Street, Marrickville: ‘C67’
o Austenham Estate, Lilyfield: ‘C62’
o Campbell Estate, Lilyfield: ‘C64’ and rename to “Campbell’s Broughton Estate” for clarity).
3. Reduce three (3) Local HCAs (removal of some properties from each):
o Rathgael Estate, Croydon: ‘C44’ - removal 6 properties
o Ivanhoe, Croydon: ‘C42’ – remove 1 property
o Fleet Street, Summer Hill: ‘C92’ - remove 1 property.
4. Revise Local Heritage Item Listings for:
o 56 Liverpool Road (28 Gower Street), Summer Hill (Hospital and outbuildings, including interiors): ‘I1614’ - due to redevelopment of part of the property.
o 44-46 Smith Street, Rozelle (School, including interiors): ‘I1487’ - due to additions that have occurred over time and do not contribute to the heritage listing.
5. Delist the following Local Heritage Items that no longer meet the threshold of listing based on their original significance:
o 40 William Street, Ashfield: ‘I409’
o 24A Railway Road, Sydenham: ‘I1750’
o 44 Wellesley Street, Summer Hill: ‘I1728’.
Attachment 2 provides a copy of the final Inner West Heritage Study – Residential (GML, May 2023) being the evidence base for a draft Planning Proposal. This is a refined version of the study that was exhibited in August 2022 and only contains content relating to the above scope. The previous draft study included recommendations to amend the Inner West LEP and included several matters for Council’s consideration. The latter require detailed investigation before potential heritage protection can be validated. These latter considerations form the body of work detailed below under the Future Steps of this report.
Engagement
The residential heritage matters outlined above formed a component of a consultation initiated in August 2022 which received some positive feedback from the community. It is proposed to restart early engagement for a further period of time in July 2023. If a favourable Gateway Determination is received from the Department of Planning for the planning proposal, a comprehensive statutory engagement program will be undertaken including letters to owners with maps, FAQs, summary statement of significance, talk to a planner pop-ups.
Theme 2 – Substations
Scope
In December 2021, Ausgrid contacted the Council to advise of the intent to delist several Section 170 heritage items. Section 170 of the Heritage Act 1977 requires State Agencies to establish and maintain a ‘Heritage and Conservation Register’ This is a separate process to the listing items and areas in a local environmental plan, under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.
An officer review identified that ten properties proposed for delisting were not listed in the Inner West LEP 2022 yet had potential important heritage values. Officers responded to Ausgrid in February 2022 and advised our intent to undertake a more detailed assessment with the aim of potentially listing relevant items in Inner West LEP 2022.
In addition to the list provided by Ausgrid, Officers undertook a review of all Ausgrid (legal owner Alpha Distribution Ministerial Holding Corporation) assets in the Inner West LGA to determine if other substations, which were neither listed under Section 170 nor in the Inner West LEP 2022, warranted detailed assessment. The review identified a further five substations of note which GML have confirmed have heritage significance and merit local listing as heritage items.
The 15 substations proposed to be included in the Inner West LEP are:
· 12 Collins Street, Annandale (Electricity Substation No. 122) – currently S170 listed
· 83 Norton Street, Ashfield (Electricity Substation No. 1497) – currently S170 listed
· 46 Fitzroy Avenue, Balmain (Electricity Substation No. 1464) – currently S170 listed
· 2 Mort Street, Balmain (Electricity Substation No. 1486)
· 4 Rawson Street, Haberfield (Electricity Substation No. 1505)
· 62 Mackenzie Street, Leichhardt (Electricity Substation No. 1489)
· 6A William Street, Leichhardt (Electricity Substation No. 1477) – currently S170 listed
· 26 Percival Street, Lilyfield (Electricity Substation No. 1500) – currently S170 listed
· 25A Cadogan Street, Marrickville (Electricity Substation No. 793)
· 200 Victoria Road, Marrickville (Electricity Substation No. 284)
· 26 Burt Street, Rozelle (Electricity Substation No. 1435) – currently S170 listed
· 7 Moore Lane, Rozelle (Electricity Substation No. 1449) – currently S170 listed
· 15 Reynolds Avenue, Rozelle (Electricity Substation No. 1506) – currently S170 listed
· 131 Victoria Road, Rozelle (Electricity Substation No. 1521) – currently S170 listed
· 2 Carrington Street, Summer Hill (Electricity Substation No. 1439) – currently S170 listed
Attachment 3 provides a copy of the two associated studies related to the substations proposals.
Engagement
Findings will be communicated to Ausgrid and Alpha Distribution Ministerial Holding Corporation and advise of the aim to proceed with a draft Planning Proposal to heritage list fifteen substations. Further engagement with the owners/operators and neighbours will take place during the statutory consultation phase.
Theme 3 - Pubs
Scope
The Heritage Pubs Study was prepared by GML Heritage in 2022 and identified 27 Inner West pubs for potential heritage listing. At the Council meeting of 25 October 2022, a Notice of Motion noted the Heritage Pubs Report and resolved to undertake early engagement with property owners and pub patrons and to prepare a draft Planning Proposal.
The list of pubs proposed to be included in the Inner West LEP are:
·
· North Annandale Hotel, Annandale*
· The Balmain Hotel, Balmain*
· Cat & Fiddle Hotel, Balmain*
· Cricketers Arms Hotel, Balmain*
· Dick’s Hotel, Balmain*
· Town Hall Hotel, Balmain*
· Unity Hall Hotel, Balmain*
· East Village Hotel, Balmain East*
· Duke of Enmore Hotel, Enmore*
· Queens Hotel, Enmore*
· Warren View Hotel, Enmore*
· The Milestone Hotel, Leichhardt
· The Royal Exchange Hotel, Marrickville
· Vic on the Park Hotel, Marrickville
· Carlisle Castle Hotel, Newtown*
· Kelly’s on King, Newtown*
· Sandringham Hotel (former), Newtown*
· Websters Bar, Newtown*
· Livingstone Hotel, Petersham*
· 3 Weeds Hotel, Rozelle*
· Bridge Hotel, Rozelle*
· Garry Owen Hotel, Rozelle
· Native Rose Hotel, Rozelle
· Sackville Hotel, Rozelle*
· The Welcome Hotel, Rozelle*
(*Denotes pubs that are in a Heritage Conservation Area)
The Pubs Heritage Study has been reviewed to:
· bring it up to date given the passage of time
· undertake minor editorial changes
· to note that Lewisham Hotel is progressing as a draft heritage item within the Parramatta Road Corridor Stage 1 Planning Proposal that has already received Gateway Determination from the Department of Planning and Environment (DPE) and is therefore ahead in process.
Engagement
In collaboration with the Engagement Team and Corporate and Strategic Communications, a patrons focussed consultation entitled ‘Love your Pub’ is under way. The consultation includes:
· A Your Say Inner West page where the community can upload stories of interest and images or videos
· All pubs in the Inner West have received coasters with a QR code redirecting to the Your Say page
· Press and social media campaigns are further encouraging participation.
In addition, Council have communicated with all proposed heritage pub owners and operators (licensees) offering to meet and discuss the proposed listing. The letter includes copy of the pub’s Heritage Inventory Sheet and Frequently Asked Questions.
Timeline progressing Residential, Pubs and Substations
Draft Planning Proposals are being prepared and tentatively scheduled to go to the Inner West Local Planning Panel in August and Council in late 2023. These are:
· Planning Proposal 1 – Residential and Substations Heritage
· Planning Proposal 2 – Heritage Pubs.
Following endorsement by Council, the two draft Planning Proposals will proceed to DPE for Gateway assessment. Following assessment, DPE will issue a Gateway Determination stipulating whether the proposals can proceed and may include a list of conditions for Council to meet before statutory consultation begins.
Once on statutory consultation, the draft amendments are a material consideration in the development assessment process. The statutory consultation period provides an opportunity for property owners and others interested parties to lodge formal submissions, which will be reviewed against the evidence base.
Future Steps
The Heritage Program will continue to focus on residential and commercial properties and will respond to the GML’s proposal that Council consider detailed heritage assessment of several items and areas. This work will initiate the detailed heritage assessment necessary to prepare an evidence base to inform amendments to Inner West LEP 2022 for the following:
1. Potential Heritage Conservation Areas (HCAs), Heritage Individual Items or Group Items:
· Additional locations in southern Dulwich Hill and Marrickville to determine if they have a sufficient level of retained integrity and significance to be potential new Heritage Conservation Areas (HCAs)
· Consider several properties in Dulwich Hill, Marrickville, Petersham and Lilyfield to determine if they have a sufficient level of retained integrity and significance to be locally listed items or group items.
2. Period buildings: GML Heritage recommended a review of several commercial precincts to investigate if:
· existing period buildings, now or following identified HCA investigations, would fall within an HCA and in this instance revise their descriptor to Contributory buildings within the DCP, or
· subject to further detailed assessment consider if they should be identified as an HCA, or individual or group heritage item.
3. Other studies: Consider undertaking additional studies that may inform future detailed investigations. This may include:
· municipal Depression-era public works throughout the local government area
· post war residential heritage
· preparing a thematic history of the local government area.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The heritage program is a multi-year approach to review heritage in the Inner West with some initial funding allocated in next year’s budget to commence this work.
1.⇩ |
Current activities - proposal maps |
2.⇩ |
Inner West Heritage Study - Residential |
3.⇩ |
Inner West Heritage Studies - Substations |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Minutes, Annual Report and EOI for new Independent member
Prepared By: Beau-Jane
De Costa - Senior Manager Governance and Risk and
Justin Lucas - Risk and Audit Manager
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
1. That the minutes of the Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee (ARIC) Meeting held on 5 April 2023 be adopted.
2. That Council thank Mr John Gordon, Chair of the ARIC, for his six years of service to the Inner West. |
DISCUSSION
The Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee (ARIC) is established in accordance with section 428A of the Local Government Act 1993.
The objective of Council’s ARIC is to provide independent assurance to Council by monitoring, reviewing and providing advice about the Council’s governance processes, compliance, risk management and control frameworks, external accountability obligations and overall performance.
ARIC Minutes
In accordance with the ARIC Terms of Reference, copies of the minutes of the Committee are to be provided to the Council.
The confirmed minutes of the ARIC meeting held on 5 April 2023 are attached.
Resignation of ARIC Chair and recognition of service to the Inner West Council
The Independent Member and ARIC Chair John Gordon has resigned from the ARIC Committee, with his last meeting being 17 May 2023. Mr Gordon remains a member of the ARIC until 30 June 2022.
Mr Gordon has been a member of the ARIC since its inception. Over this time, he has attended or presided over 32 ARIC meetings.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Funding to support the ARIC is included in the existing adopted budget.
1.⇩ |
ARIC Minutes - 5 April 2023 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Local Traffic Committee Meeting - 15 May 2023
Prepared By: Manod Wickramasinghe - Traffic and Transport Planning Manager
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
That the Minutes of the Local Traffic Committee meeting held on 15 May 2023 be received and the recommendations be adopted. |
ITEMS BY WARD
Ward |
Item |
Baludarri (Balmain) |
Withecombe Street and Ellen Street, Rozelle - Proposed 'Trucks Prohibited, Over 3t GVM' restrictions |
Fawcett Street, Balmain - Proposed 'No Parking' Restrictions |
|
Gulgadya (Leichhardt) |
Nil |
Midjuburi (Marrickville) |
Livingstone Road cycle way upgrades and safety improvements review |
728-750 Princes Highway, Tempe – Bunnings – ENR1/2021/0035 Special Condition 3 – Signage and Line Marking Plans – MOD20220424 |
|
Request for Resident Parking Scheme in Scouller Street, Marrickville (General Business) |
|
Request for update on traffic light upgrade at Alice Street corner of Edgeware Road, Newtown (General Business) |
|
Djarrawunang (Ashfield) |
The Esplanade, Ashfield - "STOP" sign and holding line |
Damun (Stanmore) |
West Street, Petersham – Pedestrian Safety Improvement Works – raised pedestrian crossing - Design Plan 10240-A Project 303082 |
West Street, Petersham at the intersection of The Boulevarde – Pedestrian Safety Improvement Works – proposed raised pedestrian crossing - Design Plan 10241 Project 303082 |
|
Request for update on traffic light upgrade at Alice Street corner of Edgeware Road, Newtown (General Business) |
|
Citybound bus stop on Salisbury Road, Stanmore (General Business) |
|
All Wards |
Nil |
DISCUSSION
The May 2023 meeting of the Local Traffic Committee was at Ashfield Service Centre. The minutes of the meeting are shown at Attachment 1.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Projects proposed for implementation are funded within existing budget allocations.
PUBLIC CONSULTATION
Specific projects have undergone public consultation as indicated in the respective reports to
the Traffic Committee.
1.⇩ |
Local Traffic Committee Meeting Minutes - 15 May 2023 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Planning Industry Professional Workshop Summary
Prepared By: Rachel Josey - Operations and Special Projects Manager
Authorised By: Simone Plummer - Director Planning
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
DISCUSSION
At the Council Meeting held on 9 May 2023, Council resolved the following:
1. That Council table a report at the June Ordinary Council meeting with a summary of the feedback received during the Planning Industry Professionals workshop. The report should include the following:
a) A catalogue of short, medium and long term service improvements that can be implemented to address the concerns and recommendations of the architectural and town planning sector; and
b) Key performance indicators and measurable data that can be used to identify how the organisation is performing in customer service and efficiency within development assessment
2. Receive a bimonthly report, tabled at an Ordinary Council meeting, monitoring improvement in customer service within the development assessment system, based of the aforementioned key performance indicators and measurable data.
3. Hold a further workshop inviting planning industry professional who work within the Inner West to specifically discuss how the heritage assessment processes can be improved.
4. Undertake an expression of interest process to identify architects and town planners with deep experience in the Inner West who can contribute their expertise to the development of the new Local Environment Plan and Development Control Plan.
This report addresses item 1 a) & b) of the above resolution.
BACKGROUND
On 27 April 2023 Council held a ‘Industry Professional’ Workshop at Marrickville Pavilion for professionals involved in the Development Assessment process at Inner West Council. This was largely comprised of architects, planners and draftspersons who regularly lodge applications for development with Council.
The Workshop was attended by 40 professionals and facilitated by Council’s Director of Planning, Senior Manager and Development Assessment Managers. Council’s Development Assessment Team Leaders were also in attendance.
The purpose of the Workshop was to –
· Hear from the professionals and their application experience (i.e. Customer Service, time frames, and outcomes)
· Tap into their professional experience/ideas
· Promote & strengthen our working relationship
The Workshop was separated into the following discussion topics -
· Pre-Development Application Service
· Development Assessment Service
· Experiences from other Councils
The Workshop presentation is included as Attachment 1.
During the workshop comments and feedback were noted, survey responses received and individual contributions from professionals were submitted. This feedback presented the following ‘themes’ –
A summary of the feedback provided is included as Attachment 2. The feedback has also been reviewed and analysed into a preliminary catalogue of ideas to provide short, medium and-long term service improvements. Some potential improvements require technical enhancements, increased staff training or input from other areas of Council.
Immediately following the Workshop the outcomes and feedback arising was provided to the Assessment Teams. The larger team has participated in a number of discussions since and they continue to participate in the review and exploration of options for service improvements.
Service Improvements
Below is a preliminary catalogue of short, medium and long term service improvements that will continue to be developed with respect to resourcing and timeframes. This will ultimately form an improvement plan which, along with key performance indicators (KPIs) which can be reported against on a regular basis to satisfy part 2 of the resolution.
Short Term / Immediate & Underway
· Emphasise as a culture and / or protocol that
• Phone calls are returned same or next working day
• Meetings with applicants are a normal and essential component of the assessment process
• Investigate the ability for the phone number display for Planners rather than displaying as private number to ensure customers know the origin of the call (work with ICT)
• Introduction of a phone contact (hunt) group available to provide general information and application process in the absence of the Planner
· Simplify Application form – to an owner’s consent and applicant declaration form
· Provision of greater information to customers at lodgement in terms of process and expectations. (e-Planning Team)
· Formalise and promote the opportunity for Applicants to request copies of submissions via a ‘customer request’, without the requirement for a GIPA application
· Co-locate heritage and urban design team with the wider DA team to improve communication within the department to ensure greater consistency and support a collaborative approach
· Host an Industry Professional Workshop in relation to heritage assessment (planning for this is underway)
Medium Term
· Review Delegations to the Inner West Local Planning Panel (IWLPP) to reduce the number of applications reported to the IWLPP (Report to IWLPP)
· Develop and provide training for all staff on a range of strategies to deliver an improved customer service within the development assessment context (knowledge and skill)
· Investigate an automated response to applicant & owner when key assessment milestones are reached (Tech 1)
· Increase and formalise the availability of specialists to attend meetings in relation to applications, PDAs included. (SLA with other teams and manage resources)
· Investigate tools to enhance consistency of decision making between assessment teams
· Enhance records management, supported by better tools to document communications with stakeholders
· Review both information and the manner it is provided to local business
· Promote greater engagement between the Development Assessment Team and Legal Team to be aware and understand outcomes and how these inform future applications
· Promote greater internal dialogue between the Development Assessment Team and other specialist Teams, including Building Certification in relation to issuing of Building Information Certificates (BICs).
· Promote staff professional development
· Embed a culture of staff mentoring for both junior staff and those recently recruited to IWC
Long Term
· Host an Industry Professional Workshop every 6 months
· Explore options to increase application survey responses
· Review notification policy with specific regard to re-notification.
· Explore options to prioritise GIPA applications for business proposals.
· Prioritise new DCP to address consistency and provide greater certainty to the controls.
· Review the Development Advisory and Application Policy, including the requirement for additional information to be submitted within 21 days.
· Review Council’s Pre-DA service
· Introduction of the Application Programming Interface (API) with the NSW Planning Portal
· Introduction of more efficient allocation and notification of applications
Continuation of projects already underway
· Continue the development of the new E-Planning Team with respect to the acceptance of applications and the provision of advice to stakeholders
· Review DA checklist & DA Document Requirements
· Hold bi-monthly information sessions for - persons ‘Lodging a Development Application’ and persons ‘Making a Submission’ (Council NOM).
· Hold Community Information Sessions for large-scale development
In addition to the above, Council officers are currently working on two projects to provide efficiencies within the development assessment process, these include:
- the implementation of an API (Application Programming Interface) between Councils IT system and the NSW Planning Portal to minimise the duplication of working in two separate places to process an application. The API will automatically push and pull information between the two systems.
- DA Process Improvement project – this project includes a number of enhancements to Council’s IT system to remove steps which don’t add value to the process, provide additional information to applicants and communicate to internal stakeholders as early in the process as possible.
Both of these projects have been funded by the Department of Planning.
Key Performance Indicators
Measurable data can be used to demonstrate success as performance and culture changes in a manner that supports organisational values. Tech 1 provides the assessment framework and data record for the DA process. Key milestones and events within this system have been reviewed to determine what data can currently or potentially be reported on. This is under analysis to determine which ones are likely to drive meaningful change.
Since the Industry Forum a number of formal and informal discussions and a workshop have been held with Council’s Senior Manager Customer Experience and Service Transformation and Team Leaders & Managers from the Assessment Teams. The KPIs below are outcomes of those discussions. While some of these cannot currently be reported upon, nevertheless implementation of them is underway as part of a change piece within the assessment teams.
NB: Unless otherwise specified all KPI days are working days
Key Process Steps |
Customer Experience KPI |
Notes |
Pre DA Minutes |
Letter sent within 10 days of meeting
|
Data collection subject to configuration of system |
Submit DA on Planning Portal to Lodgement in T1 |
100% Within 10 days
(Maintain current average of 7.5 calendar days) |
On NSW Planning Portal Excluding applicant’s time to provide any additional information required |
Call Applicant and/or Property Owner to advise responsible officer for the DA |
100% Within 10 days of allocation. |
Introduction, explain process, answer questions and case manage the process
Subject to configuration of system |
Neighbour Notification posted |
100% Within 7 days following payment of all fees |
Data collection of this KPI is available |
Internal referrals obtained |
80% response within 14 days |
Data collection of this KPI is available |
Site inspection |
100% inspections are recorded on the council record. |
Site inspections are a legislative requirement, (exceptions are modifications or following a pre-DA as a site visit has already been conducted)
Data collection is subject to configuration enhancement in the system |
Acknowledgment of receipt of submissions |
100% of submissions received are acknowledged in writing |
Current process exists - automated |
Progress update of significant milestones |
· Change in assessment officer (within 5 days) · Following the outcome of the acceleration panel (within 5 days) · Upon completion of a reassessment of amended plans (within 5 days) · Application exceeds 85 days (within 5 days) |
Reliant on system enhancement to enable notes to be captured, stamped, and reportable |
Determination |
Median within 85 days |
Based on current KPI
|
Next Steps
The Council resolution requires an update report every second month. It is proposed that work will continue on the KPIs identified above both as change behaviour pieces and in terms of creating reporting mechanisms and on going monitoring. The short / medium / long term service improvement catalogue will continue to be analysed and developed into a change plan to form part of this regular reporting.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
There are currently no financial implications, this may change as specific projects arise.
1.⇩ |
Industry Professional Workshop April 2023 - final |
2.⇩ |
Professional Industry Workshop Feedback - 27 April 2023 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Update report on the Implementation of the Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Act 2021
Prepared By: Graeme Palmer - Senior Manager, Regulatory Services
Authorised By: Simone Plummer - Director Planning
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
BACKGROUND
The Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Act 2021 (PSUP) was introduced on 1 November 2022. A report to Council on 14 March 2023 summarised implementation of the new legislation.
At the Council meeting held on 14 March 2023, Council resolved the following:
1. That Council receive and note the report and receive a report on the plan for compliance action on the Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Act 2021 by the June 2023 meeting.
2. That Council prepares an FAQ for the public about the new Policy, to be viewed by councillors first at a councillor workshop.
The FAQ document, as per point 2 of the Resolution, was presented at the Councillor workshop on 16 May 2023 and may be viewed on the Council website. They are reproduced at Attachment 1 of this report.
This report responds to the “report on the plan for compliance action” (point 1)
DISCUSSION
The Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Act 2021, was designed to “repeal and replace the outdated Impounding Act 1993 to create much stronger incentives for people to be responsible for their property in public ... Where property is left unattended in public, those responsible must attend to it within reasonable timeframes or face enforcement action, including strong penalties.
There are now much stronger regulatory and enforcement powers for authorities to deal with property left unattended in public as well as recover regulatory costs” extract from Public Spaces (Unattended Property) Guidelines For councils and other authorities 1 November 2022.
Following the introduction of the legislation, unattended motor vehicle requests, which includes caravans and trailers, increased approx. 230% (from 907 to 2562), when compared with the same period for the previous year, demonstrating strong community awareness and uptake of the legislation. There was no significant change in requests for unattended items (non-motor vehicle) such as shopping trolleys or ride share bikes.
In its implementation the Act has assisted Council in maximising turn over and increasing competition for parking spaces, however there has been no significant increase in vehicles removed from circulation.
Compliance Action Plan
Since commencement of the Act, the compliance processes have been reviewed and refined and it is anticipated that this evolution of compliance will continue as new information or variables are identified. Currently compliance activities can be categorised as either reactive or proactive.
Reactive activities
Operationally, Rangers are generally utilising a two-pronged approach for addressing unattended items.
Following a report of an unattended item Rangers will investigate and obtain pertinent information such as registration/ownership details if displayed, condition of the item or location etc.
Where the item is a motor vehicle officers can obtain ownership details via the NSW Police or Transport NSW Drives register.
One of the requirements to be considered ‘unattended’ is that the item is not under the direct control or supervision of the responsible person.
Supervision is not defined in the Act, Council has developed a working definition - that vehicles legally parked, registered and directly outside the owners dwelling and within prolongation of the site boundary will be considered “supervised”.
Officers are able to assess this requirement once owner’s details are obtained. At this point Officers will follow one of two actions-
1) Where ownership can be determined, Officers may issue a direction to the owner (and place a sticker on the vehicle) to remove the unattended property under Division 4 Section 28 of the Act.
2) Where ownership cannot be determined, Council staff are monitoring the item in accordance with the legislative timeframes with stickers being affixed to the items indicating Council’s intentions should the item not be removed.
Where items are not removed by the owner, Council may take possession of the item and hold for a minimum of twenty-eight (28) days after which they may be disposed of. This is done by Councils contractors Pickles. Items of value are disposed of via public auction.
All customer requests are managed via the above processes. Approximately 5% of vehicles require Council to take possession and remove from the streets, this is roughly the same when compared with the previous legislation. All other cases the item is removed or identified as under direct control or supervision.
Proactive Actions
Proactive patrols of locations identified as ‘hot spots’ are regularly under review including
· Hawthorne Parade, Haberfield
· Balmain Rd, Rozelle
· Lilyfield Rd, Rozelle
· Darley Rd, Leichhardt
· McKenzie St, Rozelle
As more customer requests are received other hot spots are likely to be identified and added to the list for proactive monitoring.
Shared Services Items
With respect to shared services such as shopping trolleys, there has not been a significant increase in customer requests. However, trolleys continue to be abandoned in highly visible public spaces such as prominent street corners and bus stops.
Under the Act, trolley owners such as supermarkets have up to 11 days to collect their trolleys once Council becomes aware of them. In most instance trolleys are collect within 24hrs. Abandoned trolleys are not only unsightly, they impact on the safe movement of pedestrians. The new legislation is not strong in this space and by and large management of shopping trolleys in public spaces are managed by a code of practice called up under the new Act and its regulation. The code of practice currently only requires that shopping trolleys are branded with contact details of the owner and in good working condition.
The Office of Local Government is forming a working group to examine amongst other things the implications of the code of practice. Successful management of shopping trollies in public spaces relies on preventing them from leaving the supermarket (immobilisers) or providing incentives for them to be returned (coin lock). This is likely to be a topic of discussion by the working group.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The Act contains new penalties ranging from $330 to $1320 for individuals and $660 to $2640 for corporations, that can be applied to non-compliance, which are designed to offset Councils costs incurred. Previously fines under the repealed Impounding Act ranged from $220 to $550.
Implementation over six months has not resulted in an increase in fines, although there is greater turnover in parking spaces, as envisaged by the Act. There has been an increase in administration under the Act, due to both the processes outlined under regulation and the increase in reporting by the community, however currently this additional administration is covered under existing resources.
1.⇩ |
Public Spaces - PSUP - Unattended Property Act 2021 - FAQ |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Camdenville Park upgrades and Peter Bulger Wetlands
Prepared By: Morna Scott - Capital Projects Manager
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report.
|
DISCUSSION
At the Council meeting held on 9 May 2023, Council resolved the following:
1. That Council receive a report at the June council meeting about opportunities to bring forward and complete planned works as soon as possible given the delay of several years to works at Camdenville Park, St Peters, due to WestConnex.
2. That Council reaffirm its support for the establishment of the Peter Bulger Wetlands at Camdenville Park and request funding options for the wetlands be included as part of the June report.
On 14 June 2022 a report was provided to Council on the intended reactivation of the Camdenville Park upgrade in preparation for the handover of the park area leased by Transport for NSW (TfNSW). Later than expected handover from TfNSW, in January 2023, delayed community engagement and the design, procurement and construction program that follows.
The project is now progressing well with community engagement and draft detailed designs completed including design options for the Peter Bulger Wetlands. Internal design review is underway to finalise scope for detailed design and tender.
The planned project schedule is the most efficient timing which can be achieved. The schedule considers the scale and complexity of the project, minimising disruption to sports users and meeting required seasonal timing of sporting ground returfing to ensure effective turf establishment during spring and summer prior to use during the winter sports season.
A staged approach is planned to enable use of recreation facilities as soon as possible. The planned schedule is as follows:
April 2024 |
Works commence at end of 2023 summer sports season Sporting ground closed for 2024 winter and summer sports seasons |
August 2024 |
Stage 1 complete: - Playground, BMX, pathways and landscaping western park area complete - Sporting ground construction complete and turf establishment commenced. |
March 2025 |
Stage 2 complete: - Sports turf establishment and ground open; amenities renewal, paths and landscaping eastern area of the park complete. |
Establishment of Peter Bulger Wetlands
Renaming of the Peter Bulger Wetlands received unanimous support during the community engagement.
The design options report for the wetland/detention basin area recommends:
- full revegetation of the basin with appropriate wetland species and retention of all existing trees
- replacement of the existing security fence with low level safety fencing, screened by vegetation
- pathway access from Bedwin Road including a section of elevated boardwalk aligning with the new Bedwin Road stairs
- secondary paths to provide added walking opportunities around the wetland
Due to the presence of contaminated fill material beneath the basin, the provision of a constructed wetland or bio-retention system is assessed as not feasible due to the high cost of managing and designing for the contaminated material, potential impacts on flood mitigation capacity of the basin and the impact of removing existing trees.
The proposed approach will achieve water quality improvements through planting along with ecological and recreational benefits in line with the park masterplan.
Preliminary estimates for the draft detailed concept include $1.2M cost for the wetland works and further additional funding in the order of $1.1M required for the general park works due to price escalation and additional scope.
The detailed design and tender phase will include quantity surveyor cost reviews and value management to minimise cost and additional funding required. The wetland works will be added to the scope for tender to enable pricing and potential scheduling as part of Stage 1 works.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The estimated additional budget required, including budget for the wetland works, can be funded through a number of internal existing sources.
An additional budget of $2.3 million is included in the draft 2023/24 capital budget for adoption. Suitable grant funding opportunities which meet the project time frame will be pursued to support Council funding where possible.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Inner West Council Service Charter
Prepared By: Melanie
Gurney - Senior Manager Business Excellence and Customer
Experience
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
DISCUSSION
The context for the creation of the Inner West Service Charter was a desire and commitment to improving customer service in line with Council’s Purpose and the organisational commitment in Council’s current year Operational Plan. The Service Charter was developed to provide a clear and concise outline of the operational standards of service the community can expect.
In November 2022, staff engagement activities were held to gather feedback on the development of the Service Charter. A total of 224 leaders across Council provided their input on how they want customers to feel and not feel when interacting with Council. In addition, 80 staff were involved in a more in-depth process focused on what Council could do to achieve this goal.
The Customer Service Review Sub Committee were also introduced to the process in a mini session at their November meeting and were very supportive of the planned approach.
A community engagement plan was developed aligned with the Council resolution to undertake broad community consultation to solicit as many ideas and feedback as possible. Feedback and insights gained through the engagement process helped to create a Service Charter that reflects how people want to feel when interacting with Council.
Community Engagement
Through the month of March 2023, the community were consulted via an online survey on ‘Your Say Inner West’, an in-person workshop at Petersham Service Centre and intercept surveys at the Customer Services Stalls on 4 and 18 March 2023.
The community were asked how they wanted to feel when dealing with Council and how they did not want to feel when dealing with Council. This was followed up by an activity to identify strategies and behaviours.
Promotion
The engagement activities were promoted through various channels including:
· Council’s website homepage banner
· Displayed on digital screens as well as printed posters with a QR code at Council’s Service Centres, Aquatic Centres and Libraries
· Emailed to over 700 customers who recently provided feedback
· Organic and paid Social Media posts
· At the Customer Service Stalls.
Outcomes and Feedback
The engagement activities provided valuable insights into the feelings the community want when dealing with Council.
The analysis of the community survey along with the data from staff and community workshops was blended to provide some key strategies to deliver the following positive and supportive interactions:
· Welcoming customers by providing a positive experience where they feel respected
· Making customers feel supported by addressing individual needs and fully answering questions using a solution-focussed approach
· Actively listening, showing empathy, being responsive and seeking feedback so customers are understood.
A detailed Engagement Outcomes Report is provided as Attachment 1.
CONCLUSION
The Service Charter was finalised and presented at a Councillor workshop, a Customer Service Sub-Committee meeting and staff workshops in May 2023.
The Charter has been emailed to all staff to embed service as a key performance tenet. The Charter will also be continuously promoted via all Council communication channels and touchpoints.
The Charter will form an important part of Council’s overarching Customer Experience Strategy which is currently under development.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
There are no financial implications associated with the implementation of the proposed recommendations outlined in the report.
1.⇩ |
Inner West Council Service Charter |
2.⇩ |
Service Charter Engagement Outcomes Report 20230523 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Update on Town Halls
Prepared By: Scott Mullen - Strategic Investments and Property Manager
Authorised By: Ruth Callaghan - Director Community
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
DISCUSSION
This report provides an update on the activities that are currently being undertaken to activate Council’s town halls.
TOWN HALL OPEN DAYS
Open days have already been held for Newtown Town Hall (Saturday 29 April), St Peters Town Hall (Saturday 6 May) and Petersham Town Hall (Saturday 20 May).
Council has programmed the following open days for the remaining Town Halls, with feedback from past open days incorporated into the planning of communications, presence, and activities at each site.
· Balmain Town Hall – Saturday 3 June, 11am to 1pm
· Annandale Town Hall – Saturday 10 June, 11am to 1pm
· Leichhardt Town Hall – Saturday 17 June, 11am to 1pm
· Ashfield Town Hall - Saturday 24 June, 11am to 1pm
NEWTOWN TOWN HALL
Open Day
Open Days were held on Saturday 29 April and Wednesday 3 May and included an information session for LGBTQ+ organisations in relation to the capital works being undertaken to make the building “fit for purpose” for the Pride Centre.
Exhibition Windows
Work has begun on converting the two windows facing into Pride Square as temporary exhibition spaces, with activities including scope, design, cost, and programme. Once completed the displays will be activated to promote the Pride Centre. The project will be managed by the Pride Centre PCG with curatorial input from the Living Arts team. The budget will be taken from allocated Capital works funds.
PETERSHAM TOWN HALL
Relocation of Council staff
Staff who have occupied offices at the Petersham Town Hall have now vacated the building, with the exception of Council’s Records team who will continue to remain in place in several offices on the Ground level fronting Frederick Street. They will also continue to administer the Records Archive within the basement, noting that it is not intended to activate any of the basement level at this time.
CREATIVE USE OF COUNCIL VENUES
This work is being led by the Living Arts team and the following is the timeline.
Stage 1: short-term pilot program
Residencies July to September 2023
Between November 2022 and April 2023 Council called for expressions of interest for short term residencies at our town halls. With the callout complete we are commencing the program, supporting individuals, collectives and organisations to access and book space. The short-term pilot program allows us to trial spaces, gather feedback from creatives and inform future processes.
Stage 2: development of long-term framework
Framework complete end of February 2024
Taking learnings from our open days, pilot program, industry research and creative spaces work to date, we will develop a long-term framework which will inform creative access to space including town halls. The framework will be open to ongoing improvement in collaboration with the creative sector.
Stage 3: Council implementation of long-term framework
Framework implemented March 2024 onwards
It is anticipated that once endorsed, the long-term framework will be implemented across Council, providing inclusive, accessible and equitable access to space for individuals, collectives and organisations in the creative industry.
VENUES FOR HIRE
All the Town Halls are currently available for hire as part of Councils ‘Venues for Hire’ program through the website at Venues for hire - Inner West Council.
Submissions received that do not fit the criteria for the Creative Use of Town Halls are being directed to Council’s Venues team for further assistance.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
Nit at this stage
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Investment Report at 31 May 2023
Prepared By: Daryl Jackson - Chief Financial Officer
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
BACKGROUND
A monthly investment report is provided to Council detailing the investment portfolio in terms of performance, percentage exposure of total portfolio, maturity date and changes in market value.
The monthly investment report includes details of the current proportion of investments that are non-fossil fuel investments and include details of progress in meeting the prevailing performance benchmark in respect of non-fossil fuel investments.
The investing of Council’s funds at the most favourable return available to it at the time whilst having due consideration of risk and security for that investment type and ensuring that its liquidity requirements are being met while exercising the power to invest, consideration is to be given to the preservation of capital, liquidity, and the return on investment.
Preservation of capital is the principal objective of the investment portfolio. Investments are placed in a manner that seeks to ensure security and safeguarding the investment portfolio. This includes managing credit and interest rate risk within identified thresholds and parameters.
Council determined to proactively invest in a non-fossil fuel investment portfolio.
Legislative Requirements
All investments are to comply with the following:
§ Local Government Act 1993;
§ Local Government (General) Regulation 2021;
§ Ministerial Investment Order dated 17 February 2011;
§ Local Government Code of Accounting Practice and Financial Reporting;
§ Australian Accounting Standards; and
§ Division of Local Government Investment Policy Guidelines May 2010
Council’s Socially Responsible Investments consist of Green Term Deposits from otherwise fossil fuel lending banks, such as CBA and Westpac and also long dated bond issues from a range of institutions and government agencies. These investments provide targeted funding to a wide range of green and socially responsible projects and initiatives. Council also utilises these investments to remain within the credit rating policy guidelines imposed by the NSW TCorp loan covenant requirements.
Certification
The Chief Financial Officer Daryl Jackson as the Responsible Accounting Officer has certified that the investments listed in the attached report have been made in accordance with Section 625 of the Local Government Act 1993, Section 212 of the Local Government General Regulation 2021 and Council’s Investment Policy.
DISCUSSION
Council’s investments are held in various investment categories which are listed in the table below. Council’s investment portfolio size is $222.4m. All Socially Responsible Investments (SRI’s) are investments that comply with the Non-Fossil Fuel standards. Council’s portfolio had a return 3.07%, against the UBSWA Bank Bill Index Benchmark (3.53%) on a marked-to-market basis. For the past 12 months, the portfolio has returned 3.34% on a marked-to-market basis.
Without marked-to-market influences, Council’s investment portfolio yielded 4.01%pa for the month, up from 3.95% pa in April. This is based on the actual interest rates being received on existing investments and excludes market value changes of the securities/deposits.
The valuations on Council’s long dated fixed rate bonds slipped during the month as long-term market rates increased. As interest rates rise/fall the dollar valuations of existing bonds fall/rise in the market. While a bond’s (or FRN’s) market value may drop below its face value (or par value) during the life a security, providing Council does not sell the security and the issuer is sound (which all of Council’s holdings are) then the bond’s market value will come back to the face value by the time it matures.
Change in the value of our portfolio
During May, due to the limited availability of non-fossil fuel investment products in the month - Commonwealth Bank of Australia is still not accepting new funds into its Green investment product, and Westpac’s offering is a minimum investment period of 6 months with a lower return; no new investments were entered into during the month of May 2023.
With the assistance of our investment advisor, we are constantly requesting Commonwealth Bank of Australia open their Green investments again.
· Change in value
o Emerald Reserve Mortgage $11.7k (amortised face value received)
Emerald Reserve Mortgage (purchased by the legacy Marrickville Council) maturing in August 2051 and August 2056 is categorised as greater than 1 year term to maturity category and continues to be outside policy.
Council’s entire investment portfolio remains invested in non-fossil fuel lending ADIs (51% of portfolio) and socially responsible investments (49% of portfolio).
The attachments to this report summarise all investments held by Council and interest returns for periods ending 31 May 2023.
The Current Market value is required to be accounted for. The Current Market Value is a likely outcome if Council were to consider recalling the investment prior to its due date.
All investments held in the month of April were in accordance with the Local Government Act, Local Government Regulations and the Inner West Council Investment Policy.
The External / Internal Restrictions and Working Funds Table (above) reflects the amount of total cash, bank and investments as at 31 May 2023.
All funds have been allocated as laid out in the adopted 2021/22 Operating Budget and Long-Term Financial Plan.
The performance chart over the page shows Council’s rolling 12 monthly return versus benchmark over the past 5 years. Each data point is the 12 month return for the stated month end.
Council’s investment performance had reflected the downward trend in interest rate markets over recent years accelerated by pandemic related interest rate cuts. With inflation pressures building, interest rates increased sharply over much of 2022, causing negative marked-to-market returns on existing bonds and FRNs over that period, however market rates have largely stabilised and the higher rates being received on new investments and FRN rate resets are flowing through to the rolling 12 month figure which is exceeding the benchmark’s performance again.
Domestic issues
§ The latest jobs data revealed a fall in employment and a rise in the unemployment rate, from 3.4% to 3.7%, which taken together suggest that the recent period of extreme labour market tightness may now be starting to unwind.
§ Wages growth rose a slightly weaker than expected 0.8% quarter-on-quarter taking annual growth to a slightly stronger than expected 3.7% year-on-year. This was the fastest annual increase since 2012 but is still not regarded by economists as a wages breakout worthy of another rate hike on its own.
§ Consumer confidence surveys are near their three year lows reflecting the sharp increase in interest rates over the year and not helped by the absence of handouts for most Australians in the federal budget. It continues to remain well below business confidence and warns of softer conditions ahead as the post-Covid reopening boost and pent up demand wears off.
§ Consumers are curtailing their spending on discretionary goods due to the RBA’s rate hikes and cost of living pressures. This is a key indicator that the RBA looks at leading some economists to predict the RBA will leave rates on hold in June.
Interest Rates
· At its May meeting the RBA rose the cash target to 3.85%, noting that further tightening of monetary policy may be required to ensure that inflation returns to target in a reasonable timeframe, currently expected to be mid-2025, but that will depend upon how the economy and inflation evolve.
§ At the end of May, the market was pricing in another rate hike over the coming three months to take the cash rate to 4.00%. Rate cuts are being priced in as early as 2024, implying the markets doubt the RBA’s expectation that inflation will not be tamed until mid-2025:
In May, term deposit rates across the 1 to 60 month range increased by an average of 25 basis points, mirroring the RBA’s rate hike at the start of the month, with the biggest jump across the 3 to 12 month area:
1.⇩ |
Inner West Council Investment Report - May 2023 |
2.⇩ |
Inner West Council Economic & Investment Portfolio Commentary - May 2023 |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Updated Annual Disclosure of Interest Returns 2021-22
Prepared By: Beau-Jane De Costa - Senior Manager Governance and Risk
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
DISCUSSION
Council’s Code of Conduct requires Councillors and Designated Persons to prepare and submit returns of interest to the General Manager:
1. Within three months of being elected or becoming a designated person; and
2. Annually (within three months of the start of each financial year); or
3. If, at any time you become aware of any new interests that need to be disclosed, you must submit a new return within three months of becoming aware of the interests.
In accordance with point 3 above, the following Councillors have submitted amended disclosures which are now tabled before Council:
1. Councillor Zoi Tsardoulias
2. Councillor Mat Howard
3. Councillor Chloe Smith
4. Councillor Kobi Shetty
In addition to being publicly available on request, the returns are also published on Council’s website. A general redaction of applicable private details which may include things like, signatures, primary residing addresses, specific financial information or family member details has been applied to these forms, in accordance with the Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
There are no financial implications in relation to the tabling of updated amended disclosures.
1.⇩ |
Amended Disclosure Pecuniary Interests - Clr Zoi Tsardoulias - 2021-2022 - Redacted |
2.⇩ |
Amended Disclosure Pecuniary Interests - Clr Mat Howard - 2021-2022 - Redacted |
3.⇩ |
Amended Disclosure Pecuniary Interests - Clr Chloe Smith - 2021 - 2022 - Redacted |
4.⇩ |
Amended Disclosure Pecuniary Interests - Clr Kobi Shetty - 2021-2022 - Redacted |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion to Rescind: C0523(1) Item 7 Fishing along Foreshore Reserves - 9 May 2023
From: Councillors John Stamolis, Kobi Shetty and Liz Atkins
MOTION
We, the abovementioned Councillors, hereby submit a Notice of Motion to rescind Council’s resolution of 9 May 2023 C0523(1) Item 7 Fishing along Foreshore Reserves, and propose the alternative Motion be adopted as follows: 1. That Council in consultation with residents, assess impacts and risks associated with fishing activities and develop solutions to minimize these impacts and risks; 2. That Council convene an onsite meeting with local residents, General Manager and ward councillors - as per resolution of November 2021 to consider issues that have been raised by the community. 3. That Council consult with residents and report on fishing activities along reserves in Balmain East on a half-yearly basis. |
Background
Council resolved on 9 May 2023:
That Council maintain current servicing and management of foreshore parks.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Cycling Infrastructure Signage, Designation and Enforcement
From: Councillor Marghanita Da Cruz
MOTION
1. That Council write to Transport for NSW seeking clarity on the meaning of road markings and signs, in particular, is the Booth Street separated lane at Whites Creek a bike path or bike lane?
2. That Council notes City of Sydney describes them, as a cycleway – for use of bicycles only. e.g., Bourke St cycleway is a bike path.
3. That Council bring back a report of the cost and scope to undertake an audit of Cycling Infrastructure and Routes including safety, signage, road markings, shade and crash barriers etc.
4. That Council seek clarity whether Council or the police have the delegation to enforce laws and regulations related to cycling (and rolling) including why did council or police not take quicker action including inspection, liaison and an emergency detour.
5. That Council notes the large embedded energy amount of rare materials and road space of electric cars compared to that of bicycles and other small rolling devices. So, Council should give them higher priority.
|
Background
On Saturday 20 May there were reports to Facebook that a vehicle was obstructing the separated cycleway on Booth St Annandale on the curve at the Bridge over White’s creek. See Twitter post https://twitter.com/joelmcourtney/status/1659757307553792001
The vehicle was reported to police and had been there since Thursday morning. The police promised to tow it away on Sunday. Following further reports to Council, the vehicle was still there on Tuesday evening.
Council arranged for our contractors were eventually to tow the vehicle out of the lane on Wednesday. This occurred after further phone calls to Council. Some damage to the concrete forming the separated cycleway was reported.
We need clarity of jurisdiction between police and council for dealing with vehicles in on road cycle lanes and where bicycles can be parked.
Road Markings
Car obstructing “Cycleway” which prompted
this NOM.
Photo Robert Moore, May 2023
From NSW Government Website: Bicycle lanes and shared paths
Know the difference between bicycle lanes, bicycle paths and shared paths in NSW. Take extra care in these areas.
Bicycle lanes
Bicycle lanes are designed for
bicycles. Signs
and road markings show you where they are.
When a bicycle lane is marked on the road, bicycle riders must use it, unless it’s not practical to do so.
Bicycle lanes start with either a sign or a road marking with both a picture of a bicycle and the word ‘Lane’.
Bicycle road markings are displayed along the bike lane to remind drivers and bicycle riders to stay within their lanes.
A bicycle lane ends with a sign or a road marking with a picture of a bicycle and the words ‘Lane end’. A bicycle lane also ends at an intersection (unless it’s at the unbroken side of the continuing road or continued across the intersection by broken lines) or at a dead end.
You can drive in a bicycle lane to avoid an obstruction. You can also drive in a bicycle lane for up to 50m to:
• enter or leave the road
• overtake another vehicle turning right or making a U-turn
• enter a lane from the side of the road.
If you need to drive in a bicycle lane, take extra care and check your surroundings for bicycles.
Bicycle paths
Bicycle paths are different from bicycle lanes. It’s optional for bicycle riders to use a bicycle path.
Bicycle paths start with a ‘Bicycle path’ sign or a road marking. They run alongside a road or on off-road areas.
Bicycle paths can also be used by:
• people using skateboards, foot scooters and rollerblades
• people who use wheelchairs or mobility scooters
• postal workers on motorcycles.
Other vehicles can only drive on a bicycle path if they’re entering or leaving a road, or if there’s a sign saying they can. When driving on a bicycle path, you must give way to all other road users on the path.
Shared paths
Shared paths can only be used by bicycle riders and pedestrians.
On shared paths, bicycle riders must:
· keep to the left (unless it’s not practical).
· give way to pedestrians. This means slowing down and even coming to a stop if necessary.
· keep to the left of any oncoming bicycle rider.
Riders of skateboards, foot scooters and rollerblades must:
· keep to the left (unless it’s not practical)
· give way to all other pedestrians.
Source
https://www.nsw.gov.au/driving-boating-and-transport/roads-safety-and-rules/road-lanes-lines-markings/bicycle-lanes-shared-paths
(viewed 28 May 2023)
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Leading a Reform Agenda on Waste
From: Councillor Marghanita Da Cruz
MOTION
1. That Council notes councils have a key role to play in reducing waste and its impact on the environment 2. That Council notes across the Sydney metropolitan area, 55 per cent of household and commercial waste goes to landfill each year, resulting in loss of valuable resources, costing businesses and households more than $750 million in waste levies each year. 3. That Council will work with other Sydney councils to a) reduce waste; b) improve environmental outcomes where waste has to be processed; c) find solutions for the residue that is left; and d) coordinate our advocacy, communications and collective buying power to bring the benefits of scale, efficiency and industry confidence. 4. That Council write to the NSW Government to invest the revenue from its waste levy for council and industry initiatives that: a) accelerate the transition to a circular economy; b) build the waste infrastructure needed to meet the growing pressures of population growth, loss of landfill capacity and a lack of competition in the sector; c) educate and support communities to reduce waste; and d) set the waste levy at an appropriate level with realistic hypothecation allocation, to streamline planning approvals for infrastructure, and to increase clarity and efficiency of licensing procedures. 5. That Council write to the Commonwealth Government to expedite bans on materials that cannot be recycled or recovered, and to increase extended producer responsibilities including labelling to specify recycled content in product and packaging. 6. That Council work with the other tiers of government to ensure the delivery of infrastructure solutions locally to reduce waste hauled long distances or to landfill. |
Background
Across Australia, people are asking for more ambitious action on climate change. Reducing waste and its impact on the environment is one of the key actions councils can take to lower our emissions.
Across the Sydney metropolitan area, 55 per cent of household and commercial waste goes to landfill each year, resulting in loss of valuable resources, costing businesses and households more than $750 million in waste levies each year.
Sydney councils must meet ambitious resource recovery and waste reduction targets, while also meeting the community’s expectations for uninterrupted services and public health outcomes. The time has long passed when councils collected rubbish and transported it to a landfill where it would slowly rot away.
Achieving the overhaul of the industry that is needed requires strategic input from Mayors, Councillors, GMs/CEOs and councils' officers.
Providing viable waste services for the community is no longer solely an operational issue for council staff to manage. Industry-wide changes include a limited number of suppliers, a lack of processing infrastructure and a shortage of readily accessible waste collection and transfer sites. These changes present all Sydney councils with the prospects of rising costs, increasing truck movements and resource recovery rates that are static at best. Few options exist for increased efficiency or resource recovery improvements, or to reduce landfill.
The original drivers of public health and hygiene have been supplemented by the need to reduce pollution, lower carbon emissions, and recover and re-use resources. Collecting waste is just part of the picture; Councils must make strategic decisions about where this waste will go.
The last 20 years have seen significant positive change. Recycling has been introduced for glass, hard plastics, paper and cardboard. There are separate collections for mattresses, electronic waste, tyres, clothing, mobile phones, batteries and chemicals. Landfills capture methane to generate energy. There will soon be collections for food waste and/or food and garden organics.
In spite of councils’ successes, waste processing and disposal have not kept pace with recent changes, yet the population is growing and waste generation rates continue to increase. Most Sydney councils must pay to haul recyclable materials and waste far outside their local area, and new transfer capacity is difficult to secure due to cost and availability of appropriately zoned land.
Data shows that we will not be able to meet NSW and Commonwealth targets with our current systems. Even with the highest efficiencies, progress in domestic waste collection and recovery will be impossible without major changes. These transitions will be expensive. The Waste Levy on landfill is an incentive to recycle, but in a failing market just adds to the costs that Council must charge the community. Only a around 7 per cent of around $800 million in annual waste levy revenue comes back to councils and the waste industry through contestable grants to fund improvements. Councils will not receive a fair share of funding, despite being asked to meet government targets and transition to a circular economy.
I attended the Metropolitan Sydney Mayoral Summit on Waste on 18 May 2023 to discuss what councils can do to contribute solutions to these concerns. The Sydney Mayoral Summit was convened by Southern Sydney Regional Organisation of Councils (SSROC) on behalf of Resilient Sydney, which our council supports.
Together we heard from the waste industry, NSW EPA and Federal Government representatives, and Sydney Mayors about initiatives and areas of influence where councils can work together.
Australian Packaging Covenant https://www.dcceew.gov.au/environment/protection/waste/plastics-and-packaging/packaging-covenant
Australasian Recycling Label https://recyclingnearyou.com.au/arl/
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
ATTACHMENTS
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Council to Display First Nations Map, State from the Heart and Torres Strait Flag in Council Chambers
From: Councillor Marghanita Da Cruz
MOTION
1. That Council display the Map of Indigenous Australia.
2. That Council display the Image of the Uluru Statement from the Heart in the Council Chamber.
3. That Council fly the Torres Strait Flag in the chamber alongside of the Aboriginal Flag.
4. That Council bring back a report on adopting traditional place names in our correspondence.
|
Background
Map of Indigenous Australia
“Australia's First Peoples have been living on the Australian continent for Millenia. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australia is made up of many different and distinct groups, each with their own culture, customs, language and laws. They are the world’s oldest surviving culture; cultures that continue to be expressed in dynamic and contemporary ways.”
“This map attempts to represent the language, social or nation groups of Aboriginal Australia. It shows only the general locations of larger groupings of people which may include clans, dialects or individual languages in a group. It used published resources from the eighteenth century-1994 and is not intended to be exact, nor the boundaries fixed. It is not suitable for native title or other land claims. David R Horton (creator), © AIATSIS, 1996.
No reproduction without permission.”
Map can be viewed and purchased at https://aiatsis.gov.au/explore/map-indigenous-australia
Matching postcodes to traditional place names
Australia Post have recently launched a campaign that allows people to include the traditional name of places in the address field. This is one way that you can acknowledge that places are firstly Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander places. Source: https://aiatsis.gov.au/whose-country
Uluru Statement from the Heart
· 2010 Prime Minister Julia Gillard establishes the Expert Panel on the Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples in the Constitution.
· 2012 Expert Panel Report finds strong public support for constitutional recognition and recommends removing existing constitutional references to race in ss 25 and 51(xxvi), inserting a statement of Indigenous recognition into the Constitution, giving the Commonwealth Parliament a new power to make laws about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, creating a constitutional ban on racial discrimination and inserting a provision recognising Indigenous languages.
· 2013 The Gillard government, with support from the Opposition, passes the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples Recognition Act 2013, to provide an interim form of recognition of Aboriginal people.
· 2014 Parliament forms a joint select parliamentary committee, chaired by Senators Ken Wyatt and Nova Peris, to advance the work of the Expert Panel.
· 2015 Indigenous Leaders meet with Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and Opposition Leader Bill Shorten at Kirribilli House and issue the Kirribilli Statement. In response, the Prime Minister and Opposition Leader establish the Referendum Council.
· 2016-17 The Referendum Council runs 13 First Nations Regional Dialogues to discuss options for constitutional reform.
· 2017 The Referendum Council holds a National First Nations Constitutional Convention where delegates draft and overwhelmingly endorse the Uluru Statement from the Heart which calls for a constitutionally entrenched First Nations Voice to Parliament, and a Makarrata commission to oversee a process of treaty-making and truth-telling. The Turnbull government rejects the call for a Voice to Parliament.
· 2018 A Joint Select Committee of Parliament finds the Voice is the only viable recognition proposal and recommends that the government ‘initiate a process of co-design [of the Voice] with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
· 2019 Minister for Indigenous Australians, Ken Wyatt, announces a ‘co-design’ process to determine the structure and functions of the Voice. The constitutional enshrinement of the Voice was excluded from the terms of reference.
· 2021 The Uluru Statement wins the Sydney Peace Prize with co-laureates Pat Anderson, Megan Davis and Noel Pearson.
· 2022 Anthony Albanese is elected as the new Prime Minister of Australia and reconfirms his commitment to implement the Uluru Statement in full during his victory speech upon the Australian Labor Party defeating the Liberal National Party in the May federal election.
· October 2022 The Inner West is partnering with the Sydney Alliance to provide the training program and coordinate the recruitment campaign as well as making town halls and facilities available for the training free of charge.
· 2023 Legislation which Proposes an alteration to the Constitution to recognise First Peoples of Australia by establishing an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice to make representations to the Parliament and the Executive Government of the Commonwealth on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in introduced into Federal Parliament. https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/bd/bd2223a/23bd080
The Uluru Statement from the Heart and its history can be read here https://ulurustatement.org/the-statement/
“Thomas Mayor is a Torres Strait Islander man who lives on Larrakia Country in Darwin. A father of five children, he is a wharfie and union official for the Maritime Union of Australia. He has tirelessly advocated for the proposals in the Uluru Statement from the Heart and is the author of four bestselling books. His First book, Finding the Heart of the Nation: The journey of the Uluru Statement towards Voice, Treaty and Truth, tells his story, the story of the Uluru Statement, and the stories of the remarkable people he met on his campaigning journey. A children’s version, Finding Our Heart, was published in June 2020. In 2021, Thomas released a children’s book, Freedom Day: Vincent Lingiari and the Wave Hill Walk-Off, published by Bright Light; and Dear Son – Letters and reflections from First Nations fathers and Sons. ” Blak & Bright First Nations Literary Festival, https://blakandbright.com.au/artist/thor/mas-mayo (viewed 2 June 2023)
Australian Flags lists these Special Days for flying flags
· 27 May to 3 June — National Reconciliation Week– 27 May as the anniversary of the 1967 Referendum which successfully removed from the Constitution clauses that discriminated against Indigenous Australians and 3 June as the anniversary of the High Court decision in the Eddie Mabo land rights case of 1992.
· July, nominated week — NAIDOC Week (originally an acronym for National Aboriginal and Islanders’ Day Observance Committee, the acronym has since become the name of the week) – NAIDOC Week is held every year to celebrate and promote a greater understanding of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and culture
Source - 3rd edition of Australian Flags https://www.pmc.gov.au/sites/default/files/resource/download/australia-flag-booklet-fa-accessible-150dpi.pdf
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Customer Service
From: Deputy Mayor Philippa Scott
MOTION
1. That Council note that further to the Customer Service Charter on this agenda, the Customer Experience Strategy, will be provided to Council in September for endorsement to go on public exhibition.
2. That Council note that further to the recent training opportunities for staff, a key item in the Customer Experience Strategy will need to be an organisational-wide culture uplift to be highly responsive, highly flexible, and highly empathetic, with metrics that include:
a) Quick responses to emails, phone calls, and online service requests, with information provided in clear, plain English; b) Making proactive phone calls when residents reach out in other ways, both to understand and to follow up on issues raised; c) Requests assigned to a single case manager who is responsible for gathering and assessing information, following up interim information, keeping residents informed at regular intervals, and finding and confirming solutions; and d) Qualitative review of customer interactions for their consistency with our stated values of being here to serve the community, with an emphasis on responsiveness, flexibility and empathy.
3. Establish a Facebook Online Customer Service page to exist separately from the Inner West Council’s organisational Facebook page. The purpose of the Online Customer Service page is to:
a) Respond to resident requests on Facebook when “tagged”; b) Join local resident groups and respond to issues; and c) Note the Customer Advocate page is not a communications and promotions tool, but a customer service tool. A report is to be brought back to Council in August on how this will operate in considering points a, b and c above.
4. Establish a mobile customer service outreach team: a team of staff and a branded van to bring Council administration directly to ratepayers, with a roving schedule for council staff to be accessible in locations such as shopping centres, council recreation facilities such as libraries, aquatic centres, sporting grounds, festivals, and major transport stops such as train stations and ferries during peak travel time. The outreach team will cover not only 9am-5pm Monday to Friday but also after hours and weekends.
5. Increase the customer service stalls from 26 to 48 per year, and rotate them into new locations including shopping precincts and transport stops as well as the town squares and parks
a) Note that with more regularised activity, and providing the forward schedule in our monthly newsletters, letterboxing promotion may not be needed which would decrease the cost per annum; and b) Note that reporting on the engagement with the stalls is to continue through the Customer Service Committee, and if changes to the schedule are recommended, they will come to Council.
6. Note that further investment $350k will be necessary to cover the increased activity in points 4 and 5, which will be moved as an amendment to the budget.
7. Staff report in September with the Customer Experience Strategy, on the adoption of new technologies to improve transparency around maintenance schedules so residents can know when and where maintenance is due to occur in their neighbourhood, beginning with an immediate update to the way that mowing and street sweeping schedules are made public.
8. In 2024, request the Internal Ombudsman Shared Service (IOSS) conduct a 12-month review of customer service to determine what improvements have been made and where there are further opportunities. |
Background
Improving customer service has been a focus for Council over the course of this Council term. A Customer Service Committee has met monthly for 18 months, including representatives of the community, Council members and staff. Council staff are to be commended for the work they have done to date and there is much to build on. However there are also elements of service that can still be improved.
Internal training held to date has been focused on embedding a culture of service within the Council staff. Hundreds of staff have attended, and managers and supervisors have followed up to ensure that resident interactions are in line with this direction.
The Customer Service Charter on this agenda reflects these commitments, and the Customer Experience Strategy, which will come to the September meeting, will outline how Council will achieve the elements of the Charter. Particularly important elements of that Strategy have been outlined in the motion.
Further, a great deal of customer service interaction with Council, largely via the elected Councillors, is now taking place via social media. The Council’s customer service team needs to be present and active in that space - responding to residents, taking part in discussions, conducting online outreach and interacting with the community in the way that Councillors do every day.
The most successful element of the improved customer service program has been the increased outreach via stalls and forums. After experimenting with monthly and then fortnightly weekend outreach, it is clear that the stalls should be held weekly and rotate into spaces other than town squares and parks. At the same time, a mobile outreach service in a van can meet residents where they live, work, shop and socialise during the week, at shopping centres and train stations. A budget adjustment of $350k will be moved as an amendment to the Budget at the June meeting.
The DA Customer Service area, while commendably reducing the median time of determination to ~90 days (from above 100 days), still has work to do to ensure that proactive phone calls, empowered case management, face-to-face visits, reliable advice, and in particular consistent and accurate heritage advice is demonstrated.
IT work on the website and the service request system to take place over the next two years is budgeted, however, immediate improvement to some very specific elements of the website, such as the mowing and street sweeping schedule, need to be made immediately. Staff are asked to report back in September on the solution to out of date and inaccessible online schedules.
To ensure that the effort and investment in Customer Service is having the intended effect, the Internal Ombudsman, who is the receiver and arbiter of a range of customer service complaints, is asked to conduct a review of the service in 2024, two years after the improvement program began in earnest.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Emergency Services Levy increase
From: Councillor Pauline Lockie
MOTION
1. That the Mayor writes to the Treasurer, the Minister for Emergency Services, the Minister for Local Government and local Members: a) Expressing Council's strong opposition to the NSW Government's decision to impose an enormous Emergency Services Levy (ESL) cost increase on Councils for 2023/24, and for scrapping the Emergency Services Levy subsidy for Councils; b) Noting that as a consequence of the unannounced 73 per cent increase in the State Emergency Service budget and an 18 per cent increase in the Fire and Rescue NSW budget, Council's 3.7 per cent rate increase to provide essential community services and infrastructure has been significantly eroded; c) Advising that the NSW Government's decision may impact Council's ability to deliver important local services and necessary infrastructure in the long term; and d) Calling on the NSW Government to take immediate action to: i. Restore the Emergency Services Levy subsidy in 2023/24; ii. Urgently introduce legislation to decouple the Emergency Services Levy from the rate peg to enable Councils to recover the full cost (in future years); and iii. Develop a fairer, more transparent and financially sustainable method of funding critically important emergency services in consultation with local government.
2. That the Mayor also writes to the President of Local Government NSW seeking the Association's ongoing advocacy to bring about a relief in the burden of Councils' emergency services contribution.
3. That the General Manager writes to the Chair of the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) advising that Council's forced emergency services contribution is manifestly disproportionate to the 2023/24 rate cap, which has resulted in additional financial stress. |
Background
The Emergency Services Levy is a cost imposed on Councils and insurance policy holders to fund the emergency services budget in NSW. The majority is paid as part of insurance premiums, with a further 11.7 per cent funded by Councils and 14.6 per cent by the NSW Government.
In the 2019/20 financial year, legislative changes increased Councils' contribution to the Emergency Services Levy. In recognition that this change significantly impacted the financial sustainability of many Councils, the NSW Government has been providing "one-off" subsidies to offset these growing levies each year, which helped minimise the financial impacts to Councils.
The NSW Government’s recent decision to both substantially increase the Emergency Services Levy and withdraw subsidies for Councils is an unexpected cost hit that will eat into any Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART)-approved rate rise. Increases in rates will now have to be diverted to the significantly higher Emergency Services Levy payments this year.
Councils are already under massive financial pressure from the combined impact of the pandemic, extreme weather events, high inflation, and wage increases. The levy increase for the state’s 128 Councils in 2023/24 amounts to almost $77 million, with the total cost imposed on the local government sector increasing from $143 million in the current financial year to $219 million next year.
This represents a 53.1 per cent increase, completely dwarfing the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) baseline rate peg of 3.7 per cent for 2023/24.
For Inner West Council, the impact of the increased, unsubsidised levy is $1.7m for 2023/24 which is 29% of Council’s total contribution ($5.8m). This amounts to 38% of Council’s expected increase in rate income for 2023/24.
If the NSW Government’s decision is not reversed, over time this unfair increase will ultimately impact Council’s financial position, and our capacity to provide the services and infrastructure that our community requires.
The timing of the announcements by the NSW Government is particularly challenging for Councils as it comes so late in the local government budgeting cycle, well after IPART’s rate determination for the coming financial year, and after Councils have prepared their draft budgets for consultation with their communities.
Reporting suggests that the increase in costs this year reflects a 73 per cent increase in the State Emergency Service budget and an 18.5 per cent funding increase to Fire and Rescue NSW.
All Councils strongly support a well-funded emergency services sector and the critical contribution of emergency services workers and volunteers (many of whom are Councillors and Council staff). However, it is essential that these services be supported through an equitable, transparent, and sustainable funding model.
In line with Local Government NSW’s position on this matter, I am asking Council to call on the NSW Government to take immediate action to address this issue.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Webcasts
From: Councillor John Stamolis
MOTION
That Council look at ways to increase public accessibility and use of its webcasts for its Ordinary Council meetings and report back in September 2023. |
Background
Webcasts for Councils monthly Ordinary Council Meetings go back to 2017. These provide an important record of Council meetings as well as a means for residents to see how decision-making occurs.
Viewing levels for Ordinary Council meetings have never been high but recent data shows a trend decrease since the commencement of this current Council. More so, based on a 3 month moving average, viewing rates are now the lowest on record.
It might be useful to create a separate web page (accessible from the home page) to highlight the most recent meeting. Council may also consider creating a Key Topics page which links to items such as:
· Budget
· Policies and Plans
· Plans of Management
· Development and Rezoning
· Environment
· etc
For example, the ‘Budget’ topic could provide links to relevant webcasts items for the past 3 years. This will assist people to easily access items given that most people do not know when these items are debated or may not be familiar with Councils agenda.
Note: The chart below shows a 3 month moving average for the number of views of Councils webcasts for its Ordinary Meetings. For comparative purposes, where Council had two Ordinary meetings in a given month, the meeting with the higher number of views was selected for that month. A trendline (polynomial, order 3) is also shown.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Unoccupied Dwellings Rise by 35%
From: Councillor John Stamolis
MOTION
That Council investigate the stock of unoccupied dwellings in the Inner West and report initial data back by November 2023. |
Background
Inner West Council is experiencing a significant rise in unoccupied private dwellings … from 5,457 (7.6%) in 2011, 6,060 (8.1%) in 2016 to 8,152 (9.9%) in 2021.
The number of unoccupied private dwellings in the Inner West is now 35% higher than 5 years ago while the total number of private dwellings grew by 10% over that time.
Inner West Council currently has the fifth highest number of unoccupied dwellings (8,152) and the fifth highest rate of unoccupied dwellings (232 per square kilometre) of all Sydney Councils.
Three-quarters of unoccupied dwellings in the Inner West are in the following 10 suburbs.
Little is known about unoccupied dwellings and how these affect:
· housing affordability and house prices
· availability of rental stock and rent levels
· development quotas enforced on Councils by State Government
Clearly, a significant proportion of unoccupied dwellings have a logical reason for being empty such as households travelling for holidays or work, or dwellings being developed or renovated etc.
But what if a small proportion of these unoccupied dwellings could be returned to the housing market such as 5% to 10%. This would make 408 to 815 dwellings available across Inner West Council. Even 2%, is 160 dwellings!
During this housing affordability crisis, where rents are skyrocketing and where supply issues are critical, we need to look as broadly as possible at finding solutions.
State and Local Governments need to understand why a significant and growing proportion of housing stock is unoccupied and if there are incentives to get even a very small proportion of these back onto the housing market.
As a first step in understanding the stock of unoccupied dwellings across the Inner West, Council may consider requesting data from ABS showing the number of unoccupied dwellings by suburb by type of dwelling.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Support for Inner West organisations with anti-poverty and food relief programs
From: Councillors Councillor Pauline Lockie and Councillor Dylan Griffiths
MOTION
1. That Council notes the recent media reports about the increasing demand on anti-poverty and food relief programs run by Addison Road Community Organisation and the Rev. Bill Crews Foundation.
2. That Council notes data from Addison Road Community Organisation showing that 76% of people who could not afford to pay for low-cost groceries at Marrickville food pantry are in the Inner West local government area.
3. That Council notes the data provided by the Rev. Bill Crews Foundation outlining the dramatic surge in demand for its food relief and anti-poverty support services.
4. That Council notes the recent survey of 1,900 OzHarvest supported charities which found that 73% have reported an increase in demand in the past six months, and more than a third of their clients were seeking food relief for the first time.
5. That Council organises monthly meetings between Council officers and local anti-poverty organisations throughout FY23/24 to track community use of these services, and identify ways Council can assist with anti-poverty and food relief programs. These meetings will be reported back to Councillors via briefing notes or reports to Council.
6. That Council establishes $50,000 of grant funding, in the 23/24 FY budget, for local anti-poverty and food relief programs, such as those run by Addison Road Community Organisation and Bill Crews Exodus Foundation.
7. That Council writes to Premier Chris Minns and Treasurer Daniel Mookhey to advocate for urgent and ongoing funding for local anti-poverty and food relief programs in the NSW Budget that will be handed down on Tuesday 19 September.
8. That Council writes to the Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Treasurer Jim Chalmers to: a. Advocate for urgent and ongoing Federal funding for local anti-poverty and food relief programs; b. Reiterate Council’s support for the Australian Council of Social Service (ACOSS) Raise the Rate campaign, and its call to permanently and adequately increase income support payments.
|
Background
At its Ordinary Council meeting on 9 August 2022, Council unanimously supported an urgency motion on food security following a sharp rise in food theft and people seeking food relief in the Inner West. Since then, the cost of living crisis has worsened, and pressure on our local anti-poverty and food relief services continues to grow, with providers of these services reporting dramatic increases in demand.
Addison Road Community Organisation (Addi Road)
Addi Road is one of the main suppliers of food relief in the Inner West. It distributes free emergency food hampers to people in need and other not-for-profit organisations; sells low-cost groceries at its food pantries; and provides emergency food vouchers to provide free groceries to those who cannot afford to pay for food at its food pantries.
Demand for Addi Road’s food relief services has grown by more than 60% in less than a year, yet the organisation receives no government funding for these services. CEO Rosanna Barbero told ABC News in May that she “has never seen it this bad”, and noted that the cost of living crisis was seeing a new cohort of people turning to them for food relief: “We’re really entering into a crisis in the lower middle class and the middle class…that is frightening.”
Many of the people who are increasingly reliant on Addi Road for food live in the Inner West. 76% of people who needed emergency food vouchers to pay for groceries at the Marrickville food pantry between January and March this year were from the Inner West Council local government area. 80% received income support payments, highlighting yet again the urgent need to lift these payments to ensure everyone has enough to cover the basic necessities.
Rev. Bill Crews Foundation
The Rev. Bill Crews Foundation also provides direct food relief to people across the Inner West through the free meals provided at its Loaves & Fishes Free Restaurant in Ashfield and its food vans.
In the month of May, the Foundation supplied a total of 38,311 meals compared to 29,387 meals in April, an increase of 8,924 meals. This surge represents a 30% rise in demand, with an additional 288 meals being distributed each day when compared to the previous month. Their daily volume is now 1,240 meals per day.
The number of people seeking assistance has also witnessed a dramatic surge. In May alone, the Foundation assisted 20,116 people, compared to 18,111 in April and 14,128 in March. This amounts to an additional 2,000 individuals seeking support in just one month, equating to an average of 64 more people requiring assistance every day. Since March, they have seen an alarming increase of nearly 6,000 guests within a span of only two months.
Additionally, the number of hampers donated in May rose to 1,879, a significant increase from 1,556 in April and 1,548 in March. These numbers further highlight the escalating need for necessities within our community.
The Foundation has advised that its Social Health and Wellbeing team are unable to meet the increased need for services. They have provided over $12,000 to individuals for utility support since January 2023, and over $283,480 has been issued to support vulnerable individuals and families to sustain tenancies and for food security through vouchers. Its intake team, who respond to one of crisis appointments, currently have a 5 week waitlist.
Ahead of this year’s federal Budget, Rev Crews spoke about the rise in demand for the Foundation’s services: “It’s all day from breakfast to night. There are so many people struggling. Even people who have got jobs can’t earn enough to pay rent and all the other medical bills…we’ve morphed from feeding the homeless to feeding the hungry.”
Officer’s Comments:
Comment from Director Community:
Inner West Council allocates $560,000 annually across its Community grants programs. Officers are currently assessing the applications received for the 2023/2024 funding round. There are no additional funds available to allocate specifically to food relief as the Community grants budget will be fully expended. Council also provides “in-kind” support for many local not for profits and charities in support of their work. However, income support financial relief through vouchers, are the primary responsibility of the Commonwealth and State governments. Council regularly advocates on poverty related issues in policy and program forums in support of local organisations.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Making the Rainbow Tunnels Permanent
From: Councillor Pauline Lockie
MOTION
1. That Council notes the successful collaboration between Transport for NSW and Inner West Council that saw three rainbow lighting artworks installed in Transport for NSW-owned pedestrian tunnels in Newtown, Petersham and Ashfield during Pride Inner West and Sydney WorldPride.
2. That Council notes that these works were produced and funded by Transport for NSW as part of its reVITALise 2023 Creative Program and Safer Cities Program.
3. That Council notes that these artworks were created by local LGBTQIA+ artists and were extremely well-received by the community.
4. That Council notes that, since these artworks were deinstalled in April/May, there have been requests from the community for them to be reinstalled.
5. That Council asks the Mayor to write to the Minister for Transport to request that Transport for NSW works with Inner West Council to make the Rainbow Tunnel artworks permanent.
|
Background
Transport for NSW (TfNSW) recently collaborated with Inner West Council to install rainbow lighting artworks in three of its tunnels during Pride Inner West and Sydney WorldPride. These were:
· ‘Stars of Splatters’ by HOSSEI, Petersham pedestrian subway tunnel
· ‘Slipstream’ by Alexandra Jonscher and Andrew Christie, Ashfield Station pedestrian tunnel
· ‘1000 Kisses’ by Kieran Butler, Newtown pedestrian tunnel.
The Rainbow Tunnels project was part of TfNSW’s reVITALise program, which is trialling creative interventions to support long term best-practice placemaking, and its Safer Cities Program, which supports trials of place-based approaches to improving women, girls and gender diverse peoples’ safety within public spaces.
Each of the three Rainbow Tunnels was designed by a different local LGBTIQA+ artist, and were extremely well received by the community. While they were designed to be temporary, local residents have asked that they be made permanent.
Given these tunnels are owned by Transport for NSW, which funded the works, I am proposing that the Mayor writes to the Minister for Transport to raise this request.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Balmain Road/Orange Grove crossing
From: Councillor John Stamolis
MOTION
That Council renew the surface of the road crossing, along with the immediately adjacent footpath, from the Lilyfield shops to the Orange Grove School (i.e. across Balmain Road) as soon as possible.
|
Background
The crossing from the Lilyfield shops to Orange Grove Public School (across Balmain Road) is in a poor state.
This is a highly used crossing for the school, the markets and also to and from the shops.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Newtown Festival
From: Councillor Liz Atkins
MOTION
1. That Council note that the Newtown Neighbourhood Centre has announced that it will no longer hold a Newtown Festival. 2. That Council note that the suburb of Newtown is partly in the Inner West Council area, and partly in the City of Sydney Council area, with King Street being the border between the two Councils. 3. That Council note that the Inner West Council has a strong program of community festivals, some of which include main street closures. 4. That Council note the City of Sydney has a Sydney Streets program where major streets including high streets are closed once or twice a year to traffic, to celebrate neighbourhoods, and that the streets to be included in the annual program are selected following consultation.
5. That Council ask the Mayor to write to the Lord Mayor of the City of Sydney to discuss the possibility that a Sydney Streets closure could be held in Newtown, organised in coordination with the Inner West Council.
6. That Council staff to work with City of Sydney staff as necessary to ensure this happens, including to provide advice about benefits to the community and the local organisations, local businesses and communities that could be involved.
|
Background
In May this year Newtown Neighbourhood Centre (NNC) announced that they would no longer run the Newtown Festival. Over the last 40 years, the Festival experienced significant growth, with many more businesses, sponsors and people attending the event. This large-scale financial endeavour eclipsed the resources, capabilities and purpose of NNC.
The decision – which involved reviewing several possible funding scenarios and business cases, as well as community consultation – was not made lightly. Ultimately, the NNC board had to consider the role of the Festival in line with NNC’s core objectives: to strengthen the community through the provision of essential resources, support and care for those who need it most.
Not surprisingly many Inner West residents were disappointed, while acknowledging the strong program of other community festivals in the Inner West.
City of Sydney runs a festival program known as Sydney Streets which has a budget of around $2million p.a. The program has included the closure of major thoroughfares, e.g. Oxford Street. As yet it has not included King Street but it appears that an approach to the Lord Mayor to seek to have King Street included on an annual basis could be successful. The proposal has the support of the City of Sydney Deputy Mayor, Councillor Sylvie Ellsmore.
Officer’s Comments:
Council has worked closely with Newtown Neighbourhood centre following its decision not to continue to deliver the Newtown Festival. It is understood that the festival was running at a loss of up to $500k per annum. There have been high community expectations in relation to the festival overtime and these would need to be carefully managed in any decision to reactivate the King Street Precinct. There are no funds available in the Inner West Council events budget to support any new initiatives. In addition, staff time is committed to the existing calendar of events for 2023/2024.
This includes the live screening of the Mardi Gras parade and other
celebrations in Camperdown Rest Memorial Park in Newtown as well as Summerfest
in Enmore Park.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Good Neighbour Policy
From: Deputy Mayor Philippa Scott
MOTION
1. That Council expand the ‘Good Neighbour Policy’ beyond live music venues and licensed premises to include artistic, creative and sporting clubs and activities, and commercial and retail businesses, excluding construction businesses.
2. That Council staff bring back report on the regulatory implications of this course of action and a draft amended version of the policy to Council for approval.
|
Background
Council’s excellent Good Neighbour Policy requires that instead of immediately launching compliance or legal action when complaints are received about a live music venue, Council officers will mediate with complainants and venue operators to find solutions.
As a dense, mixed-use community, the Inner West also contains a range of other long standing hospitality, creative and sporting operators that are also adjacent to housing or other businesses. In the same way that the Good Neighbour Policy ensures the longevity of live music venues, the health and vitality of our commercial, sporting and hospitality precincts can also be protected by extending the policy to include them. It is intended that officers will first seek to mediate, and we will seek to limit the range of avenues through which complaints can be made.
Noting the particular sensitivity to construction operation, this sector is excluded from the intended extension of the policy.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: GreenWay Community Forum 2022/2023 Annual Report
From: Councillors Councillor Timothy Stephens and Councillor Dylan Griffiths
MOTION
1. That Council receive and note the GreenWay Community Forum 2022/23 Annual Report, provided as Attachment 1.
2. That Council thank the Greenway Community Forum for their work.
|
Background
Nil.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
1.⇩ |
Greenway Community Forum 2022/23 Annual Report |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Drag Story Time
From: Councillor Mathew Howard
MOTION
1. That Council work with Rainbow Families to present a drag story time event at an Inner West Council library in 2023-2024.
2. That Council fund the event through the existing LIbraries and Community Venues Budget.
3. That Council supports working together with community groups to make our LGBTQIA+ communities, kids, and families feel safer, connected, and supported.
|
Background
Drag story time events foster inclusion, promote literacy and are fun.
The Inner West is home to the largest concentrations of LGBTQ+ parented families in
Australia and drag story times are a positive, affirming way for diverse families to connect, celebrate and promote visibility and acceptance.
Importantly, drag story time events are an important way to encourage greater participation by LGBTQ+ parented families and the LGBTQ+ community in council’s library and cultural programming.
Rainbow Families is the peak organisation supporting LGBTQ+ parents and their children. As a charity, registered with the ACNC, Rainbow Families works to reduce discrimination and disadvantage faced by children of LGBTQ+ parents so they can thrive and shine and is a support network for parents and carers, as well as future parents and carers.
The purpose of Rainbow Families is to build a community that fosters resiliency by connecting, supporting and empowering LGBTQ+ parents and their children.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Trial of Extended Hours at Henson Park
From: Councillor Mathew Howard
MOTION
1. That Council trial extended hours at Henson Park in winter months, allowing lights to remain on until 9:00pm between July 1 and October 1, 2023.
2. That Council erect signage at Henson park and write to residents in streets surrounding Henson Park informing them of the trial and providing an avenue to provide feedback.
3. That Council provide a report to the December meeting evaluating the trial, including patronage, feedback from park users and nearby neighbours, and costs of implementing a permanent extension in future winters.
|
Background
Lighting Henson Park for extended hours at night during the winter months offers an opportunity to improve public health and safety for local park users.
A number of residents have raised concerns that the lack of lighting in winter months hampers opportunities for locals to exercise, walk dogs, participate in organised sport and passive recreation, as well as walk through our parks.
A trial offers an opportunity to assess the response of residents and park users and to further bolster the efforts of council to promote exercise and use of our parks.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Hawthorne Canal Multipurpose Courts
From: Deputy Mayor Philippa Scott
MOTION
1. That Council approve that the multipurpose sports courts on Hawthorne Parade, Haberfield be open and available for community use with lights on until 10pm year-round.
2. That Council advise any clubs that currently use the courts for training in the evening of the adjusted hours that the courts will be available to the community after training.
3. That Council vary the contract for closure and opening of the nearby Richard Murden Reserve toilet block to accommodate this use. If necessary, any further budget variation reported back to Council in the quarterly budget review in August 2023.
4. That Council write to the WestConnex authority and remind them of the continued issue of subsidence of the Hawthorne Canal multipurpose courts as the result of WestConnex construction and request that they repair the structural damage and replace the court surfaces.
|
Background
Residents wish to use the Hawthorne Canal multipurpose courts for casual and organised recreation in line with the allowed use of the surrounding netball and tennis courts, which immediately adjoin the multipurpose courts. This is a reasonable request which can be accommodated by extending the hours of the lights and nearby amenities.
However it should be noted that the major issue with Hawthorne Canal courts is not the lighting but continued subsidence which has led to an uneven, dangerous, substandard surface. The WestConnex authority, who have spent millions of dollars building a privatised motorway, should be required to compensate the community for the damage caused as the result of this project and return the surface to the standard provided by the Council to the community when it was first built in 2019.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Local Democracy Groups and Council Committees
From: Councillor Jessica D'Arienzo
MOTION
1. That the Terms of Reference for all Council internal Committees and Local Democracy Groups as listed below be amended to allow for online/hybrid attendance:
Internal Committees: ● General Manager’s Performance Assessment Panel; ● Customer Service Review Sub-Committee; ● Flood Management Advisory Committee; ● Local Traffic Committee; and ● Major Capital Projects Committee.
Local Democracy Groups: ● Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Advisory Committee; ● Access Advisory Committee; ● Arts and Culture Advisory Committee; ● Bicycle Working Group; ● Environment Advisory Group; ● Housing and Affordability Advisory Committee; ● LGBTQ Working Group; ● Multicultural Advisory Committee; ● Planning and Heritage Advisory Committee; ● Seniors Working Group; ● Social Strategy Advisory Committee; ● Transport Advisory Committee; and ● Young Leaders Working Group.
2. That Council replace the Mayor, Councillor Byrne with Deputy Mayor, Councillor Scott on the Major Capital Projects Committee until September 2024.
3. That Councillors' committee assignments be published online on their Councillor profile.
4. That Local Democracy Groups be provided with a short survey to provide feedback about their first year of operation.
5. That following feedback provided at the recent Local Democracy Group forum, the Terms of Reference, policy challenges and composition of the Planning and Heritage Advisory Committee be reviewed and updated by the Director, Communities and Director, Planning and brought back to Council for approval; and that should the revised composition require the appointment of new members, that the recruitment panel (Deputy Mayor Scott, Councillor D’Arienzo and Councillor Griffiths, supported by relevant Council officers) be reconvened to do so.
|
Background
Council’s Code of Meeting Practice allows for Councillors to attend and participate in Council
meetings by audio-visual link with the approval of the Council. Similarly, this Notice of Motion
proposes that all Council internal Committees and Local Democracy Groups allow for hybrid
attendance.
Council’s recent forum for Local Democracy Groups provided value feedback to the Council, and further views of the groups should be sought via a short survey. The feedback also presents the opportunity to revisit the Terms of Reference and composition of the groups should it be required.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Community Support for FIFA Women's World Cup
From: Councillor Jessica D'Arienzo
MOTION
1. That Council notes the FIFA Women's World Cup 2023 is being hosted by Australia and New Zealand between 20 July - 20 August 2023 and Council intends to broadcast Matildas games on big screens at multiple locations.
2. That Council notes that the Inner West has a strong local football community and our local sporting grounds have proudly hosted previous Matilda matches.
3. That Council engages our local football clubs and co-ordinates local messages of support for the Matildas.
4. That Council co-ordinates a public wall of support to collect messages of support from the local community.
5. That following the World Cup, the local messages of support be converted into a permanent artwork at a suitable location.
6. That Council fund the project for an amount up to $12,000 to be allocated from the 2023/2024 Perfect Match budget
|
Background
We want football fans across the Inner West to share in the exciting build up to next month’s FIFA Women’s World Cup 2023.
The Matildas' first kick-off is against the Republic of Ireland on 20 July in Sydney and the Inner West Council has committed to live screenings of the Matildas' games at 3 sites across the LGA.
Now we invite you to contribute to our Matildas wall of support. It's an opportunity for communities across our LGA to unite in their love of football and celebrate the upcoming FIFA Women’s World Cup tournament.
It's our Inner West way to inspire and spotlight future female football talent, build excitement and increase support.
In addition, we acknowledge and welcome the recent announcement by the Minister for Sport, Steve Kamper, that a further $3.23 million was available to football clubs, associations and councils under Round 2 of the NSW Football Legacy Fund for new and upgraded football facilities and participation programs.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Cumulative effect of Additional Equipment for Telecom Towers
From: Councillor Marghanita Da Cruz
MOTION 1. That Council receive a briefing note about proposals for Telecom Towers in our LGA and the regulatory framework. 2. That Council write to the Minister for Telecommunications, copying local federal members, that our residents have concerns about the initial and cumulative radiation from these towers being placed in our densely populated LGA and to advise what Radiation Safeguards are in place regarding ensuring the cumulative radiation effect of the additional equipment and community consultation are met. |
Background
Council has received applications from Telecommunication Companies to install Towers in our LGA.
Council can only assess the visual impacts of the Towers, not the radiation from the initial equipment being installed on the Towers or cumulative radiation from any additional equipment which is installed in the future.
'Phone towers and base stations When telcos want to build or install new equipment near you, there are rules they must follow. '
https://www.acma.gov.au/phone-towers-and-base-stations
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Notice of Motion: Henson Park Lighting
From: Councillor Justine Langford
MOTION
1. That Council note there is no lighting in the dog off-leash area of Henson Park Oval at night.
2. That Council note that residents wish to safely use the off-leash dog area of an evening, especially during Winter and through daylight savings.
3. That Council investigate lighting the dog off-leash area of Henson Park Oval of an evening to improve safety and amenity for dog walkers and residents who want to use the park for exercise at night. |
Background
Members of the Henson Park dog community have contacted ward Councillors and Council staff, requesting that lighting be left on of an evening to facilitate safe dog walking after hours. Lack of lighting is of particular concern over Winter and during daylight savings.
Henson Park dog off-leash area is a much loved and regularly used facility that is important for dogs and a valuable social outlet for dog owners. There's a great community around it, including an active Facebook group. Residents really appreciate having Henson Park nearby. It's a great community facility for active recreation. They want to use it safely throughout the year.
Most afternoons there are 50+ residents with dogs using the space. The lighting on the grassed areas used by dogs and owners is very limited. When the oval lights are on it's quite bright. But usually there are just a couple of lights on the side of the toilet block at the Woodland Street entrance. Without lighting, it's dangerous to walk on the grass at night because of the slope and uneven surfaces. It's often slippery after rain too. In the early mornings it is even more unsafe. The lack of lighting makes it difficult to check who else is in the park and how they are acting.
Local residents do walk their dogs around the streets at night – but the point of off-leash areas is that dogs can run about and play with other dogs, something which is obviously forbidden on the streets and it’s something which is important for dogs’ wellbeing.
The Henson Park Plan of Management and master plan does provide support for lighting upgrades to improve safety, and to extend the hours that the park can be used. It is understood that these works are still to be fully scoped, planned, and budgeted for. In the meantime, residents are asking for a solution to light the park at night.
Officer’s Comments:
No further comments were required for this Notice of Motion.
ATTACHMENTS
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Clontarf Cottage
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Clontarf Cottage is a wonderful community venue situated on the Balmain Peninsula. It is used for many social events, club meetings and for community purposes, and has been since its restoration more than 33 years ago. It was home to the Balmain/White Bay Residents Precinct Committee.
Clontarf Cottage was saved from demolition in the early 1980s by local residents after a lengthy campaign. It was then managed by the voluntary Clontarf Cottage Management Committee which was disbanded after the commencement of Inner West Council.
After years of campaigning, salvaging, preservation and restoration led by local residents, and taking into account its wide use, it is vital that Clontarf Cottage receives due attention from Council.
Question
What amount of funds was allocated to Clontarf Cottage since the commencement of Inner West Council? Please specify on a yearly basis.
Answer
Question
What were these funds to be used for?
Answer
The annual operating budget covers ongoing maintenance of the Property, Utilities and depreciation.
The previous capital budget was for a potential project to improve landscaping, lighting, storage, kitchen facilities, wheelchair access / bathroom facilities.
Question
Have these funds been reallocated by Council for other uses? If so, when were these funds reallocated and where are these funds now?
Answer
The capital budget was reallocated as part of the response to the COVID-19 pandemic through the quarterly budget review process for essential infrastructure renewals.
Question
What consultation occurred in regard to any reallocation to the budget in regard to Clontarf Cottage
Answer
All budget adjustments must be undertaken through the Quarterly Budget Review Statement (QBRS) process, which is tabled for Council consideration and adoption each quarter.
Question
What is the budget allocation for Clontarf Cottage over the next 5 years and what are these funds to be used for?
Answer
There is an ongoing operational budget in future years to continue to maintain the property, to cover operating costs and for depreciation of the asset.
The Access Advisory Committee (one of Council’s Local Democracy Groups) will work with Council staff to consider the prioritisation of accessibility requirements for capital projects across council sites, including Clontarf Cottage. This will be supported by the provision of asset condition reports which are being completed for Council buildings as part of the asset revaluations required for the 2022/23 financial statements.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Update on Affordable Housing
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
Question
Please provide the following information.
What was is the stock of affordable housing dwellings held by Inner West Council?
Question
How many of these affordable housing dwellings will be affordable housing in perpetuity and what period remains on those dwellings which will not be affordable housing in perpetuity?
Question
Where are these dwellings located (e.g. 3 x Marrickville, 2 x Dulwich Hill etc)
Question
What are the current rent levels?
Question
What are the tenancy durations? (i.e. is turnover high?)
Question
What proportion are occupied by key workers and what are these occupations?
Question
What numbers of new affordable housing stock is Council expecting over each of the next 2 years? - 2024, 2025
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Dwelling Targets
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
Question
What are the current dwellings targets set by the Department of Planning (or Greater Cities Commission) for each of the city Councils? Please specify the duration of these targets i.e. 1 year, 3 year, 5 year or other.
Question
Are these targets set in consultation with Councils? How is this done?
Question
Can these dwelling targets be supplied by suburb for the Inner West?
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Quality of Pedestrian Crossings
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
The quality of pedestrian crossings across the Inner West ranges from excellent to poor. Those which are poor can be due to a highly eroded paint surface, the surface paving becoming uneven … or both.
It would be appreciated if the following questions could be answered:
Question
What State or Local agency sets the standards for pedestrian crossings?
Question
Once installed is there a monitoring and maintenance schedule and/or checking of pedestrian crossings? What does this involve?
Question
Who funds the maintenance of pedestrian crossings?
Question
Who does the work in relation to improvement of pedestrian crossings?
Question
How much has been budgeted for pedestrian crossings in the Inner West for each year over the past 5 years (please include all funding - State and Local)?
Question
How much has been budgeted for pedestrian crossings for the next two years?
Question
Please include any other summary information that would assist Councillors and the public to understand issues relating to the quality of pedestrian crossings?
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Council Flyer “We are about Respect”
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
There has been mixed reaction to Councils flyer “We are about Respect”. This flyer is at libraries, aquatic centres and Council service centres.
It would be appreciated if the following questions could be answered.
Question
What has prompted the need to produce this flyer?
Question
Who approved this flyer for release?
Question
Can Council supply data (for each of the past 5 years) in relation to the number of 'customer incidents' that are covered within the scope of the flyer?
Question
Can Council supply data as to the number of customers who have been refused service by Council over each of the past 5 years?
Question
Can Council supply data as to the number of customers banned (temporary and permanent) from Customer Service Centres over each of the past 5 years?
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Aquatic Centres
From: Councillor Kobi Shetty
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
There have been several concerns raised about timetabling changes, room changes and instructor changes at Inner West Council Aquatic Centres.
Question
What factors are taken into consideration when making timetable or instructor changes to fitness classes, including gym and aqua classes?
Question
What consultation is undertaken with staff and members before timetable or instructor changes are made?
Question
What factors are considered when classes are moved to a different room in the gym?
Question
Please detail those occasions in the last 18 months that proposed timetable or instructor changes have not gone ahead due to members feedback?
Question
When members make complaints about timetable changes, room changes or changes to
instructors, what is the process that is undertaken to review those complaints and to engage
with members?
Question
Please provide half yearly membership numbers and class attendance at each centre: LPAC, AKAC and AAC from December 2021.
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Question on Notice: Fleet Transition
From: Councillor John Stamolis
Comment by the General Manager:
Answers to the questions will be provided at an Ordinary Council meeting in August 2023.
It would be appreciated if the following questions could be answered.
Question
Please provide data for the table below - showing the total number of vehicles in each category. (If Council already has more meaningful categories than those below, please use those instead.)
Question
Where does Council hope to be in 3 years time in terms of its fleet transition?
Question
What EV charging infrastructure exists currently for Inner West Council?
Question
How might the Federal Government fuel efficiency standard impact on Councils fleet transition plan?
Nil.
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Update on the Acquisition of Investment Properties
Prepared By: Scott Mullen - Strategic Investments and Property Manager
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report. |
DISCUSSION
Council will move into closed session to deal with the Update on Acquisition of Investment Properties, for information which is classified as confidential under Section 10A(2)(d)(c) and Section 10A(2)(d)(ii) of the Local Government Act 1993. The matter is deemed confidential, as the matter is commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business and, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council.
Pursuant to section 10A(2), 10(2) and 10A(3) of the Local Government Act 1993, the media and public will be excluded from the meeting on the basis that the business to be considered is classified as confidential under section 10A(2)(d)(c) and (Section 10A(2)(d)(ii) of the Local Government Act 1993.
Update on purchase of investment property June 23 - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business; AND commercial information of a confidential nature (Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it; AND commercial information of a confidential nature (Section 10A(2)(d)(ii) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council. |
|
EY Initial DD Report V12 - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Quarterly Strategic Investment Property Report
Prepared By: Scott Mullen - Strategic Investments and Property Manager
Authorised By: Kelly Loveridge - Director Corporate
RECOMMENDATION
That Council receive and note the report.
|
DISCUSSION
Council will move into closed session to deal with the Quarterly Strategic Investment Property Report, for information which is classified as confidential under Section 10A(2)(d)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993. The matter is deemed confidential, as the matter is commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business.
Pursuant to section 10A(2), 10(2) and 10A(3) of the Local Government Act 1993, the media and public will be excluded from the meeting on the basis that the business to be considered is classified as confidential under section 10A(2)(d)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993.
Confidential Report - Quarterly Strategic Investment Property Report - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business. |
|
Management Report April 2023 - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business. |
|
Financial Reports April 23 - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business. |
|
June Aged Debtors Report - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business. |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: HJ Mahoney Memorial Park & Tempe Reserve Playing Surface Upgrades
Prepared By: Morna Scott - Capital Projects Manager
Authorised By: Ryann Midei - Director Infrastructure
RECOMMENDATION
That Council adopt the recommendation contained in the Confidential Attachment 1.
|
DISCUSSION
Council allocated a budget in the 23/24 Capital Works program to upgrade the HJ Mahoney Memorial Park and Tempe Reserve Playing Surface. These upgrade works are consistent with the recommendations in the IWC Sporting Grounds Condition Report (January 2022) and IWC Playing Surface upgrade program.
The scope of works includes the laser grading of the playing surface, installation of sub-surface field drainage, field irrigation upgrade and change of turf grass species (Tempe Reserve - Sub-surface field drainage works only).
On the 20 April 2023, Council went out to public tender through Vendor Panel for the HJ Mahoney Memorial Park and Tempe Reserve Playing Surface upgrades. Tenders closed on 12 May 2023.
Subject to the adoption of the tender, construction works are scheduled to commence at HJ Mahoney Memorial Park and Tempe Reserve in September 2023 with completion in March 2024.
Tenders were evaluated in accordance with Council’s Purchasing Policy and Procedures and the Local Government Act 1993 and Local Government (General) Regulations 2021.
The Tender Report including the Evaluation Committee’s report and discussion is attached as Confidential Attachment 1.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
As noted in the confidential report
HJ Mahoney and Tempe Reserve Playing Surface Upgrade Tender Recommendation Report - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to information (Section 10A(2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business; AND commercial information of a confidential nature (Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it. |
Council Meeting 20 June 2023 |
Subject: Henson Park Development Agreement
Prepared By: Matthew Pearce - General Counsel
Authorised By: Peter Gainsford - General Manager
RECOMMENDATION
That Council adopt the recommendation in Confidential Attachment 1. |
DISCUSSION
Council will move into closed session to deal with the Henson Park Development Agreement, for information which is classified as confidential under Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993. The matter is deemed confidential, as the matter is commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed, prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it.
Pursuant to section 10A(2), 10(2) and 10A(3) of the Local Government Act 1993, the media and public will be excluded from the meeting on the basis that the business to be considered is classified as confidential under Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993.
1.⇩ |
Henson Park Report – Confidential
|
AFL letter of Support - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to commercial information of a confidential nature (Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it. |
|
Development Agreement - Confidential This attachment is confidential in accordance to commercial information of a confidential nature (Section 10A(2)(d)(i) of the Local Government Act 1993) that would, if disclosed prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it. |